pia - success in relationships?? analysis

SIKinLoVE thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
*PIA* my analysis - cuz im bored 🤔🤔 - i think pia has been one character on screen that has not been able to ful fill any relationship sucessfully..any relationship - she's just.. im sorry but she "according to me" is a desgrace to women hood

every women/grl has these relationships in her life.. does that make sense...ahem fo instane - we discussing pia

Daughter - pia and if she's been a good daughter is kinda hard to answer as their momz was neva around and their father was a drunkard...

Sister- has pia been a good sister - nooooooooo and helllllllllll nooooooooooo.. i mean she says it a lot.. that she respects and luvs her "di" but has she eva been succesful is respecting and luving her di.. pia has been the MAIN reason till date as to y bani cries a lot
- took d man bani had d cutest crush on (pushkar)
- betrayed pushkar - went afta jai (fo his money) - even when bani thought jai wasn't the right man fo her sister -- cuz of his age.. but agreeed anyway fo her sister's happiness
- left jai at d mandap fo her "luv" pushkar - betrayed and left bani stranded in a tough situation once again
- ruined bani's life as she's the one who had to marry jai -- forcebly
- cried crocolide tears fo her sister
- bani went thru HELL to get pushy/pia married
seriously i could go on - but there's alot of reasons y bani was alwayz in tears/ or feeling horrible and d main reason behind that is pia
- did she eva worry bout her sister.. wat her sister mite be feelin. u know d whole "bani neva told pia she luved mr. walia".. knowin bani - any grl would guess.. that bani's d kind who will luv her hubby even afta wat she went thru.. cuz that's BANI.. but pia failed to understand that and i dont think bani wanted to waste her time tellin pia.. and i think bani's more "friendly" wit rano on that level.. cuz bani told rano she luved (luvs) mr. walia. cuz they have an understandin they share
btw how many times did pia ask bani for money.. i think a lil too many times - once when jai was gonna give her d "blue" sari - u know june 19th.. thats when she gave d money to pia.. and then fo her operation.. again it was bani.. pia's just NOT d best example of a good sister

WIFE
- good wife/loyal wife - unh unh.. nope.. we all saw these past episodes... nothin loyal and good bout her
- she called pushkar a loser and compared him to the man she left at the mandap now that's just painful.. but that's pia
- did pia ever try to be a good wife - u know wake up on time.. make her hubby some breakfast or somethin - nahhhhhhhh (if u notice.. they did concentrate on this a lot in d show.. as pia neva succeded)
- was she eva UNDERSTANDING fo d fact that her hubby doesn't have a million dollar job. won't find one.. again cuz of PIA.. cuz of JW's revenge.. stillll she bugged him bout money.. expensive this expensive that - pea brain
- did she eva try to save her hubby's money - NOPE.. cuz she was alwayz busy buyin d best stuff fo her apartment
- did she eva try to be sweet and nice to her in-laws FOR the sake of her husband (who luvs his family) NOPE
but pia became one of those wives who take the husband away from his family - rememba how they moved out -cuz she literall forcedd pushkar to

jiju/sali let's NOT go there.. cuz this is d time when im ready to make her head disappear from her shoulders

daughter-in-law pia a good daughter in law - i THINK NOT.. i mean.. she could neva respect seema bhabhi - who i must say i luvv - cuz she TOLD pia i mean she TOLD pia..i mean the only thing pia did was complain about her in-laws to pushkar when he came home from work
- looking at seema bhabhi - u know alwayz in d kitchen - doin her things.. u can tell by lookin at them.. they're that typical indian family u know - daughter-in-laws take care of d house work. everyone eats together, enjoys together - spend a little.. if not a lot.. family time together - when pia came. pushy was no where near his family.. cuz pia was alwayz creating a hungama in their house

mother ok fine she wasn't ready to have a baby.. understandable..but don't she DARE use the word "financial problems".. unh unh.. when u spendin alllllll the money ur hubby's workin hard for.. on expensive home things.. obviously u gonna have financial problems when it comes to saving money for ur baby.. she should've told pushkar - im pregnant NOT ready to have a baby - a healthy hubby/wife discussion is a good way to go - not.. ignore this and don't tell ur husband and just go get an abortion..that's just shameful

am i missing any relationship??? cuz so far pia has NOT ... i mean HAS NOT fulfilled any relation ship wit trust.. wit everythin that's suppose to be in a realtionship.. i can't believe i wrote all this down.. but i just had to.. we're all women here - well MOST of us r.. we all share or will share these relationships wit someone in d future.. if not now (mainly d In-laws).. but pia pia pia.. haye ram.. and im sure there are women like that in this world.. and that's wat shockssss me.. that' just more pea brains 🤢 i mean how ekta portray such a character.. HORRIBLE

so if anyone EVA feels sorry fo pia - i feel sorry for YOU.. cuz hell.. i ain't feelin sorry fo pia.. ever

p.s. sorrry if i bored u guyz.. i know it got a bit WAY TOO long 😆 😆 i had a lot to say
Edited by nyzbabigyal - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

1.6k

Users

14

Frequent Posters

goldilocks02 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
hi,
it is a nice post. and good observations. pia, the peabrain never ever did satisfy her in laws that way. she never made herself acceptable to her inlaws. also she always tried to seperate her husband from them.

and knowing bani- it was very clear that she would always love the man who is her husband. why did pia never realise this??amazing !!

and also pia was supposed to be in love with pushkar so much thats he dared to leave jai at the mandap. but the important question is did she ever love pushkar at all ?
for that matter does people like pia ever love anyone so much so that they will be ready to sacrifice for there loved ones ????


Edited by goldilocks02 - 18 years ago
Affay thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Good analysis Navs! You're right on the ball with this one! It's funny how she is so different from her other two sisters..but I must say Roshni Chopra is doing a fabulous job portraying this character! I always think those vamps we hate the most are truly amazing at what they do if we hate them that much! I was just thinking the other day, that if I were an actress, and if I were in Roshni Chopra's shoes, I'd get really emotional hearing all the negativitiy against me, and I'd take it personal (but that's just cuz I'm a suck) 😆 She should feel proud of all that hatred everyone has for Pia cuz she's really doing a fabulous job portraying her!
ruma thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
what was peabrain saying in yestertodays episode -that after that one night stand jai walia has become her life. 🤢 get a life pia, you never loved him, you just want his money 🤢
lazy_mariyum thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
no she just loves to be fashionable poor pushkar and now jai i dont know how many people is she going to trap now 😡
SK_ji thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
wowww veryy good told, but i hope u hate PIA but not roshni chopra cuz the way she acts is very good and she is kinda beautiful
SIKinLoVE thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: soniajhee

wowww veryy good told, but i hope u hate PIA but not roshni chopra cuz the way she acts is very good and she is kinda beautiful

i got nothin against roshni chopra - she's obviously doin mindblowin cuz i hate pia so much.. im just talkin bout pia.. pia dixit.. pia shukla - wateva her character name is.. pia.. not roshni
LavZ thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
AGREE WITH U COMPLETELY!!! 😉 I WD SAY ROSHNI HAS DONE FULL JUSTICE TO THE ROLE JUST LIKE ASHWINI(WHO POTRAYS JIGS)N RAKSHANDA(ROSHNI BUT WE C VERY LITTLE OF HER THESE DAYS!! 😉 )LOOK AT THE WAY WE HATE THESE CHARACTERS ISNT THAT ENOUGH TO SAY HOW MUCH THESE PPLE HAV DONE TO BRING THE CHARACTER TO LIFE??? 😛

ABT PIA 🤢 N HER RELATIONSHIP.... 😕 ITS BETTER IF WE DONT DISCUSS ABT IT,SHE KEEPS ON CALLING PUSHY A LOSER I WD SAY THAT SHE IS THE BEST FOR THAT TITLE!!! 😆 SHE HAS FAILED IN FULFILING ANY RELATIONSHIP FOR THAT MATTER BE IT SIS,WIFE,SIS IN LAW,DAUGHTER IN LAW OR ANY OTHER!!! 😔

JIYA
AnitaRathore thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
The problem I have with your idea is that you seem to only think that the way to understand Pia is through her relationships with others ...

Doesn't a woman have a right to be her own person - regardless of her relationships - as a wife, sister, mother ...?

ie: remember the time when Rano was in the accident and Pia went to do the photoshoot to get money for the hospital ? What about the fact that she is really good at what she does with Jai's company? what about the fact that she is a confident, beautiful, knows-what-she-wants type individual? I wonder why Indian serials always show this type of person as the 'bad' woman -

In comparison - if talk about Jai Walia, his descriptors include, confident, good buisness man, stable, in control ... etc... why don't we talk about the women of this show in this way???
SIKinLoVE thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: AnitaRathore

The problem I have with your idea is that you seem to only think that the way to understand Pia is through her relationships with others ...

Doesn't a woman have a right to be her own person - regardless of her relationships - as a wife, sister, mother ...?

ie: remember the time when Rano was in the accident and Pia went to do the photoshoot to get money for the hospital ? What about the fact that she is really good at what she does with Jai's company? what about the fact that she is a confident, beautiful, knows-what-she-wants type individual? I wonder why Indian serials always show this type of person as the 'bad' woman -

In comparison - if talk about Jai Walia, his descriptors include, confident, good buisness man, stable, in control ... etc... why don't we talk about the women of this show in this way???

u see that's coool. i mean pia is/ has that confidence of a women - who knows wat she wants - but the WAY she gets is painfully wrong.. yes i know wit her job in JW's company is going great.. she's doin a good job.. everyone's happy wit her work.. but its her other intensions that r just 🤢 that's y i didn't mention her "work" criteria - cuz in that sense.. she's doin great.. she's a "i wanna do this" and she'll do it.. i respect that about pia.. a lot.. and as fo her right to be her own person - that's cool. be urself no harm in that.. but don't harm the ones who r urs.. just to achieve ur goals.. and pia has high dreams..and she's just not concerned bout how the others around her r treated.. when it comes to her goals/her achievements

if she knew she wanted to be somethin in her life.. she should've planned her life more accurately - as that's wat ppl do in todays' world..u just cant change ur mind 24/7 AGAIN AND AGAIN.. and expect the results u want. and that's wat pia's doing.. even in today's world everyone has d right to do wat they want - to dream big - like pia.. but u still have to look at the circumstances around u.. and then continue.. not ignore everyone/everythin around u and just go ahead and do wateva u want and accept the results to be according to you.. the way u want 'em.. no no no

they don't show "confident" women - like d way u said... as "bad" one in indian serials - its just when ur part of an indian culture - MORE is expected from u.. feel free to do wat u want.. just don't forget u have family.. its just there are CERTAIN rules u have to follow.. u just can't change urself. and expect the world to change wit u.. its just somethin u have - every culture has their own values.. and indian culture has its down - so if a grl can't fulfill her "sanskar".. its just.. considered - u know.. its just u have to abide by all d rules..
Edited by nyzbabigyal - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".