do film critics make for a good director .

So what do you guys think ,Khalid Mohammed and Kunal kohli used to rip of a film as a part of their jobs earlier ,then when they did a Switch to direction some of their films failed miserably while their own colleagues had a Gala time ripping their films

do you think crtics like Raja sen ,Rajeev masand and Taran adarsh should try making a film or they should just fore-go entering forbidden territory .

Your thoughts pls

Critics are good with words but not good at practicing what they preach. That's why voicing your opinion is easy compared to executing in action