Jai didnt blackmail Bani!

Hello Everyone!

I was just going through everyone reactions to Yday's episode. A lot of u feel Jai emotionally Blackmailed Bani… manipulated the situation so that Bani herself would refuse to hear him out. Seriously I would take that as a compliment for Jai😃. I am so fed up calling him Duffer.. it is so flattering to imagine him like this. But as much as I would want to see it like that I cant. I beg to differ coz I didn't see a cold businessman there but a Jai who was scared out of his wits at the possibility of Bani being dead! Before I start let me tell u all I am defending Jai for Yday and I am not defending his raaz. Not as yet!

My take on the entire episode was that Jai was in the verge of telling Bani the truth only coz he was too shaken by the fact that she had risked her life for that God Damn Raaz. Just watch him mention the raaz… for someone who is traumatized and terrorized by the incident he sounded least bothered about that, "TUM park Road ke Raaz keliye ES waqt ES sunsan jagah par?" was what he said! The fact bani was at such a dangerous place scared him more than the raaz and without even a moment of pause he continued… "Theek hai tho main abhi ese waqt tum sab sach batadunga' Now where was the time for him to think to manipulate the issue?😕

Even when he got the SMS the didn't react to Park Road, he reacted to Bani being in danger. I didn't see a moment of hesitation when Jai got off his car at Park Road… he didn't go to live the memory of that accident, he was plainly searching for Bani at that place. As I said in my analysis, He was here to save Bani and not save himself from the Raaz. If u give him an option 'Bani or the Raaz' he will chose Bani, the same way Bani chose him. 😃😳

Now coming to Jai saying after the raaz is out they will NEVER meet eachother again… he said twice… once in the beginning and once in the end. It was something that was always on his mind. He always knew it.. it wasn't that he came up with that all of a sudden to black mail Bani. It was an issue he was trying to cope for a long time himself… and he himself is terrorized at that possibility… and when u are in such a condition… u tend to repeat it and eachtime it sounds horrific. It is the easiest way one resorts to accept the truth… keep repeating it to yourself. Jai had accepted that… Bani didn't have the guts to… she stepped back. Now how did that make it blackmailing her? 😕

Jai could have easily lambasted her and pulled her out of the place… He could have used any of his anger techniques to bail himself out of the situation and the result would have been the same. The Raaz would have remained hidden! He could have threatened to make her life miserable or he could have told her they don't share a relationship and when they don't have a future together, she has nothing to do with his past. He has said it before he could have said now. But he DIDN'T! Instead he told Bani they do share a relationship… he didn't define it, he could have. He said it all when he said "Hum ne jo waqt sath mein bitaye un lamhoon ka tho rista hai…." He encompassed all the different facets of their relationship… the relationship they shared as employer-employee, as 2 people who shared mutual admiration and respect, friends at time, enemies, as eachother comforter, protector and finally that of Husband and Wife. All of that would mean nothing once the Raaz is out is what he said. He knew Bani well enough to make out that it meant something to her… he was bound to tell her that if this Raaz is out.. this is what they both will end up losing… he was ready for it coz Bani left him with no option!😕 She was putting her risk at stake for this Raaz and he couldn't have lived with another guilt of being responsible for her death… and more over he loved her enough not to let her die for this.

So I think whatever Jai did Yday was what I would have expected of Jai Walia👏. Now if Bani doesn't want to hear it… what can the guy do? Apart from thanking his stars.😆

I don't know what the raaz is, but one thing I can be sure of is that Jai wouldn't manipulated the Law…. He is suffering from Guilt that is the reason of the high standards of humanity that he has set for himself. Jai said there is a past in everyone lives and they are entitled to hide it from the world… That was enough an indicator that Jai cant be criminally involved with the entire accident… it is more of a moral issue for Jai and if u ask me he has punished himself enough for it. Enough is Enough… he needs to get over it! Unless the creatives are out with a butchers knife to slaughter the basic characteristic of Jai Walia… I will always be on Jai's side. I always have been and will be. For one I feel he isnt capable of being Evil and 2^nd of all I know Jai cant be a coward. So I am hoping against hope that in all the storm gathering around Park Road they do manage to salvage the Honour of Jai Walia at the end of it. I really wont be able to take a tarnished Jai. If that happens, I am done with Kasam se, Kasam Se!

When I am on this topic, I wonder why Jai should take all the blame of hiding the Raaz from Bani. What about her father? He is the guy who has to be blamed for all this😡. He kept silent all the while… now his daughter is finding out that he has donated lakhs of rupees to charity and demands an explanation from her husband. Now how is Jai to answer that Question? Nishikant must have had his reasons and Jai is carrying that baggage as well and chose to remain silent coz it will hurt Bani! What kind of a father would knowingly trust his daughters lives with a man who is supposedly responsible for a huge tragedy in his daughter life? Why would Nishikant Dixit tell Bani to go to Jai Walia for help knowing very well that if Bani tripped on the truth it would shatter her. That way I find Jai more considerate and caring about Bani than what her father was👏. Bani has the most priced relationship with Jai and she better think twice before putting that at stake. There is some kissa related to Nishikant Dixit coz of which Jai simply detests him… and I trust Jai's sense of judgement… he doesn't spare himself when he is wrong, there is no reason why he would spare others.

Lets wait for the actual Raaz to unfold… which is not happening today. What is happening today is just for the heck of it… the actual story will unfold later. My guess is Bani is not the ONLY victim of this accident, It is also Jai who is a victim! Jai has been lead to believe he is guilty and I can bet on the fact that there is a mastermind behind all this who is moving the pawns around the way he pleases to… and it will be quiet interesting if it turns out that the Singhanias are involved in this in some way.

That's it from me… catch u all with the analysis

Lots of Luv

Anu.

WHo are the Singhanias Anu?

Originally posted by: soapaddict

WHo are the Singhanias Anu?

They are Bani's maternal family. Her mom Kiran was Kiran Singhania and she belonged to a Big Business family in Mumbai.

Anu thanks for clearing some peoples doubts because I was worried and sad when people targetted my sweet Munna Jai yesterday calling him a manipulator 😭 though I agree he was rude but he also saved Banis life just in time risking his own life while she acted foolish becoming female sherlock holmes by visiting a deserted place in the middle of the night😡

OF course!!! How could i forget. BEtween the dixits, the shukla, the cobras, ooppa.. the chopras, the non name Jigs and Aditya family and the Walias.. I forgot about the Singhanis.

Makes total sense. Maybe its the patriarch or matriarch of the Singhania family.

Bani is the sole waaris. And when her mom was killed... she went back to Mt. Abu to be with her supposed dad (nishikant, who was only Pia and Rano's dad), and Jai decided to give him money to keep his mouth shut. Taking the money made him guilt ridden and led to alcoholism. And in the meantime, the Singhanias have been waiting for their time to make a move!

Ok, I really need to get a life..

I completely agree Anu...i mean the way he said that fine he will tell her...the man was scared the possiblity that if he didn't come on time what could have happened to her scares him....although hes yet to admit he is hook line and sinker in love with her...if i was in his position before telling someone something distressing you always give the affects so Jai did exactly that. he explained to Bani what he's been going through and what he will go through...instead of blackmail i think its more embarassment...if you've done something bad in life really bad you dont want the person you love the most to know...because your scared it will cloud there judgement of you and leave....so in all Jai tells Bani that she will need to leave because he probably cant bear the fact that she will leave him first once the raaz is out, so his way is less painful...and the raaz well we will find out soonish what it is...i still reckon its tony the guys starting to creep me out...again excellent analysis Anu 😃

Sorry Anu but I disagree. I've said in another post, and I say it again that Jai emotionally blackmailed Bani. Bani even noted how easily Jai could say he would never see her face again, he didn't care about the effect it had on her, he was only concerned about his own ego! 😡 How could he face Bani, after torturing her for months, and now telling her he killed her mother? Its all about Jai.

I also think he's a coward, he unleashed all his frustration and anger on Bani when Pia ran away, but he is now afraid of the Park Road backlash. Wouldn't Bani respect him more for his honesty? When the truth does eventually come out, won't Bani think the same thing? And the fact that he let himself be blackmailed by Cobra and Mamba (Roshni and Ranvijay)? Whats the use hiding the secret when half of Mumbai already knows it?

I don't think Bani's dad is to blame. The poor man had to mortgage his house and gave everything to care for Kiran before she died. If Jai caused the accident, and Nishkant was financially incapable of caring for Kiran, Jai should have coughed up.

Whatever may have happened, until evidence to the contrary is shown, I blame Jai for the Park Road accident because his behaviour implies he is guilty!

Originally posted by: PriyaS

Sorry Anu but I disagree. I've said in another post, and I say it again that Jai emotionally blackmailed Bani. Bani even noted how easily Jai could say he would never see her face again, he didn't care about the effect it had on her, he was only concerned about his own ego! 😡 How could he face Bani, after torturing her for months, and now telling her he killed her mother? Its all about Jai.

I also think he's a coward, he unleashed all his frustration and anger on Bani when Pia ran away, but he is now afraid of the Park Road backlash. Wouldn't Bani respect him more for his honesty? When the truth does eventually come out, won't Bani think the same thing? And the fact that he let himself be blackmailed by Cobra and Mamba (Roshni and Ranvijay)? Whats the use hiding the secret when half of Mumbai already knows it?

I don't think Bani's dad is to blame. The poor man had to mortgage his house and gave everything to care for Kiran before she died. If Jai caused the accident, and Nishkant was financially incapable of caring for Kiran, Jai should have coughed up.

Whatever may have happened, until evidence to the contrary is shown, I blame Jai for the Park Road accident because his behaviour implies he is guilty!

woah priya you really have it in for Jai don't you😆😆😆 i have to disagree with you because i think jai gave her that ultimatum first so she wouldn't have a choice if she found out the raaz and left him first..it would kill him inside...so this way its less painful hes told her to go first....im sorry but what happened to innocent till proven guilty...you dont know the circumstances...his behaviour shows guilt i agree but that doesnt mean he committed the crime...it could mean he was a part of it...or he witnessed it....?either way we will know today...in regards to his vengence,,yes he was harsh to Bani at first but now he is more than making up for it...and look at Bani she's so happy....

I totally agreee with Anushka.

His words were too powerful for Bani.

if pia or roshni wanted to know the truth , they would listen to what Jai had to say and they would try and break all Jai promise given to them.

One thing i could not understand when Nishikant is dead then why was the cheque prepared on his name? is anyone using his name or his account? Is he living and who died was the really nishikant Dixit?

I don't think Jai's intention towards Bani were wrong, or cold even if he did emotionally blackmail her. There was a mixture of guilt and fear for Bani's life, and I think that in his fear he did in a way emotionally blackmail Bani, hoping against all odds that he wouldn't have to reveal the Raaz. I felt that way because in the SMS it said...do whatever you want Bani will find out about the Raaz....which meant in a way that he wasn't ready to tell Bani the Raaz, and hoping that her feelings would keep her from learning it. I don't think it was a cold and calculated move, but rather a desperate one on Jai's part to protect his wife.
I also think that when the Raaz comes out and Bani doesn't leave his side...it will strengthen his faith that Bani isn't someone to betray his faith and loves him to full dedication.