Poll

how did dhananand really die

Login To Vote
bhaiyyaji thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
hey folks

made this poll thought it be excited for us to get some knowledge. please vote and leave your comments

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

13.2k

Users

3

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

702755 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
both he did sent him to exile but after that he killed him
bhaiyyaji thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: LUCYKAEDE1

both he did sent him to exile but after that he killed him

u sure he sent to him exile and then killed him i heard he sent him on exile but never heard that he kill him some historians say they never heard of dhananand after that but if he was such tyrant he wouldnt have let CGM live in peace so maybe you are right.

and why would he send him on exile if he had to kill him later on which i dont understand. but anyways we see what happens, and wouldnt that make CG cruel. why would durdhara marry him if he kills her father after sending him on exile so many questions
702755 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: bhaiyyaji

u sure he sent to him exile and then killed him i heard he sent him on exile but never heard that he kill him some historians say they never heard of dhananand after that but if he was such tyrant he wouldnt have let CGM live in peace so maybe you are right.

and why would he send him on exile if he had to kill him later on which i dont understand. but anyways we see what happens, and wouldnt that make CG cruel. why would durdhara marry him if he kills her father after sending him on exile so many questions


ok here it is,dhanananda had totally same situation as gaddaffi,internally his power was snatched by cgm by war and then they made dhanananda to leave magadha but after that on his way his people killed him.durdhara never liked cgm,she never wanted to marry him.her loving him is purely fiction.cgm also never liked her,but she was forcefully married to him for two reasons.
1-people at that time accepted royal families as their ruler so it was a necessity for cgm to marry durdhara
2-chankaya wanted a baby who could succeed cgm
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
In the ACK Chandragupta, they have it that the Vishyakanya killed him. So in this serial, if they are true to that, they might have Mihika have an erotic encounter w/ him, and bite him when he's about to start, so that he dies.

In the ACK, Dhananand & all his sons were killed that way, but in this serial, only one son was mentioned, alongside Durdhara. So they might show that son getting killed. But given that this serial might want to dramatize Chandragupta avenging the death of his parents, they might show him actually kill DN, even though it's ahistorical.

Another question - is CGM likely to be the one to kill Bhadrashal, or will it be Ahilya? The latter has an existing grudge against Bhadrashal, so it would make more sense if he does it, rather than CGM.
bhaiyyaji thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: LUCYKAEDE1


ok here it is,dhanananda had totally same situation as gaddaffi,internally his power was snatched by cgm by war and then they made dhanananda to leave magadha but after that on his way his people killed him.durdhara never liked cgm,she never wanted to marry him.her loving him is purely fiction.cgm also never liked her,but she was forcefully married to him for two reasons.
1-people at that time accepted royal families as their ruler so it was a necessity for cgm to marry durdhara
2-chankaya wanted a baby who could succeed cgm



you got point i know the love track is fictional shown but there isnt much about CGM personal life so it could be anything i think the producers must have really researched hard if they shown 2 characters liking each others. its also said that durdhara fell in love at first sight for CGM but that is not shown in this show rather they made typical love track.

i dont know about CGM falling for her but it could be possibility as they have to show something to take story forward comment back i love to hear your views as you make more sense than me
702755 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: bhaiyyaji



you got point i know the love track is fictional shown but there isnt much about CGM personal life so it could be anything i think the producers must have really researched hard if they shown 2 characters liking each others. its also said that durdhara fell in love at first sight for CGM but that is not shown in this show rather they made typical love track.

i dont know about CGM falling for her but it could be possibility as they have to show something to take story forward comment back i love to hear your views as you make more sense than me


in my defence,i am a history student and my mom is history teacher.
702755 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

In the ACK Chandragupta, they have it that the Vishyakanya killed him. So in this serial, if they are true to that, they might have Mihika have an erotic encounter w/ him, and bite him when he's about to start, so that he dies.


In the ACK, Dhananand & all his sons were killed that way, but in this serial, only one son was mentioned, alongside Durdhara. So they might show that son getting killed. But given that this serial might want to dramatize Chandragupta avenging the death of his parents, they might show him actually kill DN, even though it's ahistorical.

Another question - is CGM likely to be the one to kill Bhadrashal, or will it be Ahilya? The latter has an existing grudge against Bhadrashal, so it would make more sense if he does it, rather than CGM.


with this comment you are challenging chanakya intelligence directly,there is no way killing by vishkanya make cgm a samrat.it needed proper political thing,cgm made army and made a revolt against dhananda,he was captured,sent to exile and killed.it was just like how gaddafi got killed.
bhaiyyaji thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
good am enjoying the debate k then Lucky i can call you lucky cant i can you tell me if Mura was alive during CGM reign or has history been changed. some say yes on this forum but there isnt any proper evidence just wondering if you got it i know some have tried answering it but i didnt get proper answer what i looking for you know
702755 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: bhaiyyaji

good am enjoying the debate k then Lucky i can call you lucky cant i can you tell me if Mura was alive during CGM reign or has history been changed. some say yes on this forum but there isnt any proper evidence just wondering if you got it i know some have tried answering it but i didnt get proper answer what i looking for you know


mura's is mentioned in mudrarakshasa and puranas,historians most probably disagree that his mother's name was mura.they think that his name maurya was from a republican clan,moriya of pipalihalivana.this is mentioned in mahabodhivansh sutta and mahavansh.i am lucy not lucky if you are referring to me.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".