Originally posted by: AishuJSKfan
@Rehan, yes, the Satcitananda philosophy is what we're after. But there's actually a difference between the mind and the soul. Also, how can you claim that materialism leads to peace. As far as we know, all we're doing with materialism is creating weapons of mass destruction. And I'm not saying that there should be a stop to progress, neither is Prabhupada. Yes, we should obviously have progress, but still lead spiritual lives. For example, there should be an end to the pursuit of material happiness. You shouldn't have to work like an animal 6 hours a day, five days a week, to be happy. That is a conditioned soul.
btw, I didn't ask if you were a fan of Prabhupada.
Mind and soul are as much different as mass and energy. In physics we have mass-energy equivalence and in metaphysics we call it mind-soul equivalence. Einstein formulated the former while Buddha had spoken of the latter nearly 2400 years prior to Einstein. Both the equations are afterall the manifestations of each other and contain the deepest secrets of our universes.
As I said, we have a very obscure idea of materialism today. As per most religious leaders of these days, materialism means extreme indulgence in personal pleasure, riches, greed and violence. But as per our ancient scriptures definition materialism is exactly opposite to renouncement. But I had said, balance needs to be maintained between materialism and spiritualism. Life is all about balance. For example, when Asoka took up Buddhism he gave up expansionism but he didn't surrender weapons - he still maintained the world's largest army because he knew if he gives up weapon and disbands his army, his entire empire shall be in disarray and peace shall be gone for ever.
As per Mahabharata, Krishna advised Arjun to be fully armed with all weapons of mass destruction (then known as Divyastras) much before the war was perceived and himself oversaw the largest bloodbath of his time with his ruthless strategies. War is never a desirable event, but at times when there's only choice between war and nation's dishonour, war is imperative. Besides weapons are not merely for waging war. They are actually for preventing war. Weapons of mass destruction are used as Weapons of Deterrence. In Military science, we have a proverb - 'The best weapon is the one which is never used'. Being religious need not mean being unpragmatic. Idealism has no place in politics or military - Mahabharata is the greatest proof of that. Indians, who have been attacked and savaged by rogue state and non-state elements more than often, should know this better than anyone else.
LOL. Once again you took my careless gesture in a more serious light. I merely tried to say that though I am not a fan of Prabhupada or ISKCON, I do agree with this point. That's it. 😊
Edited by Darklord_Rehan - 14 years ago