another view on Poorvi.. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

2.2k

Users

10

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

Ami25 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Deegie

That's the funny thing. Poorvi recieved most praises that gala for 'meri jaan'. Other contestants made mistakes, but Amit was the only one to comment on Poorvi. No one had something to criticise about her singing, so he commented on her genre. She was that gala's best performer and he criticised her?
That is putting down.
Poorvi was just placing the mirror in front of him: look at yourself dude, you also are best in one genre (nothing more or less). And maybe people find it wrong attidude of her because his genre is Punjabi and her western. That's why people might blame Poorvi for something she never did. She didn't criticised Punjabi songs but Amit's way of thinking.
IF some one has a bad attitude in this situation it is only Amit.
Another thing I don't get: Poorvi in comp by looks? For me that is baseless. Looks are subjective. but if you would measure her and other contestants by the standards of models, film stars, there were loads of other contestants WAY prettier/good looking than Poorvi. I find Poorvi average in looks. And even if the judges made their selection on looks, I don't think the other contestants would stand there.


Poorvi criticised amit as well soo whats the bog deal ?? she is a horrible singer and there is no denying in that ! Amit didnt do anything !! he is a shy guy and works very hard and appreciate it when he gets good comments !! not like poorvi over -confident i think she has paid sunidhi already to be in her favout soo there is she !!! money speaks thats all
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
Its not abt GENRE, its not abt Voice quality or type, its not abt Attitude!
Its abt SUR...TAAL, MELODY!
This is a MUSIC competition and contestants shd at least be able to sing IN TUNE!
I cannot tolerate singers who cannot sing in tune and who murder my favorite songs!

Purvi cannot sing in tune, shes horribly besura in all songs, her sur goes haywire and she doesnt care, judges dont seem to care!
But we who love music and love sur cannot tolerate besura singers, thats all!
She shd GO ASAP!

Edited by pallavi25 - 13 years ago
niladri05011993 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: pallavi25

Its not abt GENRE, its not abt Voice quality or type, its not abt Attitude!

Its abt SUR...TAAL, MELODY!
This is a MUSIC competition and contestants shd at least be able to sing IN TUNE!
I cannot tolerate singers who cannot sing in tune and who murder my favorite songs!

Purvi cannot sing in tune, shes horribly besura in all songs, her sur goes haywire and she doesnt care, judges dont seem to care!
But we who love music and love sur cannot tolerate besura singers, thats all!
She shd GO ASAP!

she will not go. she is here to stay becoz real music lovers know that poorvi has a soft tune which modern day singers cannot have.
kadami thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: pallavi25

Its not abt GENRE, its not abt Voice quality or type, its not abt Attitude!

Its abt SUR...TAAL, MELODY!
This is a MUSIC competition and contestants shd at least be able to sing IN TUNE!
I cannot tolerate singers who cannot sing in tune and who murder my favorite songs!

Purvi cannot sing in tune, shes horribly besura in all songs, her sur goes haywire and she doesnt care, judges dont seem to care!
But we who love music and love sur cannot tolerate besura singers, thats all!
She shd GO ASAP!


You are absolutely right.

I am sure she already gone. Thae above music lover wants to keep for own pleasure e.g. be-suri is fit to sing for ca-bra dance in hotels, streets and privately for her fans doing eeh ooh aah etc.. Life of sun is fifty percent left. I do not think that the above fan can force her to stay until sun goes. We are real music lover for Bollywood classical, semi classical and all sureela songs.
Edited by kadami - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".