THE AUTOPSY OF TODAY'S EPISODE (24.06.2011) - Page 2

Originally posted by: chiru_

Deewana group - Nice harmony but somehow couldnt enjoy their performance this time. They can do even better

Seema - The kid got talent but its just not her day. Bad song selection

Geet - Every episode is rock for him. Got bored as soon as he started singing (screaming???)

Last Minute - As usual no harmony. They seem good enough for choirs

Sahiti - Am very glad she won best performance as well as SLB's rose.. Truly deserving. I want to see her win the show

Kartar - This time i dint have to sing the lyrics myself. I dont see why they make 63yr old uncle dance when he's struggling even to remember lyrics.

Nirmitee - Never enjoyed their performance but today was something.

Shovon - I guess he missed Sonu a bit too much., more than Seema i could say. He is my favourite after Sahiti

Amit - Like someone said on this forum, he finally realized this is a singing show. Good going

Piyush - He was just ok but if doesnt buck up soon he'll be out in no time

Sajda sisters - Enjoyed their performance. Nothing much to say

Simply my POV. Hope i dint offend anyone :)

Originally posted by: scinerd

Thanks for the awesome analysis, I agree with a lot of what you said but not all of it. I thought Piyush was good, not great. Song did suit his voice. I thought

seema was horrible, it didn't suit her.

Last minute, girls, I fast forwarded it. It hurt my hears to much. No harmony and way to pitchy.

Amit did a good job but I think the fact that he was concentrating so much took away from his overall performance. , I'm sure sherya has a small crush, he is very good looking and her age! but she still does come across very professional.

Geet was trying to hard. Kartar ji is cute, but it was like any uncle singing.

Shati was really good! But I actually thought bhoomi did a better job and that is very rare to hear that. But she still was really good, its a very western song, so I applaud her for how well she did.

Nirmtee, love them. They did a great job, it wasn't there best but it was still way better than most. They know true music! I think they are very different, and India doesn't quite get it yet. They harmonize as well as boys 2 men, backstreet boys etc. I personally think two of the guys on that group are good looking, I don't know how you think they are hermaphrodites. Dewanna group, I'm starting to love them more and more too. They rock and they have such good voices all of them! Going from filmy song yesterday to a folk song! They rock!

I think Last mintue + Geet/Kartar ji should be bottom two. Please India don't repeat putting two amazing acts in the bottom again.

Originally posted by: musickimasti

I echo everyone's comments on this show. It truly is one of the worst singing reality shows ever. Piyush who was my favourite in the audition rounds has been pretty weak so far. However, his voice texture is different so I am pretty sure that even if he gets eliminated very soon, he will get singing opportunites in bollywood. Pritam commented about his voice quality in today's episode and said he might do some recordings with him.