Most Ridiculous Reality Music Show...

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Rani

@April2007

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: DiviNitya

That crying thing was a shocker!! I was suprised n didnt understand or awhile why Abida ji crying also coz couldnt figureout what went so wrong but knowing reason shez crying or her songs was v weird!! I felt Atif just instigated her too!!! But what kinda judge or grownup would think that way, she should b encouraging the contestants they did good but can do better by giving pointers!!! Worse is after all that fiaso of raging atif speech n abida ji broke down, next when its time to give points both Runa ji & Asha ji gave 10 & 10 n said they liked performance.. Lol atif was fuming seeing that haha!!! Actually manytimes sara n indrani attempted asha ji n lata ji sings but she just enourage them n give marks for avg performnce too naa, just an example!! Isme religion wali baat yaa disrespect wali bast kaha hai muhje nahi samajme aaya!! Infact its a compliment, she should have appreciated it even more han if pki would have sung it! Poor buddha he got scared n was clueless what he did wrong that made Abida ji cry like tht but seeing other judges marks he might have understood l8r! Yeah he said sorry for no fault!

As a result of Abida's crying Buddha got zero from her and at last minute Indian team had change their songs selection.

I think it is wrong for anybody to think that if they sing a sufi song they own the song and only they and they way they interpret song is the true way of singing it. Sufi songs are written by great Sufi's like Bullay Shah and many other sufi's..why did Abida thinks that only she can do justice to them, this is very selfish attitude..not Sufi like at all, very egoistic behavior..I wouldn't be able to listen to her music without thinking about this incident..she is very narrow minded, Sufism has not touched her, one would hope sufism makes people generous.

You are right that Atif seem to encourage her and went to console her because Buddha sang her song and it hurt her so much..maybe Buddha did well and she felt very threatened.

Edited by April2007 - 12 years ago

Quote

mtar3

@mtar3

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: April2007

As a result of Abida's crying Buddha got zero from her and at last minute Indian team had change their songs selection.

I think it is wrong for anybody to think that if they sing a sufi song they own the song and only they and they way they interpret song is the true way of singing it. Sufi songs are written by great Sufi's like Bullay Shah and many other sufi's..why did Abida thinks that only she can do justice to them, this is very selfish attitude..not Sufi like at all, very egoistic behavior..I wouldn't be able to listen to her music without thinking about this incident..she is very narrow minded, Sufism has not touched her, one would hope sufism makes people generous.

You are right that Atif seem to encourage her and went to console her because Buddha sang her song and it hurt her so much..maybe Buddha did well and she felt very threatened.

He wants to encourage big fat lady for no reason and simultaneously, he hit Ashaji again and again.
What a animal working in the show;.