The Judges have LOST it!!!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Rapier

@Rapier

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#11

I don't know about the judges scores and markings. But I was so confused today with the theme being "kuch hatke dikhaa jaa." I didn't think any of the performances today were 'hatke.' They looked like your normal contemporary, tango, rumba, etc. When I thought 'hatke,' I assumed acts that eave you awestruck and leaves you thinking, 'how in the world is this possible?' So in that regard, yea I agree with the TM.

Quote

gilmores

@gilmores

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 12 years ago

#12

LOL, the judging of this show is SO sub-par and embarrassing it's not even funny anymore. They have gotten it wrong from day 1 and while there was some improvement in the last few weeks,

they were back to lameness today.

Okay...so umm before I only watched Darsheel-Avneet's performance and Gurmeet-Shampa's because it came right after theirs in the video I was watching.I can't comment much if Gurmeet-Shampa got correct scores based on style b/c I haven't even heard of Zouk dance style before. 😆 But whatever I saw was very cleverly choreographed and conceptualized. Shampa was the star obviously. I enjoyed it truth be told. I thought it was interesting that Shampa picked a fluid dance style for a very stiff Gurmeet...and then I thought she masked Gurmeet's upper-body stiffness well.

But I decided to catch Salman-Isha's because there was such a big hungama about it...

I know I fall into the "Salman-Isha haterzzz club" and my opinion probably won't count for much, but for the life of me I failed to see how they got a 30. I'm not some dance expert either but I found some thigns weird..so I would loev to hear from those who actually know about Tango.

For starters, their lifts were very messy. You could see the effort in them and they were not at all smooth.In one, Salman's hand was just hanging there because he failed to grab Isha's leg (?)... Then gosh, wasn't the body posture all wrong for a ballroom dance?? It was too slouchy and weak. Isn't it supposed to be more upright and strong for any ballroom dance actually? Never seen any GOOD ballroom act done with such a slouchy posture honestly.

Now the FEEL. Please correct me if I am wrong, but is Tango not an AGGRESSIVE yet SENSUAL dance? That is what I always thought :S. so going on that, Isha-Salman were the FURTHEST thing from aggresive and sensual..I have NEVER ever seen any Tango performed with the dancers giggling away throughout the dance as if they're shying away in love or something. I found it MOST ANNOYING honestly and thought it totally KILLED the whole mood of Tango. If I'm not wrong, Madhuri called the act sweet. I have never heard of a Tango being SWEET. A Waltz is sweet...but a Tango? Not from what I know. :S

It boggles my mind how the judges ignored every single mistake of theirs and gave them a full 30...unless of course the "hatke" thing in their act was too make a total mess of a Tango? 😕

Edited by chocolover89 - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

TanShiLuvr

@TanShi_CrazyLuv

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#13

Gurmeet was best ...u roocckkkeeddd my hero MAY ALLAH bless u amein

Quote

605921

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#14

JUdgess to kuch bhi nahe janta yaar app log he jante ha sab 😆

Quote

Arnav90

@Arnav90

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#15

I think scores are also planned by Channel... The show is gone out of reality way before

Quote

Rhea_401

@Rhea_401

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: music_masti
Lift Dikhalaja...the shows name should be changed...if there is no lifts no marks...darsheeel got lowest marks bcose in his dance lifts were not there...savio cant lift bharti...and do all the gymanastics...so marks will be low...last two weeks gurmeet shampa dint had lifts in their acts they got low marks...rashmi deepak last week thier lifts in first kajraho act was good than second days lift..so they got less point ini second act...salman ish thier dance is full of lifts..only one dance there was no lifts was the govinda karishma act...they dint get marks...karan and ritwick same..less and simple lifts less marks...

Had it been so dn lemme tel ya rithwik n sneha did one of da mst tough,innovative n smooth lifts..n da lift de fumbled up ws da SAME..yep u heard me ryt same as isha n salman yest..n salman too fumbled up der yet de scored a 30!!

n do u thnk rithwiks performnce ws wrth a 25 sm as isha n salmans bollywood disaster!!..i dnt se isha isnt a gud dancr bt undoubtedly judges r damn partial towards her !

Edited by Rhea_401 - 12 years ago

Quote

TanShiLuvr

@TanShi_CrazyLuv

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: Rhea_401

Had it been so dn lemme tel ya rithwik n sneha did one of da mst tough,innovative n yep smooth lifts..n yep da lift de fumbled up ws da SAME..yep u heard me ryt same as isha n salman yest..n salman too fumbled up der yet de scored a 30!!
n do u thnk rithwiks performnce ws wrth a 25 sm as isha n salmans bollywood disaster!!..i dnt se isha isnt a gud dancr bt undoubtedly judges r damn partial towards her !

agree wth u Isha-salman always came up wth same lifts/concept n dance style...

wat was in thier hat-ke act?

was this act a/c to theme?

no ..i thnk the same they did bfore ...bt judges r mahan😛they just wana pick 10-10-10-- whneva there are salman-isha anways

n Gurmeetwas tooo fantastic a/c to theme bt he got 27wthout any reason madhuri n KJO cut 1 mark

Rithwick m nt his fan bt whn he was perfrming i was lik OMG ..lifts..were magical as i said bfore bt he got 25 i was xecting 29...Rashmi was too hatke as cmpare to salman-isha bt she too got less marks ..😕

Quote

Tich

@Jin.

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#18

the most stupid scoring ever...

isha and salman never stick to the concept...

what was so hatke in tango??

did they do something like rashmi-deepak or darsheel-avneet or even rithvik-sneha??? No.. they did what they were always doing...

I really hate the judges for giving 25v to rithvik and 24 to rashmi.. they deserved 29 and 27 ... pathetic...

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: AquaNymph
the most stupid scoring ever...

isha and salman never stick to the concept...

what was so hatke in tango??

did they do something like rashmi-deepak or darsheel-avneet or even rithvik-sneha??? No.. they did what they were always doing...

I really hate the judges for giving 25v to rithvik and 24 to rashmi.. they deserved 29 and 27 ... pathetic...

Rithvik did floor contemporary, I don't see anything hatke in that. His dance was almost flawless just like Isha, but nothing hatke about it

Rashmi Deepak had hatke concept, but I feel they couldn't execute well and thus their scores

Darsheel and Avneet, sad that they aren't in the running anymore :(

GC, nothing hatke there either. It was the same, he was hiding under Shampa as usual.

Karan's performance, very choppy and all over the place. Again nothing Hatke and same with Bharti.

About Isha, she did tango and it was flawless, concept wasn't hatke but then again no one did justice to the "hatke" theme according to me

Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 12 years ago