Biological Vs. Adopted - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

3k

Users

12

Likes

125

Frequent Posters

soapwatcher1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
Laurie, absolutely loved both your posts and agree with every word you have written.

Sowmya, we ask Archu to stay away and not interfere in Purvi's and Arjun's marriage in order to be fair to both girls yet we want her to postpone the wedding. If we want her to stay away, she cannot have any say in when they should marry, it is their decision to marry now or later. I don't see the point in postponing the wedding until Ovi comes to terrns with it. Purvi is not Ovi's sister (Ovi has never considered her to be), the parents are getting divorced and Manav and family are moving to Canada, it is not like the two girls' lives will ever cross paths so why snatch or postpone Purvi's happiness to appease Ovi? This will only breed more hope in Ovi and give her time to brood and plot. Better to make a clean cold cut by having the marriage take place right away. That way Arjun is out of her system once and for all.

Perfangel, Archana's initial reaction was exactly what you have written, Arjun in her eyes was not right for either of her girls. I do not agree with the way Arjun conducted himself in regards to the engagement and the fact that he never tried to explain himself to Ovi. I believe he still owes her an explanation though it might be too late now, it was callous of him not to square things away as he of all people knows how much she loves him or obsesses over him. That said, Archana did realize that Arjun loved Purvi and had never loved Ovi so she would be hard pressed then to punish one child just because her other child is unhappy with this rishta. Mothers above all else whether it makes perfect sense to their children or not, do love all children equally and try to be fair to all of their children. She is being fair to Purvi in not snatching her happiness for Ovi's sake, she is being fair to Ovi in not letting her throw herself away on a man who doesn't care for her. What more can Archana do? Not invite the Deshmukhs? She is damned if she does and she is damned if she doesn't. Look at the way Manav pushed her when he thought she had hidden Arjun's and Purvi's love from him. If my child was living in la la land, I would shove it in her face not unkindly but to make her realize the follies of her ways. That is what Archana did in handing that invitation and that too only after Ovi had come to her with that crazy offer of a barter exchange.

I do believe Ovi knows Archana loves her or she wouldn't be so ready to dish out crap every single time. It is only when you are confident in a person's love that you tell them you are unhappy with them. When there is indifference, you do not rant and rail. I read in a parenting magazine this psychologist reassuring a mother who was upset that her toddler had told her he hated her. The psychologist told the mother not to worry, the child could say that only to her as the kid was so supremely confident of his mother's love, he knew she would keep loving him no matter how he acted out. That is my take on Ovi, every time she throws a tantrum at Archana, it is a test to see how far she can go without alienating this woman, her mother, as she, Ovi knows deep down in her heart that Archana loves her. It is Ovi's greatest fear to be unloved and her secret hope, contrary to the poison that has been fed her, that this gentle, beautiful creature loves her above all else (equally of course with all her other siblings).
Edited by soapwatcher1 - 13 years ago
zeezee55 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
Excellent Cocololo123!!! I totallgree. Once you adopt a child, that child ceases to be "adopted" - it is your child. maternal love is maternal love whether biological or adopted. Archana brought up Purvi like her own daughter, it is even more poignant because, Archana had lost her children to Manav at that time, and Purvi was her life-saver. I think that was what kept Archana live and sane. How can she love differently.
preetie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
I think Archana is supporting the right. Supporting Ovi in her lust for Arjun is wrong that is why archana is supporting Purvi. If roles were reveresed then she would have supported Ovi if Arjun also loved her and Purvi was kabab mein hati
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
Excellent posts by Perfangel and Sowmya Jairam...I agree completely..👏
Ideally Adopted and Bilogical kids should be same to a mother and mother should try to be fair..Parents in general.
here we have some who mix the issues...PR is not the case...In PR ArMan did not joinly adopt a child...Seperated for 18 yrs a woman adopted a child and raised her..
Manav raised their biologica children on his own for past 18 yrs..
No one here is against adoption or loving adopted child as it is made out to be just because few have opposite views..
That is all I had to add as Perfangel and Sowmya has said it all...Fantastic posts by you both..👏
Edited by Dabulls23 - 13 years ago
sherma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

I never post, but I had to post this one. Archana is a great adopted mother but a horrible, absolutely horrible biological mother. The point is not that she is being a good adopted mother, the point is that she is being a horrible biological mother. Her biological children hate her. I was excited for their reunion and now all my excitement is gone. She truly does not deserve them. I am sort of glad they were taken away now.


Your mother is your most compassionate companion. Your pain must hurt her the most. At least that's what my mom tells me and when I am hurt she acts like my pain hurts her more than it hurts me. Archana has not done much to win Teju and Ovi over, her tears don't mean much. As you guys said a mother must be fair, then on what standard has Archana been fair to her biological daughters?

Arjun is not her toy so it's not like she can take Arjun away from Purvi and give it to Ovi, but what she could've done was to show more compassion toward Ovi. If she a "sensible" women has lived 18 years without Manav and still held on to him, then Ovi is an immature girl who barely has a clue about the realities of life. She let Purvi be with Arjun, fine! But she should have been more understanding towards Ovi. She should've tried to connect with her. Why does Arjun Purvi need to get married right away? Ovi can barely fathom losing Arjun, now she has to watch and hear about him getting married? Which brave person in this forum thinks she can hold it together if their loved one got married right in front of their eyes. Ovi's case was also special because she was about to marry him, had her life planned and within a second it was taken away from her. She didn't even have time to process this thing. If a situation like this hurts us mature, reasonable people how would it effect a spoiled, obsessive girl like Ovi? Why does Archana need to be so insensitive and down right selfish and invite Manav's family? Who wants to go? No one!!!! Yet she wants to establish, and hurt other people because of her values. What are these values worth if it only hurts people? Which mother hurts their own daughters? A mother who does not deserve to be a mother. I want to slap her when she drags Manav into this whole thing. Ovi hates Purvi, because of her mahanta Ovi has had only one parent in life and that is Manav. She lost the love of her life to Purvi, she does not need to share Manav with Purvi. She shouldn't have to. Purvi is Archana's daughter, not Manav's. Manav has already been too kind to them.

Then comes Arjun himself. Of course he is our hero, so he can't do anything wrong for our fans who love seeing "love" onscreen. Let's just overlook the fact that if anything like that happened to any girl in real life, the guy would be considered a pig. Archana acted like neither of her daughters deserved to be with him, but after her silly test all of a sudden Arjun can be with Purvi. My mother would have never let any boy who did that to me around me. I am not a mother but I treat my younger sister like my daughter and I would not let any guy who has cheated my daughters like that around them. Even if I thought that the guy couldn't come out because of "majbooris" and bad timing, I could not get over the pain my loved ones suffered because of him. I could not and would not let that guy get close to any of my daughters. Archana once again is a horrible mother because she completely overlooked the fact that this guy has hurt her daughter Ovi. She was angry because this guy cheated her daughter"S". She overlooks the fact that because of this guy her daughter is in a bad state.

I don't think people here try to insult Purvi by saying she is a adopted daughter so she must mean less than a biological daughter. What they want to stress is Archana is a horrible mother because she disrespects the gift God gave her, her own biological daughters. She constantly says Purvi is a gift, Purvi is a gift, Teju and Ovi are also gifts. Your own biological children are the biggest blessings in life, and she insults them both.
superb post,luvd it👏

cs-07 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
Am not posting much in the forum plus everyone has already said what i wanted to. Agreed totally with Varsha Di. Perangel, Sowmya and ummm i forgot the other id. awesome posts./

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".