koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Why has my post ' Why The Insistence on IG rishta' been closed down ? . In that thread there is not a single bickering , everyone has expressed views very civilly . The view was that girls should not be subject to CONDITIONS in a mrraige , and instead of bowing before conditions , The girls parents should break the Rishta . . What is wrong with expressing this view ? Where does 'INDIRECT BASHING" come in or BASHING OF SAXENAS come in ? Without criticizing Saxenas how are we supposed to present this view ? . I take utmost care NEVER to bash members .........and only discuss the show . . R we not supposed to critique even the SHOW or storyline now ?And how can we do it if we dont say or express that so and so is wrong in his actions ? How can discussion proceed ? . Has some spiteful member ..........A pratigya fan most likely pressed on report button only to spitefully get the thread shut down ? Coz This is becoming a TREND and I wish to bring MOds attention to it . Some Pratigya fans are not only talking about the mental capacities and moral upbringing of Krishna fans but are often clicking on report buttons and getting posts shut down just for the heck of it . . I understand mods r busy and have no time to read every individual post and its easier to shut down the whole thread but its very unfair on members like us who take utmost care to abide by IF rules . . Last time , on SAM4U 's request a closed topic was re opened by mods . He had asked the very same question I am asking ...........that now why is even this topic closed down . . This rule Indirect bashing of character is not allowed is VERY VERY irksome , in this way it becomes difficult to express a view in general . neither do I criticize the actors EVER or the members of the forum .But if I say that tHis action of Saxenas is wrong , Or Pratigyas stand is wrong How do I bash her ? Should I only say I love this show and Pratigya is good ? . So many other posts r there bashing and bashing this show daily , they r never shut down . Why only this ? Last time stillhopeful's post .a quality humor one was shut down just coz she called Pratigya Princess Pea . Was that any reason to shut a quality post down ? . I fully expect even this post to be shut down but before going I wanted to express my disappointed feelings . Members who directly comment on mental capacities and morality of members r not given any individual warnings [ DYEHARD , Soap bubble and Pragmatic in Anu sarkar's thread] but our posts r shut down just like that . .
I have never encountered this kind of shutting down in any other forum . Following IF rules of never bashing actors or members, I have thoroughly enjoyed being on IF and expressing my views .

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

645

Users

5

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

TheNikil1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
@koolsadhu1000; find this very weird...topic discussed was highly popluar as expected but hardly indirect bashing...Sometimes I find it hard to understand our moderators
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

Kools I support your post...Forum is to post honest candid views be it negative or positive...Everything has two sides...Both sides have to be expressed well...That is called constructive feedback...

koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Kools I support your post...Forum is to post honest candid views be it negative or positive...Everything has two sides...Both sides have to be expressed well...That is called constructive feedback...

I really appreciate the support . I just wanted mods to know what we all are feeling since many days now .
--Hope-- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
OMG Kools you IG post was closed down?

I can never understand this Indirect bashing reason given by mods

we ahev even expressed this disappointment with the harshness of rules before on the rules and regulations thread.

why is it that on threads that support pratigya only the offensive posts are closed down but on your thread or my thread or even other threads (where pratigya or a her actions are not supported) the ENTIRE THREAD is closed down

I think this is very undemocractic. actually very autocratic.

giving a reason to close down popular threads because the posters viewed is not in keeping with popular opinion.

Can the mods please explain what they mean by indirect bashing?

I think that if the mods find a thread has indirect bashing they should either close down the specific post instead of the entire thread OR they should specfically quote the bashing post on the thread and give a warning so the other posters and the original poster can continue posting while ignoring or discouraging the poster doing the bashing

this is less autocratic, is respectful of the rights of the non-bashful posters and helps to encourage non-bashful debtate

Mods r u listening?

Please reopen the IG thread.

What you are doing is not correct.

It hinders free speech
lilindiangurl13 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
there is no need to open a topic for this if you feel it was wrong then just PM us please we are more then happy to hear from you all... and as for your topic it was closed because it was reported so i closed it so i could check it probably... and after going through all the pages i re-opened.... next time please PM us instead of opening topics like this....
Thank You
TOPIC CLOSED
Edited by lilindiangurl13 - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".