Joyel thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
I have noticed that the same family structure of Mrs.kaushik paanch bahuein is also utilised in HHSJH.Lovely character in MKPB is similar to Sona in HHSJH,who is also a working housewives but concentrates more on homeworks.Another one bahu Ria speaks english frequently like Renu in HHSJH.Again another bahu Gehna does all the works in the house just like Neelam bhabhi.Nimmi bahu in MKPB is also interested in fashions like one bahu in HHSJH.In MKPB there is only 5 housewives but in HHSJH only 4 housewives.Each serial has a strict mother in law too.Husbands in both serials are under the guidelines of their wives,except Neelam bhabhi.Kanaya character is a police officer in HHSJH and Shibu character is also a police officer in MKPB.
Edited by Joyel - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.3k

Users

9

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

Sonali.S thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Joyel it is not so. If the characters are being made then the characterization is done by thinking something. Those who work on developing these characters always take care that their should be no similarity with other shows characters...those people r always intelligent as they run their shows which gets them popularity and a position to the serial and characters depicts everything related to the show...u should give time to serial before doing such analysis.

And please joyel i request you not to take the name of other serials as it can create a rift between 2 forums...and also it is against the rules of IF
caribbeanchica thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I totally agree with joyel.N im sorry if another serial has to come into play if the analyis is to made by a person's perception..we do have freedom of speech..and we are entitled to our opinios... but its the same with the job description a police officer ...
caribbeanchica thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: sonali.singh

Joyel it is not so. If the characters are being made then the characterization is done by thinking something. Those who work on developing these characters always take care that their should be no similarity with other shows characters...those people r always intelligent as they run their shows which gets them popularity and a position to the serial and characters depicts everything related to the show...u should give time to serial before doing such analysis.

And please joyel i request you not to take the name of other serials as it can create a rift between 2 forums...and also it is against the rules of IF

n please sonali.sing im requesting u please use some sense and logical judgement before requesting others by seeing if there is really a rift between the 2 forums...so im requesting u sonali.sing can u provide miss joyel with the evidence and proof of the rift her allegedly rift dividing post caused????Please i REQUEST YOU😆😆😆😆
GunDaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: caribbeanchica

n please sonali.sing im requesting u please use some sense and logical judgement before requesting others by seeing if there is really a rift between the 2 forums...so im requesting u sonali.sing can u provide miss joyel with the evidence and proof of the rift her allegedly rift dividing post caused????Please i REQUEST YOU😆

Yes it can create fights between the Forum ,as according to this post ,some might say that this serial is copycat of that serail or what and that's where the fight starts,. don't know much about rules ,but mentioning the name of the other show and comparing it is against the IF rules . Comparing is strictly prohibited ,i request you to go through IF COC once .Peoples are not allowed to compare serials here ,and creates an necessarily Havoc in this peaceful Forum.

@Bold Sonali is an Engineer and she knows where to use sense and give judgements ,and she knows the meaning of RIFT , COMPARE etc and she has thoroughly gone through the rules.😊


so just chill , leave this issue here ,Have a Nice day.



VishaD. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
The show have just started and why would Zee allow another show with the same story with their current show? Plus, comparing two shows are not allowed, so kindly refrain from doing so 😊
Dovebird thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
@PiE-ChUcKeR_AmI@sonali-singh,I have seen u guys commenting on Rukjananahi(RJN) here.And also u always discuss about Indu singh(AD) instead of Kanaiyaa character here.U should only discuss about the current character of the actor and not the previous character.If Joyel brings a good post with a strong evidence of the show,why u not appreciate him.Instead u treated him with the rules of IF.I thing u also not obeying the rules of IF.
Sonali.S thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
carribean and dovebird...first of all i want to tell u that there are no harsh issues and joyel is a very gud friend of mine. He always takes part in the forum and always brings something new to discuss just like he brought a gud discussion of neelam bhabhi. He knows it very well what i will say will be only for his best and he appreciates it. He even edited the topic and thanks my frnd joyel for it. I never want that his thread too gets locked like the one locked yesterday when the name of AD's old show was used...that was not wrong and everyone must follow IF rules and why to blame me and the developers of the show. Its not about one show. The people making shows r not fools and no need to proove it as whole tv industry knows it and u should too...what will u do carribean when members from MKKPB will come and start talking bad about joyel and the show. Will u come that time to stop them by giving explainations...i will definately come but not to encourage them but to stop them and say sorry from my friend's side. ...Please i request do not compare the characters and enjoy your respective shows

And joyel please edit your last line. It can hurt any of the housewife and MKKPB members who so have their shows and tracks...sorry joyel if i am saying so but it is for your benefit.
Sonali.S thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
dovebird...as for as my convo on AD's appeciation thread...yes i do it there and for doing it i have taken the permission from the thread opener and my request u can see on page 1 on the AT . Can u tell me any other place where i have talked about his previous show. If so then by now my account would have been banned or my thread would have been locked. And its the appreciation thread of AD and actors are known by their acting and their roles only. Ya he is kanhaiyya too and we also talk about him. Its the AD and we do what should be done there, the actors appreciation and just wanted to share one thing. Day before yesterday i started talking general thinks there and amit made me realize it and its against IF rules so i edited all my comments there from page 13 to 15 and u can see it there...the AT is for aniruddh and he is actor so we can talk about his roles and not only us but u can see that even suhasi's last role discussions r being made in her AD which is not wrong...and it is your IF who takes the decision to lock forum after the shows r over...where to talk with friends about the last show then. We r humans, can't keep anything forever in our heart and always desire to share with our friends...every thread is for a respective convo like Nach baliye thread for suhasi and AT thread for appreciation of actors...its not wrong if a thread for nach baliye is being made as i said we r humans who can't keep anything and so their r no issues in forum. It was all happygoing...everyone cheers their own jodi ..if i am doing at a right thread then what is wrong in it???
Sonali.S thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
and dovebird if anyone will say to me that why i am talking about the previous shows in the AD thread then i will definately ask them why they make a rule to lock forums after 3 months and should provide and convince my friends to come there and listen to my verdict when the forum is still unlocked. Ask them why after ending of serial one gets so busy and takes part only in the new forum. Then how to tell what is in my heart when i think of my previous show. I am not a god and have feeling too.

If again i will be questioned then i will ask to lock my account forever because for me right is right even before my friends...i hope u will understand.

No issues and please be happy ...thanku

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".