Manyata Slips and Uday wins Round 3 :p

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Gman

@Gman

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: jyoti06

I will like to point out on error of Gardener too. He is partly to blame for the Manyata's badmashi.

When she offered the flowers to Uday. Gardener kept quite and actually was smiling at the Manyata's tantrum or success. Firstly he should never have planted poisonous plant in the garden and secondly he went along and enjoyed the Manyata's plan. When Uday got allergy, he should have run for help. he kept quiet and watch Uday like lamp post. SO he is not totally innocent but Manyata definitely dig grave for him.

Quote

Gman

@Gman

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: jyoti06

Actually what Manyata did yesterday was also very wrong since its almost like playing with Uday's life as those flowers were poisonous but for this the poor Gardener had to pay the price where Uday is very wrong since he knew who was the main culprit here ..thats why I feel both needs to rectify their mistakes here ...

Yuvika, I want to point here something, Gardener is not totally innocent here. he should never have planted the poisonous flowers in garden and secondly he should have warned Uday of its effect when Manyata offered him and thirdly he did not run for help and watched Uday's helplessness like an idiot. To add it, he really enjoyed the Manyata's trick on Uday.

Manyata did dig grave for him but he should not played along with her just because she befriended him. So I did not find Rajmata and Uday decision wrong. That gardener did not fulfill his duty properly i.e., keeping resident or guest away from the poisonous plant.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Gagori Chatterjee

@jyoti06

Alumni

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

#43

@Gman:I agree the gardener was also at fault along with Manyata and so deserved a punishment but my issue is whether the punishment given to the gardener was valid here when Manyata too did same mistake but in the name of punishment she was only given another warning by Rajmata who told her that she will repent this for her life that gardener lost his job because of her while the Gardener was severely punished wherre he had to loose his job forever for that same mistake ...I found Gardener's punishment a bit too harsh than Manyta's punishment when both sort of committed similar mistakes ...I would hv preferred if gardener was given a cut in his salary as punishment than directly sacking him

Quote

Gman

@Gman

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: jyoti06
@Gman:I agree the gardener was also at fault along with Manyata and so deserved a punishment but my issue is whether the punishment given to the gardener was valid here when Manyata too did same mistake but in the name of punishment she was only given another warning by Rajmata who told her that she will repent this for her life that gardener lost his job because of her while the Gardener was severely punished wherre he had to loose his job forever for that same mistake ...I found Gardener's punishment a bit too harsh than Manyta's punishment when both sort of committed similar mistakes ...I would hv preferred if gardener was given a cut in his salary as punishment than directly sacking him

I find Rajamata's decision to punish the Manyata was duly she deserved one. Living whole life with guilt that someone had to loose his job because of her insensitive prank on others will make her to think twice of consequences of her actions/pranks on others. She needs this lesson.

Gardener is too at his biggest fault by planting such poisonous plant in the garden. If he had not planted in first place, this scene will not have come into existence. So he deserved his punishment too.

After today's episode, Punishment to both guilty parties evaporates into thin air by merely Uday's apology to Manyata infront of whole household.

Edited by Gman - 13 years ago