The Judges have LOST it!!!

Shaitan-Haiwan thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Seriously what is wrong with the judges? Their marking is getting worse and worse and their bias is just SO obvious!! 😕Once again the judges have gone all crazy. They almost NEVER get it right!
My issue is that.with Bharti and Rithvik they graded them harshly...but then with Isha-Gurmeet-Karan they were more lenient. I find it absoultely ridiculous and pathetic.
Bharti's performance was a huge improvement from last week. I really feel she should have gotten all 8's! And then Rithvik?...25?...Really? Minimum 27!!!
With Gurmeet, they gave him 27, but if you really look at it... Shampa was doing most of the dancing, he was just...sort of there. Almost seemed like she was the contestant. Shes very smart in chreograping to hide Gurmeet's shortcomings and then using her own dance talent to cover up. Very surprised the judges didnt notice that.
Karan should have gotten 19. That was a disgusting performance.
And what with Isha-Salman getting 30? It was absoultely UNDESERVING! There was nothing hatke about the performance, Isha's expressions were over the top and did not match with the dane style AT ALL! I am really not sure why they got 30. It seemed like their act was the easiest compared to everyone else.
Another thing that annoyed me is when the judges were almost in tears when Darsheel left. I mean, they are the ones who marked him wrong 90% of the time. There were many times where they gave him low marks when he really didnt deserve it and what a shame and disgrace that Darsheel is leaving the show after giving the best hip hop performances. What a disgrace and shame for the show!!!
They should have a triple-elimination next week and just wrap up with show!! I just want this season to end, its such a nightmare.
Edited by DIDfan89 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

95

Views

8.3k

Users

36

Likes

204

Frequent Posters

aa123.80 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
WORD. I made a post on exactly the same thing yest, so I obviously agree. What was so faulty in rithwik's performance that he got a 25??? AND yes, Bharti's was so much better than last week and still the points remained the same.

And about Isha, I've spoken so much already, there was nothing hatke as far as I saw. Just terming something as "tango" doesn't make it hatke. While Rashmi, who actually did something hatke was given JUST a 24.

Yes, when Darsheel was there, they'd give them a 24 or max 25 every week, while they were so much better than so many contestants. Just freaking retarded. And now when they're out they feel sad. :/

IDK what the hell is wrong with them.


Edited by aa123.80 - 12 years ago
Rolzz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Ditto! What a weird show!!
Awesome2210 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
totaaly agree ! ronly the last lift of rithvik dint go that well ! .. but everything else was just magical ! and frankly speaking , I dint understand Isha-Salman concept till now ! ... and dance was also what they do usually !
MrManagement thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Why is that whenever Isha-Salman score a 30 there is uproar? Why would the judges be biased towards them? Did Salman and Isha bribe the judges ( the judges gets cut out of Isha's prize money), or are threatening them? Seriously, I wouldn't mind if people gave constructive criticism, but in every post I just see people stating "they don't deserve a 30". Give me the technical reasons why there dance was bad! I think that the Judges know a lot more about dance than we do, I trust there judgement over the people who make the same cliche statements every week. In every reality show, when someone favorite is out or get less votes people cry foul.
Edited by MrManagement - 12 years ago
tastahnin thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: DIDfan89

Seriously what is wrong with the judges? Their marking is getting worse and worse and their bias is just SO obvious!! 😕Once again the judges have gone all crazy. They almost NEVER get it right!

My issue is that.with Bharti and Rithvik they graded them harshly...but then with Isha-Gurmeet-Karan they were more lenient. I find it absoultely ridiculous and pathetic.
Bharti's performance was a huge improvement from last week. I really feel she should have gotten all 8's! And then Rithvik?...25?...Really? Minimum 27!!!
With Gurmeet, they gave him 27, but if you really look at it... Shampa was doing most of the dancing, he was just...sort of there. Almost seemed like she was the contestant. Shes very smart in chreograping to hide Gurmeet's shortcomings and then using her own dance talent to cover up. Very surprised the judges didnt notice that.
Karan should have gotten 19. That was a disgusting performance.
And what with Isha-Salman getting 30? It was absoultely UNDESERVING! There was nothing hatke about the performance, Isha's expressions were over the top and did not match with the dane style AT ALL! I am really not sure why they got 30. It seemed like their act was the easiest compared to everyone else.
Another thing that annoyed me is when the judges were almost in tears when Darsheel left. I mean, they are the ones who marked him wrong 90% of the time. There were many times where they gave him low marks when he really didnt deserve it and what a shame and disgrace that Darsheel is leaving the show after giving the best hip hop performances. What a disgrace and shame for the show!!!
They should have a triple-elimination next week and just wrap up with show!! I just want this season to end, its such a nightmare.

@bold, absolutely agree...

don't know why i feel that most of the time judges were unfair towards rithvik...what was wrong in his performance that both Remo and Madhuri deducted 2 marks?the whole performance was smooth and clean...just for a trivial mistake both of them gave him 8 😲...he should have got at least 27-28...

for karan, it was nothing compared to rithvik...he too got 8 from Remo 😲

for Darsheel, i think it was his best performance...it is a matter of regret that such a dancer had to leave the show where least deserving contastants are there...


roxy22 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: DIDfan89


Seriously what is wrong with the judges? Their marking is getting worse and worse and their bias is just SO obvious!! 😕Once again the judges have gone all crazy. They almost NEVER get it right!

My issue is that.with Bharti and Rithvik they graded them harshly...but then with Isha-Gurmeet-Karan they were more lenient. I find it absoultely ridiculous and pathetic.
Bharti's performance was a huge improvement from last week. I really feel she should have gotten all 8's! And then Rithvik?...25?...Really? Minimum 27!!!
With Gurmeet, they gave him 27, but if you really look at it... Shampa was doing most of the dancing, he was just...sort of there. Almost seemed like she was the contestant. Shes very smart in chreograping to hide Gurmeet's shortcomings and then using her own dance talent to cover up. Very surprised the judges didnt notice that.
Karan should have gotten 19. That was a disgusting performance.
And what with Isha-Salman getting 30? It was absoultely UNDESERVING! There was nothing hatke about the performance, Isha's expressions were over the top and did not match with the dane style AT ALL! I am really not sure why they got 30. It seemed like their act was the easiest compared to everyone else.
Another thing that annoyed me is when the judges were almost in tears when Darsheel left. I mean, they are the ones who marked him wrong 90% of the time. There were many times where they gave him low marks when he really didnt deserve it and what a shame and disgrace that Darsheel is leaving the show after giving the best hip hop performances. What a disgrace and shame for the show!!!
They should have a triple-elimination next week and just wrap up with show!! I just want this season to end, its such a nightmare.


Except 4 bharti bit i agree 100% with u. To me competetion ended yesterday nt interested in ths drama anymore.
Shaitan-Haiwan thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: MrManagement

Why is that whenever Isha-Salman score a 30 there is uproar? Why would the judges be biased towards them? Did Salman and Isha bribe the judges ( the judges gets cut out of Isha's prize money), or are threatening them? Seriously, I wouldn't mind if people gave constructive criticism, but in every post I just see people stating "they don't deserve a 30". Give me the technical reasons why there dance was bad! I think that the Judges know a lot more about dance than we do, I trust there judgement over the people who make the same cliche statements every week. In every reality show, when someone favorite is out or get less votes people cry foul.

Why does there need to be an uproar when someone thinks Salman-Isha dont deserve a 30?
And since when do we (the audience) need to provide a "technical" reason to dislke someones performance? We are not the judges. We are the audience, and the most important component of a reality show. As you can see there are MANY people in this forum that agree with my post. So nobody is assuming, nobody is crying foul .We're voicing our opinions. So you can call it what you want but your just coming across as a insecure Salman or Isha fan.
and BTW, I am dancer myself and that too professionally. So i know JUST as much as Remo and surely more than Madhuri and Karan. So be careful when you "assume". I am sure you've heard the saying about assuming. :D
I actually LIKE Salman-Isha, so my criticism is constructive, for me they went downhill after that Horror-based performance they did. That is my opinon, I dont need to give you a "technical" reason for disliking their performance.
I didnt like it and I dont think they deserve a 30. End of story.
Edited by DIDfan89 - 12 years ago
music_masti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Lift Dikhalaja...

the shows name should be changed...

if there is no lifts no marks...

darsheeel got lowest marks bcose in his dance lifts were not there...

savio cant lift bharti...and do all the gymanastics...so marks will be low...

last two weeks gurmeet shampa dint had lifts in their acts they got low marks...

rashmi deepak last week thier lifts in first kajraho act was good than second days lift..so they got less point ini second act...

salman ish thier dance is full of lifts..only one dance there was no lifts was the govinda karishma act...they dint get marks...

karan and ritwick same..less and simple lifts less marks...
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
i agree ... even i dont understand their marking... karan's performance was very weak he forgot his steps and bharti's performance was better than her previous one, isha didnt deserve 30, seriously i felt bad for dharsheel cant handle this crazy show anymore 🤢

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".