Ouster of Vishal (the rickshaw wala guy) [MOD NOTE pg 5

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Preciousa

@Preciousa

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: Hunk101
Vishal had a somewhat good voice but his yesterdays performance wasnt up to the mark, so obviously she would have to select someone else who sang better than him.

But how was the green-eyed lady even close to him, forget being better than him?

Originally posted by: citanuzuki16
I found that Blind Man with his lil son a mere sympathy gainer..

What did he do or say that you see him as 'sympathy-gainer'? He didn't fake his blindness, nor any story, nor his son. 🥱

And can some of the members here please grow up and stop being emotional? You guys tell others to stop 'bashing' a judge and get some knowledge while you guys get personal and bash a person without having any knowledge yourself! If we can't discuss a decision regarding this show then what is the use of even having a forum for any show!?

Edited by Preciousa - 14 years ago

Quote

Fatema-Tuz-Zohora

@fzohora

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#42

From now on i won't reply to this thread...Before i go, let me clear myself...I have no problem with the topic starter nor the Contestant Vishal...Even i'm sad that Vishal left out... Its an open forum..So i think people have the right to defend also...Anyone can criticize...Thats not my headache...the topic starter pointing the respective judge "Shreya Ghoshal" in an aggressive way.. Thats my only problem.. "but I think Shreya rejected him, because she felt she was incapable of being a mentor to him. He needs someone much more senior and experienced to be able to bring out his true talent. Shreya simply didn't have it in her to be up for the challenge." - This is the quote from the topic starter...Don't you guys think its a bit aggressive ??? Everyone has the right to critize without bashing or attacking each other or the singers or the judges. - It's from the Mods!!

I didn't use any bad words or aggressive words here...U guys can check my previous posts in this thread... (for those who Accused me as "Bashing forum members")

And plz read the whole convo before commenting or Accused someone... You guys can criticize...No one will come to defend but don't be so aggressive towards the respective judges or singers which may hurt other forum members... Thats what i'm trying to say...Thank You!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

428419

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#43

I so agree with the topic starter!I was so mad at Shreya for not taking Vishal!He was such a good guy and his voice really had depth..he did good in the recording round too..I actually liked his voice more than the housewife's voice..🤔

and I thought the mentoring thing was a bit confusing😳..Sanjay's team is OK..but Shreya mentoring above 25 and Sonu below 25?😕I thought it would be the other way round.

Quote

Tweety

@SayCheese

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: Ranbir.Fan
I personally considered Vishal a mere sympathy gainer contestant. I am not saying he didnt have a good voice, but I dont agree with the topic opener atall. I simply dont understand the reason you are bashing shreya for. Shreya will obviously select singers with better singing capabilities & Vishal had many loopholes when it comes to his singing abilities. So Shreya's decision was correct.

I completely agree with you. Vishal is a great singer there's no doubt but yes he isn't trained nor has he learnt music and at the end of the day it's a competition. So yes Shreya made the right decision!

Quote

428419

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: citanuzuki16
yes I'm jst bored of these silly emotional dramas...
I found that Blind Man with his lil son a mere sympathy gainer..
I was like O God WTH is this now...
I just hate when people go off with their stories on screen by themselves.
Gimme a break...
Cant they keep their...HEADS HIGH.

When have people become so insensitive in these issues?Sorry..but I think this post is seriously of bad taste..esp the highlighted parts!🤢

Quote

music-a-muse

@music-a-muse

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#46

As an offside, I thought this show was about mentoring contestants with potential X-factor.

so, why would a judge want a ready made "tayyar" singer, who may not have the X-factor?

.Where do they get the chance to mentor a ready singer?

The whole concept of the show is confusing to me😆

Quote

sushrutapandey

@sushrutapandey

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#47

I think he was kicked out to make way for the better looking Amit Jadhav

Quote

citanuzuki16

@citanuzuki16

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#48

Originally posted by: .sb.

When have people become so insensitive in these issues?Sorry..but I think this post is seriously of bad taste..esp the highlighted parts!🤢

I know
I'm a lil rough with these things at times...Am sorry...
I guess I realize now I made a mistake...