Why Are We Blaming the Dancers? - Page 3

nice post... 👏 jhalak is a celebrity dance show... which makes it obvious that both dance as well as their individual popularity will be taken into accounts... i dont understand why popular contestants get bashed for other people getting eliminated...

Originally posted by: angake

Good one, Ilovepyaar. I have to say when we are almost at the finish line of the competition I am getting to see more thoughtful posts. Thank you.

Ditto to everything you said. This is the first time I am watching JDJ and I had to look up on what the concept of the show was. As far as I understood the show is a dance competition based on popularity. Here, dance as well as popularity are the two important factors that keep the contestants in the show. And so that is how I have judged all the eliminations so far.

Shibani is someone I thought who would go all the way to the end. But the wild cards entry changed the equation (and not the existing contestants). If the wild cards were not there I think Shibani would have absolutely gone all the way to the finale. But there is now way Shibani could have competed popularity wise to GC, Ritvik, Rashmi, Barti and Isha. At the end of the day it is a dance and popularity contest so she didn't have enough votes to save her. I was completely fine with that because it fits how I define this competition as.

Darsheel, again felt sad at his exit but I don't think he would have gone all the way till the end. So his exit came earlier than later, that is all. The way I counter argued my disappointment at not being able to watch Avneet again on the JDJ platform was that she is so young and she has a long long time ahead of her to showcase her skills on more platforms such as these or better platforms where dance is the only criteria.

All the other eliminations were fitting, I thought.

From the start of the show I thought there would be two contestants who would go all the way to the end (well 3 before the wild card entries) and those two contestants are still there fighting it out. Isha is a much better dancer than most although from a choreographers point of view I can tell you her expressions are never to the mark. But she has spend years and years honing in on her talent and dancing skills. This is a testament to all that years of handwork. So she absolutely deserves to go to the finale. Gurmeet is a decent enough dancer but he is the most popular contestant on the stage right now. But his popularity did not happen over night. He did not get this popularity just by lying on a sofa with a golden spoon in his mouth. He seems to have worked hard to have reached where he has reached today. His popularity is a testament to all his hard work in his field. The way I look at it is, here you have two worthy contenders who excel in their own field (dancing and acting respectively) and who have weaknesses in the others' field (Gurmeet in dancing and Isha in conveying her expressions to the audience). At the end of the day I want these two to be in the finale because they are the two people who have fit the bill perfectly for the dance and popularity contest.

It is a shame when we delude ourselves that this is a purely dance competition or a purely popularity competition. It is both. And it is an even bigger shame when we discredit these contestants' journey on the show and blame them for the exit of others contestants.

So sorry for the length of the post and for bringing in specific contestants names. I hope the thread remains safe. 😳

wonderful post... completely agree with u... especially the part in red...