I hate being judgmental but...

Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Yes I hate being judgmental but one contestant who doesn't appeal to me as much for singing as for other personality related issues somehow is Amit. He seems very diffident and negative (I feel negative vibes) and jealous!!!
May be I am totally wrong but this is something that I felt very strongly just now and thought would pen it down.
having said this I loved his first performance on the aiwein song, it was so full of energy and was so perfect but after that somehow for me at least he seems to have gone awfully wrong!! and even his voice quality doesn't appeal to me unlike Vipul's whose voice has a very soothing quality. Devendra is very good but his voice still sounds a bit immature to me. As for Poorvi, I don't feel judgmental about her at all strangely. I feel that she is just reserved and shy. I don't feel that she is snobbish or has an attitude problem. I like her singing and her voice and her presence. She has the X factor in her strangely and when she sings she comes alive because otherwise she is poker faced. Yes she did slip on surs etc yesterday but I feel that it has more with her adapting the song and trying to bring variations in it (as Sunidhi pointed out she scatted, etc...) than singing awfully wrong.
Well as usual just my two cents and strictly my opinion and I suppose all of us are entitled to having one isn't it so guys??

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

836

Users

4

Likes

9

Frequent Posters

Ami25 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I disagree with your views !! strongly ! He doest have any issues ! he is a guy from a very poor family who might havent have an exposure in his life. He is doing great ! I know he will not be an Indian idol for sure but i dont see any jealousy in him !! He just doest like teh way poorvi singh that all ----- and Poorvi is one person who has a long list of people who dont like her. I am from chandigarh and i have seen her singing in parties and religious functions. She is no diffrent than what i have heard him three years back. She is very ordinary when oi comes to singing. i wouldnt comment on her personal behaviour. because what she does and how she behaves in none of my business. But she doest give pleasant vibes. Thats all i can say.
ObodroKargosh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
finally a post on II6 forum I can completely agree to lol like each and every word of it!!!
Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
OK ji. You see I didn't have the privilege of having inside information.
As for Amit you may very well be right. It might have to do with his background.
I am sorry if I hurt anyone and most of all Amit. That was not my intention. It was an impulsive post.
As for Poorvi I feel very bad about all the bashing on this forum. It is not fair. She too is very young and has a long way to go. I like her presence on stage. I feel that she is the only one apart from Vipul who has the capability to bring that extra something. Well I must admit that I havent been a regular watcher of the show though. So I am commenting from very limited exposure.
Ami25 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
OK ji. You see I didn't have the privilege of having inside information.
As for Amit you may very well be right. It might have to do with his background.
I am sorry if I hurt anyone and most of all Amit. That was not my intention. It was an impulsive post.
As for Poorvi I feel very bad about all the bashing on this forum. It is not fair. She too is very young and has a long way to go. I like her presence on stage. I feel that she is the only one apart from Vipul who has the capability to bring that extra something. Well I must admit that I havent been a regular watcher of the show though. So I am commenting from very limited exposure.
[/QUOT

Everyone has their own views ! YOu have yours and i have mine. LIke some people think poorvi is too proud and according to you amit is jealous !!
MJHTMonayaSajan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
I personally feel Amit is very sweet n shy n he is seriously trying hard to give his best...
I know he won't b an Indian Idol but I want him in top3...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".