Thoughts on the Children:Responsible Discipline

ChicagoCarole1 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Several things about yesterday and today's episodes caught my attention. Mainly to do with the children in the story and the way adults interact (or don't) with them.

Firstly, Ansh, Payal, and Palak although adorable, are all spoiled...Ansh more than the girls. All of them seem to be used to getting their way. Why are they allowed to interrupt or speak back to adults? Why are they even present for every adult activity? They act on their impulses. I can understand that Ansh has been the center of Aarti's life, but there is such a thing as responsible discipline. Discipline comes from the word disciple...meaning a child who is disciplined is taught how to follow rules, act appropriately, have manners and act in a way in accordance with the culture so that child is accepted and productive. Discipline is NOT punishment. A parent who ignores discipline is doing a disservice to their child.

Secondly, what adult was responsible for the children on the day after the wedding? Obviously, Gayatri didn't want Aarti near her son. So who was suppose to check on the children? Adults were up and dressed. Guests were in the house for the rituals, and the children were still in their room, not bathed or dressed. They had not had breakfast. No one had checked on them. In this case, the children misbehaved, but the adults left these small children to their own devices. So who is at fault? Did the in-laws in this house just think that magically the children would be cared for? Gayatri told Aarti not to worry about Ansh because he was "at home." I think this whole incident is just going to fan her worries, because no one was watching the kids.

Thirdly, I think once this whole ritual, wedding stuff is over, Aarti will fall into the role of caring parent who is the one that will be sure Ansh and the girls feel cared for and safe. I just hope that in doing that she also disciplines them appropriately and doesn't always say, "It's okay." because often it is NOT okay...children need to know that.

Okay...enough preaching on children...but they have been my vocation for many years...and I really dislike when a child is treated in either extreme...either neglected or over indulged...both can ruin a person.

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

865

Users

7

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

AngeloScuro thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Thanks for that lovely viewpoint. It's informative and insightful. I hope the show can show what it is all about, what real parenting is!😃

Please don't stop talking or writing on you favourite subject. I for one am ready to read it.😃
Edited by AngelDark - 13 years ago
angake thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: ChicagoCarole1


Secondly, what adult was responsible for the children on the day after the wedding? Obviously, Gayatri didn't want Aarti near her son. So who was suppose to check on the children? Adults were up and dressed. Guests were in the house for the rituals, and the children were still in their room, not bathed or dressed. They had not had breakfast. No one had checked on them. In this case, the children misbehaved, but the adults left these small children to their own devices. So who is at fault? Did the in-laws in this house just think that magically the children would be cared for? Gayatri told Aarti not to worry about Ansh because he was "at home." I think this whole incident is just going to fan her worries, because no one was watching the kids.


This is something that bothered me too. As an argument I can say that the Puja happened at 7 am and so the adults must have thought that kids would sleep in. But the house is full of guests. It is very likely that all the hubbub could have woken up the kids earlier than their usual routine. And I didn't see Ran Dulare, the servant anywhere either. In that case who would have attended to them. I know with my own kids and nieces and nephews, as soon as they wake up they come asking for breakfast even before they brushed their teeth. 😕

In fact, among all the people present in the house, Aarti, a member of the Scindia household who just came the night before, was the only one who thought about getting some breakfast ready for all the kids- not just for Ansh but also for Payal and Palak.
LuvStrk-001 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Lovely Points u have put here dear!!!
Thanks for this Post!!!
sneha522 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
i frankly cant children that act the way Anch did, it is really uncalled for. Arti needs to stop babying him, it comes a point where it is time to learn basic respect. Yash was right, Anch needs to behave, Arti being a puppet for Anch, when he asked her to yell at Yash was going over and beyond the parent child relationship. kids need boundaries and Arti lets him cross them because he doesn't have a dad but he does still have a mom, which is a parent last time i checked.
cutestvampire thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
aarti seriously needs to teach ansh how to behave... he gets very annoying all the time and so jiddi... and all.. i guess because he doesn't know how things work in join family... but still today's behavior was disrespectful and aarti didn't say anything... she has to tell him to shut up sometimes...
gafulu14 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
STILL ARTI HAS TO TEACH ANSH, RATHER FULL FILL HIS DEMAND

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".