Why get personal with Dev? Note, page 3

Madhura2105 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Guys, why few (who dont accept the newbie as Gopi)amongst us are getting personal with Dev?? What has she done to us?? Nothing, isnt it??? We have absolute no authority to criticize her personally and especially on her personal life.

Yes, we can criticize her acting as "Gopi". But personally, i have to share this, I caught up with some of her episodes in her previous show on the you tube, her character there was of a vibrant girl and an out going and out spoken one, I must say, she was too very good at it and was adorable too. That showed she aint a bad actress at all.

I do understand, when "Gopi" is taken into consideration we all are used to seeing Giaa playing the role at its best. I do remember, when the show had hit the screens many had criticized M.Nazim and Giaa and had called them several names, but lets not forget that time the show was just starting, we ourselves were trying to actually understand the characters as the actors were playing it. Once, we understood the graph of the characters we accepted them warmly and whole heartedly, didnt we?? And its because of us that the show has been running for 2.5years. The way Giaa was sacked from the show was really pathetic and cruel on the part of the SP and PH and the reason "Giaas dancing in JDJ will hammer down Gopis image" was even more pathetic and this shook Giaa and GiNa fans to the core, including me. But being Giaas fans we are doing all our best to get her back to the show with due respect, isnt it?? Tell me, frankly personally bashing Dev up is it actually helping us to get Giaa back in the show by any sort??? No, isnt it??? Then why bash her personally and who are we to interfere in Devs personal life?? Nobody.

As far as Devs acting as Gopi is concerned, I know many of us cant relate to her, including me, whatever could be the reason behind it. I agree, she isnt playing Gopi to that caliber of which we are used to seeing. Personally, what I feel is that Dev is lacking "involvement" in the show as well as the character. Dev, isnt aware of the ups and downs of Gopi, of which we as the viewers of SNS are aware off from the past 2.5years, so tell me how is Dev responsible for not knowing the history of Gopi??

According to me, its the Directors fault here. Its he/she who is failing some way or the other to make Dev understand the depths of Gopis pain, trials, tribulations and sorrow of which we, the audience and Giaa is well aware off. Dev, recites the lines which the writer gives her and she acts the way the way the Director tells her to do it. how is Dev responsible, if the Directors of teh show might be telling to refer the CDs of Giaa whilst enacting the scenes??? Dev is merely doing her job and dancing to the tunes of the Directors, isnt it?? Just think about it at least once.

Frankly speaking, the viewers havent accepted Dev as Gopi in a wide range, including me and hence many say "emotional" connect with the show is lost ie because we all are emotionally attached to see Giaa as Gopi and the way Giaa was shown the doors of the show was a major turn off fro many people, including me. Slowly and steadily people have detached themselves from the show, and the TRPs of the show are actually saying that the viewers arent attached to SNS any longer as they were before, which is the saddest but the truth of the show.



PS- I am not making anyone (who dont accept newbie as Gopi vahu) accept Dev as Gopi here. But personally i feel that, we have no absolute no authority to bash someone on the personal level and interfere in their personal lives. am sorry to hurt anyone, must have been unintentional. Last but not the least sorry for such a long post (Its vinders company, i guess which makes me put up such long post 😆)

A humble request guys, please act wisely and dont bash Dev personally. and please dont bash me up either 😳


And let me know your views over this rant, I want to how right or wrong i am 😳 Btw, I wouldnt mind praises coming to me on the "personal" level, if yu like the post 😉😳



STATUTORY WARNING - I DON'T WANT ANY BASHERS ON MY POST.
A HEALTHY DISCUSSION IS WELCOME, BUT NO BASHING. (I am not yelling it out, merely trying to get it to your notice. )



Love,
Dhruti 😊
Edited by dhruti - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

2.5k

Users

12

Likes

76

Frequent Posters

munnihyderabad thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#2

wow what a fantastic post druti👏⭐️

this what dipsy aka deepa said in her post yesterday ...

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/saath-nibhaana-saathiya/3068136/i-think-we-should-be-bashing-the-director-vb-note-pg-6

and i do feel that the directors should give her proper briefing and cues of gopi's CHANGING character with the current track

and yes it would really be great if we restrict our comments to how Dev is playing Gopi's character instead of getting involved with the actor's personal life or her personality


thanks for posting it 😊
Madhura2105 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: munnihyderabad


wow what a fantastic post druti👏⭐️

this what dipsy aka deepa said in her post yesterday ...

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/saath-nibhaana-saathiya/3068136/i-think-we-should-be-bashing-the-director-vb-note-pg-6

and i do feel that the directors should give her proper briefing and cues of gopi's CHANGING character with the current track

and yes it would really be great if we restrict our comments to how Dev is playing Gopi's character instead of getting involved with the actor's personal life or her personality


thanks for posting it 😊


I did read the aforesaid post which actually made me think accordingly . 😊

Thanks for appreciating the post 😃

5cents thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Dhruti, nice, sensible & mature post!!
I guess, the sentiments & emotions are running very high at this point so all this mud slinging and chaos. Time is the best healer. Even I got quite a few PM saying how can I watch & then post pics of new Gopi & Ahem...Actually, It was more of a threat ...how dare I post pics🤢. But me thick skinned gal of 21st century😉 did not pay any heed to any stuff & continued to do... what I felt was right for me😃. I can only speak for myself.

It is true that Giaa has given LIFE to Gopi and nobody can take that away from her. New girl is a replacement and will remain that. She may become better but our point of reference will always be Giaa as Gopi. Our yardstick of measurement is Giaa's portrayal of Gopi.
But I feel the tempers will keep flaring & mercury will keep rising as viewers feel cheated but they fail to get this point that it takes 2 to tango😉. Anyway, I myself am allergic to sermonizing so will not tell or get into who shd do what?? Everybody is mature, whoever is coming here so use your freedom of speech and enjoy the forum😉.

I wish best to people who are fighting for Giaa's return to SNS. But for me SNs is not Giaa it is Rashi, Koki, Ahem, Urmilla , Hetal and cats & pigeons, parrots and dogs and NOW waiting for a BONNY BABY
Madhura2105 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: 5cents

Dhruti, nice, sensible & mature post!!
I guess, the sentiments & emotions are running very high at this point so all this mud slinging and chaos. Time is the best healer. Even I got quite a few PM saying how can I watch & then post pics of new Gopi & Ahem...Actually, It was more of a threat ...how dare I post pics🤢. But me thick skinned gal of 21st century😉 did not pay any heed to any stuff & continued to do... what I felt was right for me😃. I can only speak for myself.

It is true that Giaa has given LIFE to Gopi and nobody can take that away from her. New girl is a replacement and will remain that. She may become better but our point of reference will always be Giaa as Gopi. Our yardstick of measurement is Giaa's portrayal of Gopi.
But I feel the tempers will keep flaring & mercury will keep rising as viewers feel cheated but they fail to get this point that it takes 2 to tango😉. Anyway, I myself am allergic to sermonizing so will not tell or get into who shd do what?? Everybody is mature, whoever is coming here so use your freedom of speech and enjoy the forum😉.

I wish best to people who are fighting for Giaa's return to SNS. But for me SNs is not Giaa it is Rashi, Koki, Ahem, Urmilla , Hetal and cats & pigeons, parrots and dogs and NOW waiting for a BONNY BABY




agreed with yu ...
why cant we all respect individual perception???

anyways i love yur work, and especially wen yu have naaz in it 😳 .. but i stopped seeing the show as i cant relate to the newbie as gopi .. but i do enjoy reading swasthis updates on ahem and love ...
Edited by dhruti - 13 years ago
gauri72 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
I would say it is casting director's fault.Director has to work in stipulated time period.He cant give time to actor who has been thrown overnight.He has to shoot more n more episodes in short time.Why PH and SP didnt telecast the episode shoot with Giaa?Why they force us to see what we dont want?Now dont tell u r free to watch other shows.How can they not consider our loyalty to the show?Their high trp was due to our loyalty, they should give respect to loyal viewers.Otherwise be ready for any type of criticism for cheating the viewers.If they can cheat us, we can criticise whatever we like.They have tried to suppress our voice.They can go to any extent but we have to keep our mouth shut.No way.
5cents thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: dhruti




agreed with yu ...
why cant we all respect individual perception???

anyways i love yur work, and especially wen yu have naaz in it 😳 .. but i stopped seeing the show as i cant to the newbie .. but i do enjoy reading swasthis updates on ahem and love ...



yes, Dhruti, my "ONLY" problem is why are some hell bent on throwing their opinion down our throats. I abs get it some folks were emotionally attached to Giaa so are feeling very bad...i GET THEIR pov and respect and sympathize with them. But to call names and mud slinging that ...Oh! where did u find the new Gopi appealing and stuff is ridiculous. People forget that if they are throwing stone at the mud some trash will come on them too... this is exactly what is happening here and we are facing so much of animosity.
Hoping for the better😳
Madhura2105 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: gauri72

I would say it is casting director's fault.Director has to work in stipulated time period.He cant give time to actor who has been thrown overnight.He has to shoot more n more episodes in short time.Why PH and SP didnt telecast the episode shoot with Giaa?Why they force us to see what we dont want?Now dont tell u r free to watch other shows.How can they not consider our loyalty to the show?Their high trp was due to our loyalty, they should give respect to loyal viewers.Otherwise be ready for any type of criticism for cheating the viewers.If they can cheat us, we can criticise whatever we like.They have tried to suppress our voice.They can go to any extent but we have to keep our mouth shut.No way.




Gauri dear ... i understand your thoughts ... 😃

see, i know the way SP n Ph sacked Giaa out from the show was very pathetic and cruel too .. The Cvs could have come up with some better way of telling the audience that Giaa wont be a part of the show any more ... overnight replacement was the worst step taken by the duo ... i beat, that the preggie wala and ahem confession wala promos were shoot with Giaa .. didnt we see that on last GiNa seg together ...

The Ph is very well aware of the out rage of the public and hence the change in the story line ahem not wanting the baby ... the track is more focusing on KoHem relationship rather than GoHem relationship..

The Sp n PH are facing the wrath of their decision and thats certain re.. the TRPs are doing the talking ... mb they forgot that the viewers are the ones who make the show and are also the ones who can destroy the show ... afterall, humare haathon main remote control hota hai bhai .. hum jo chahe us channel ko dekh sakte hain .. hai naa???
Edited by dhruti - 13 years ago
Madhura2105 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: 5cents



yes, Dhruti, my "ONLY" problem is why are some hell bent on throwing their opinion down our throats. I abs get it some folks were emotionally attached to Giaa so are feeling very bad...i GET THEIR pov and respect and sympathize with them. But to call names and mud slinging that ...Oh! where did u find the new Gopi appealing and stuff is ridiculous. People forget that if they are throwing stone at the mud some trash will come on them too... this is exactly what is happening here and we are facing so much of animosity.
Hoping for the better😳



certainly ... callin Dev several names isnt gonaa help in getting Giaa back at all ..
it needs maturity to understand others POV, which few lack ... i have no issues with you or anyone else seeing the show, unless and until it doesnt create any issues between us personally ..

on the IF there are people whom we have never seen at all and will not even get a chance to see, but we're together as family so live like one why create animosity, w/o reason ... just accept and respect each others opinion and the issue is sorted there itself ...
5cents thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: gauri72

I would say it is casting director's fault.Director has to work in stipulated time period.He cant give time to actor who has been thrown overnight.He has to shoot more n more episodes in short time.Why PH and SP didnt telecast the episode shoot with Giaa?Why they force us to see what we dont want?Now dont tell u r free to watch other shows.How can they not consider our loyalty to the show?Their high trp was due to our loyalty, they should give respect to loyal viewers.Otherwise be ready for any type of criticism for cheating the viewers.If they can cheat us, we can criticise whatever we like.They have tried to suppress our voice.They can go to any extent but we have to keep our mouth shut.No way.



Gauri, who is telling you to keep your mouth shut...PLEASE go ahead with the protest. I think the protest happened also 2day in Mumbai. The motto PRESS ON ahs solved a lot of problems. So please go ahead. But why litter the whole forum with Giaa Jihad . You can have few posts and talk abt it vent abt it.
There are some who like SNS more than Giaa & others shd be cognizant of that.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".