ROCKSTAR soundtrack vs. JTHJ soundtrack

Page

Next Last

Poll

Both albums are directed by A.R.Rahman. Which one's better?

360297

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Although I love the title track from JTHJ, I can't help but notice how ordinary the songs are when compared to Rahman's last superduperfuper hit album Rockstar. JTHJ songs aren't bad per say, in fact they're way better than the poop that is coming out of music directors' asses these days, But Rockstar's music was a whole different level, it was loved by both the audience and critics. In fact people said that the music was the soul of the movie. JTHJ's album released a while ago but the it still hasnt become as popular as expected. In fact, most people are let down. Maybe people's expectations after Rockstar were too high, I don't know. But I sure am extremely let down by JTHJ's songs. Especially Saaans. Oh my God that song is torture! Such a sleeping pill 🥱. Worse than Asin. But the title track is BEAUTIFUL. The only face-saving song of the album.

Edited by eraser - 13 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

740920

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Both are... meh! 🥱

Rahman should have started composing bhajans after Rang De Basanti.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

448368

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Rockstar. It's not even a comparison, sountrack of Rush is way better then JTHJ ... music of JTHJ is disappointing

Quote

360297

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Oh Shush Moggliii 😆

Actually now that I think of it, Rockstar had wayyy better lyrics than corny JTHJ lyrics..I meaann seriously...Saaans mein teri, mujhey saaans aayiii????...I willl love you jab tak hai jaaan?? 😆 Maybe the sogns will make more sense after the movie releases, I dont know.

Rockstar had phenomenal lyrics! forgot who the guy was but maannn, they were so darn philosophical..and had so so much depth to them...I mean Naadaaan Parindeyyy, Sadda Haqqq, Jo bhi Main, Hawa Hawa, Katiya Karoo...man the lyrics to those songs were simply marvelous.

Quote

tomnjerry2

@tomnjerry2

Icon

+ 9

Posted: 13 years ago

Rockstar had Mohit Chauhan songs mostly..makes it monotonous.. i would say JTHJ while Tum ho beats each song from JTHJ.

Keep-------------Smiling !!!😊

Quote

740920

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: eraser
Oh Shush Moggliii 😆

Actually now that I think of it, Rockstar had wayyy better lyrics than corny JTHJ lyrics..I meaann seriously...Saaans mein teri, mujhey saaans aayiii????...I willl love you jab tak hai jaaan?? 😆 Maybe the sogns will make more sense after the movie releases, I dont know.

Rockstar had phenomenal lyrics! forgot who the guy was but maannn, they were so darn philosophical..and had so so much depth to them...I mean Naadaaan Parindeyyy, Sadda Haqqq, Jo bhi Main, Hawa Hawa, Katiya Karoo...man the lyrics to those songs were simply marvelous.

Irshad Kamil.

Quote

sourmisery

@sourmisery

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 13 years ago

Rockstar!

JTHJ songs are good but Rockstar is just another LEVEL man! I'll go listen to the album again! <3

Quote

360297

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: tomnjerry2
Rockstar had Mohit Chauhan songs mostly..makes it monotonous.. i would say JTHJ while Tum ho beats each song from JTHJ.

Keep-------------Smiling !!!😊

But the story required one singer for all songs because Ranbir played a singer in the movie and obviously he couldnt have Mohit Chauhan sing one song, Sonu Nigam sing the second and Bappi Lehri sing the third 😆

Haha you like Tum Ho? I love that song too..so melodious and soothing. Whenever I listen to that song, I feel like I'm floating in the sky. But I love the other songs more.

Quote

360297

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: bambogli

Irshad Kamil.

Oh right, thanks Mogli. Oh yes I remember when he came to take his award, he was so shy and humble hehe.

Quote

tomnjerry2

@tomnjerry2

Icon

+ 9

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: eraser

But the story required one singer for all songs because Ranbir played a singer in the movie and obviously he couldnt have Mohit Chauhan sing one song, Sonu Nigam sing the second and Bappi Lehri sing the third 😆

Haha you like Tum Ho? I love that song too..so melodious and soothing. Whenever I listen to that song, I feel like I'm floating in the sky. But I love the other songs more.

excatly wht i feel whn i listen to that song... !!! 😆

but it still is monotonous... while i love MC songs but JTHJ has got variety.. javed ali,mohit,Raghav,Raabi...all songs r pretty good but u need time to realize that... !!! its not like u will like JTHJ songs more than Rockstar songs but they r not that bad as some one compared to Rush songs...seriously !!! 😆

And i think ARR makes composition always keeping the movie in the mind !!! no random songs !!! 😛

Keep------------Smiling !!! 😊