what poignant scenes between Maan Geet today. - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.5k

Users

16

Likes

144

Frequent Posters

ninand thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: naamteeg

@ninand..
@skg267..
@pippa..

love all of your in depth analysis about Maan and Geet's characters.. it kind of fills in all the blanks that the CVS can't show or put forth in a 30 min episode..

There is something that has been nagging me since the ML started... why do you guys think the CVS have not yet made Maan show some curiosity about his marriage to Geet.. they haven't yet shown him asking how he ended up marrying someone he just knew for a short time, and who she was and how they paths crossed?...
Is it because Maan was bogged down with this unexpected relationship that he felt was being pushed on him? Now that he is been given breathing room by Geet will he be showing some curiosity and try to explore those questions??

What is your take guys... would love to read your different ideas... thnx




I for one thing,believe that his not wanting to ask, is very natural.

Initially, when he first woke up to this condition, it gave him a feeling of having lost control.
He could not make sense out of the changed behaviors of everyone around him .

Suddenly everyone had started taking liberties with him , teasing him, and coming out with their disapprovals and complaints very frankly.
That was a shock to his already shocked system. No one had dared to so that before. even daadi ma seemed to have more authority in her voice as she expected him to do her bidding.(All the scenes where Daadi and Dev expect him to apologise to Geet when they did not know about his ML).

The cold reserved man that he was, he had to immediately take action. That did not involve showing his vulnerability and asking people about his past.
Yes, that is what Maan Singh Khuana would have felt- that asking about his past would leave him open to others.

SO he gets busy re-establishing who's the boss in the place.

Then, also, his brain would not allow him to dwell too much on the matter. For someone who's a control freak like him, thinking of the lost time would unsettles and disturb him greatly.

now, coming to the Man after he gets to knwo about Geet.

Hes told that she is his wife. Hes flabbergasted. he cant even stand the mere presence of the girl, and here hes married to her! he finds nothing in common or even remotely significant in that rustic, ill-educated woman.
He starts off with despising her. He still is in a state of disbelief over his marriage. and thus all the temper tantrums. In this case, like hell will he want to know more about them- him and her. It would only madden him further.

Now , theers a distinct change in him after the Teej fiasco. it was after dev's little monologue that he actually realizes that she not at fault.
Even then , after trying so much , he cannot accept her. Moreover his family is forcing him into believing in the marriage.

This suffocates him, frustrates him to the core, .. he cannot just grow feelings for her out of practice or trying. And he cannot follow with pretending either.

This tells us again , why he wouldnt want to know about his past. His one dialogue today- that all this is just a story to him. Even if he sits down and watches their video of marriage, the Maan in that video would be an absolute stranger to him.
their would be simply no connection.Itw oudl be equal to listening to the story from others.

Besides, once again , the same love story over and over again , the same expectations, the knowledge that 'he had substantially changed in her love' would make any foray into the past impossible.

HooH! I hope I made sense.

Lord! I am possessed today it seems!!😳 I take no responsibility of this rambling, you asked for it.😳
naamteeg thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: ninand


I for one thing,believe that his not wanting to ask, is very natural.

Initially, when he first woke up to this condition, it gave him a feeling of having lost control.
He could not make sense out of the changed behaviors of everyone around him .

Suddenly everyone had started taking liberties with him , teasing him, and coming out with their disapprovals and complaints very frankly.
That was a shock to his already shocked system. No one had dared to so that before. even daadi ma seemed to have more authority in her voice as she expected him to do her bidding.(All the scenes where Daadi and Dev expect him to apologise to Geet when they did not know about his ML).

The cold reserved man that he was, he had to immediately take action. That did not involve showing his vulnerability and asking people about his past.
Yes, that is what Maan Singh Khuana would have felt- that asking about his past would leave him open to others.

SO he gets busy re-establishing who's the boss in the place.

Then, also, his brain would not allow him to dwell too much on the matter. For someone who's a control freak like him, thinking of the lost time would unsettles and disturb him greatly.

now, coming to the Man after he gets to knwo about Geet.

Hes told that she is his wife. Hes flabbergasted. he cant even stand the mere presence of the girl, and here hes married to her! he finds nothing in common or even remotely significant in that rustic, ill-educated woman.
He starts off with despising her. He still is in a state of disbelief over his marriage. and thus all the temper tantrums. In this case, like hell will he want to know more about them- him and her. It would only madden him further.

Now , theers a distinct change in him after the Teej fiasco. it was after dev's little monologue that he actually realizes that she not at fault.
Even then , after trying so much , he cannot accept her. Moreover his family is forcing him into believing in the marriage.

This suffocates him, frustrates him to the core, .. he cannot just grow feelings for her out of practice or trying. And he cannot follow with pretending either.

This tells us again , why he wouldnt want to know about his past. His one dialogue today- that all this is just a story to him. Even if he sits down and watches their video of marriage, the Maan in that video would be an absolute stranger to him.
their would be simply no connection.Itw oudl be equal to listening to the story from others.

Besides, once again , the same love story over and over again , the same expectations, the knowledge that 'he had substantially changed in her love' would make any foray into the past impossible.

HooH! I hope I made sense.

Lord! I am possessed today it seems!!😳 I take no responsibility of this rambling, you asked for it.😳


yup, taking into consideration MSK's nature and the current situation he is in at present, what you say makes total sense.. thanks😊

Now I wonder if he will ever try to find out why and how it happened or will he just start recollecting bits and pieces of his past and just string them together... can't wait to see how the writters will handle the story from here on..

will keep an eye out for your posts... very interesting posts I must say... hopefully you post most of your posts in the main GF pages. I have never entered any of the group posting as yet. 😆
thanks again for the in depth analysis... 🤗
Edited by naamteeg - 14 years ago
gafulu14 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#23
i totally agree! It's ironic
ChurriBurri thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
There love is going day after day. They are pleasure to watch. Geet can't come to an end.
pippa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#25
@naamteeg:

I think ninand has said everything...not much to add to it except that now he's got that load off his chest after that hear-to-heart talk with Geet, he's in a better place and mind set to think about the marriage without any outside pressure.

I think we'll catch him thinking about Geet more often, take note of her, not just of her looks but as a person.May be try to relate to her as an individual and in the course of that attempt, try to wonder and hopefully understand the qualities that Geet possesses which would have attracted him to her before the ML.

Geet will quite likely insist that both Dev and Dadima leave Maan alone and not pressure him to accept her.

Once he becomes his own man, his relationship with Geet is bound to change and flower.
Edited by pippa - 14 years ago
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#26
@naamteg:

I agree with ninand and pippa and think it is quite natural that he hasn't asked about his relationship with her, as from the beginning Dev and Daadi put him in a position of weakness every time they bring Geet up, as they insist on a relationship he can't remember. And MSK hates being made to feel weak and out of control. Geet put him back in a place of strength and control yesterday, where she knows he is most comfortable, and I think that will make a huge difference to him now. Like pippa said, he will operate as his own man and things can go from there.

Also to add one thing, I got the feeling that before he heard Geet voice her own feelings and not be vouched for by either Dev or Daadima, he didn't take the whole situation very seriously at all. I think this is why he was so ready to believe her guilty of all the things NT framed her for. In his current state, it just makes more sense that Geet is a gold-digger, or a conniving girl out to ruin his career. If this turned out to be true, he could throw her out of the house and his life would go back to normal so he was desperate for her to be someone he could hate. It is only when he heard the hope coming from her mouth (when she was telling Daadi he was changing) that he really understood their relationship was a very real thing to her and started acting likewise.

Hoo! Have you gotten more explanation than you bargained for? 😆

@ninand: I am so glad you liked my epic post! I had good fun writing it. I do post quite often actually, long, never-ending character analyses, most of the time. I can send you some links if you want...😊
Edited by skg267 - 14 years ago
jasw thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#27
Lovely analysis by you guys! I just love this kind of thought provoking analysis and this takes me to the older days when each action by the leads used to compel some of the articulate viewers to write their views. The beauty and the charm of the old episodes are coming back! (I really don't know how any sane person can think of ending such beautiful serial)

Kudos to CVS for taking the cliched story of memory loss to such greater height, the credibility of the story makes us all glued to it. I just loved the way both Maan and Geet opened to each other with full honesty and truth. Yes, the situation is very poignant and yet so beautiful!

naamteeg thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: skg267

@naamteg:

I agree with ninand and pippa and think it is quite natural that he hasn't asked about his relationship with her, as from the beginning Dev and Daadi put him in a position of weakness every time they bring Geet up, as they insist on a relationship he can't remember. And MSK hates being made to feel weak and out of control. Geet put him back in a place of strength and control yesterday, where she knows he is most comfortable, and I think that will make a huge difference to him now. Like pippa said, he will operate as his own man and things can go from there.

Also to add one thing, I got the feeling that before he heard Geet voice her own feelings and not be vouched for by either Dev or Daadima, he didn't take the whole situation very seriously at all. I think this is why he was so ready to believe her guilty of all the things NT framed her for. In his current state, it just makes more sense that Geet is a gold-digger, or a conniving girl out to ruin his career. If this turned out to be true, he could throw her out of the house and his life would go back to normal so he was desperate for her to be someone he could hate. It is only when he heard the hope coming from her mouth (when she was telling Daadi he was changing) that he really understood their relationship was a very real thing to her and started acting likewise.

Hoo! Have you gotten more explanation than you bargained for? 😆

@ninand: I am so glad you liked my epic post! I had good fun writing it. I do post quite often actually, long, never-ending character analyses, most of the time. I can send you some links if you want...😊


"Hoo! Have you gotten more explanation than you bargained for? 😆"

Haha.. never too much when it concerns MAANEET.. thanks a bunch for all your inputs SKGPIPNIN😆...

"In his current state, it just makes more sense that Geet is a gold-digger, or a conniving girl out to ruin his career. If this turned out to be true, he could throw her out of the house and his life would go back to normal so he was desperate for her to be someone he could hate."

So it's history repeating itself.. the pre-geet Maan as well accused Geet of many nasty things just so that he can curb his feelings for her... so the next step, if my memory serves me right is, for him to stop curbing what he feels for her and to admit to himself that it is not that bad to "harna" and show his emotions.. like he did the first time around when he watched her drying her hair...

And the rest of the relationship will grow as Maan comes to know about Geet's character and strengths as they go through life's ups and downs as they did the first time around before the ML and what you so beautifully explained in your post to ninand in the previous page (the one you called epic😆).. just loved it...
Edited by naamteeg - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan

4 years ago

Geet ff do dil part 7 on page 6

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan

1 years ago

Geet teaching kis*

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127
Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

3 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Chup Chup ke Part 40 on page 66- 24/6/25

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts

4 months ago

Maan Geet SS || The Unyielding Heart||

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m

3 years ago

Maan Geet new Ss Binding by Love Pt 29 page 47- 10/1/25

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".