viggy123 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Can someone explain to me why Sam is discouraging Mayank? He knows that Nupur is being abused. Rohan had told him that earlier and Mayank must've told him what he saw yesterday. Both times, he had this totally 'pheeka' attitude of 'don't interfere'.

I would've expected more from him. Even if Nupur was a total stranger to them, I would expect Sam and Mayu to stand up for her. Mayu totally lived up to my expectations. On the other hand Sam was a total and absolute let down.

And don't get me started on Gunjan. If 'Chintoo' was the reason they left Morena, how can it take her so long to remember that? It's only been 4-5 years since they left Morena. But that's a creative call, I guess.

I don't mind the track being stretched because I'm totally enjoying the acting these days. And hope the ending is as beautiful as the beginning and the middle. I really need them to focus on Nupur's recovery and her re-integration into a life of love and hope.

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.1k

Users

15

Likes

123

Frequent Posters

relentless. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Excellent Post Viggy! 😃
Im also pretty suprised to see Sam not encouraging Mayank to stand up for Nupur, yes they are all aware of the fact that she is not their Nupur, but humanity does matter. I really expected much more out of Sam since he was held responsible for everything about the trio's past.
Also, Gunjan suprises me everytime 🤔 I mean she does know who Chintu is, but come on does it that long to figure out an obsessed school kid who is no one but Dhruv himself, but here she does have a reason too, she doesnt know its her Nupur di, and thats why things are more complicated for her now, but yeah its not a century she has completed that she will forget that easily. Oh well, its the CVs call, completely, because if i start with some more loopholes, people will bajaofy my band. And One cant blame the characters anyway, they are just doing what they are asked to do. 😆
Zehnaseeb thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
I totally agree about the Sam thing. I was incredibly dissapointed when he said to mayank that he shouldn't have interfeared. Dhruv was about to beat her up with a belt and he still had that opinion. Okay it's fine they all believe she's not their nupur but on humanitarian grounds how can he not care about a woman being beaten up so cruelly and brutally. 😭 😭
Gunjan well better late than never. 😆But I feel she should've told mayu rather than confronting nupz. I mean if he really was the reason there was no way nupur would ever admit it would she. 😕
spate22 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
I think it's only to drag the storyline!! 😆 I think this a little too much, no??!! I hope the story unfolds soon!! I can't take any more abuse!! 😔 Especially for a show like MJHT!! 😒

Shreya
_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
can u please tell me when it was shown that samrat came to know abt nupur being hit with belts. before this "belt" incident even mayank was completely convinced that she isnt their nupur. it was only after seeing that he hit dhruv! do u literally wanna say that if rather than mayank sam wud have seen dhruv doing all this wud nupur, he wud have remained silent! if u think so then i think u have till date only saw MN in the show n missed all other ppl totally, coz samrat shergill can never be like that.
secondly in yesterday's epi it was nowhere shown that samrat comes to know the reason behind this incident. This "mayank must have told samrat" things dont work in tv soaps...it isnt real life that we can assume things must have been done. A thing doesnt happen till its shown. and till now it has nowhere been shown that sam knows abt the belt incident. so from where does this question comes into play? even while sam was looking after mayank's wounds mayank was all lost n didnt tell sam abt what happened. i request pls dont try to forcefully make posts which motivate bashing...there is simply NO LOGIC behind what u have posted!

if i say that why didnt ever mayank came back to support samrat in the past three years despite that he knew that samrat is not the culprit what wud be ur answer??? certain things cant be justified because cvs dont throw any light on them...n similarly sam is totally unaware abt dhruv's limit of obcession n the belt incident.
Edited by princessyashika - 14 years ago
relentless. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
@Yashika, There has to be a reason for why mayank was beating up Dhruv, and i dont think Samrat is dumb, is he? He could have figured out as to why Mayank was all of a sudden beating up Dhruv, but again CVs don't focus on such issues and thats why they go unnoticed.
viggy123 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
Au contraire mon frere (soeur in this case), this is one track that I don't mind being stretched. Who knows if Mayank and Nupur will get another track worthy of their talent after this.....

What I really want now is for Mayank to dig into Nupur's past...I'm sure he will find something that will convince him that it's really her. And then, I want him to confront Nupur. I hope he's the first one to get through to her and make her admit that she's his Nupur. And then both of them together can take Dhruv on. And honestly, I'm against violence, but in this case, I so wish that Mayank bashes him up one more time. This time with the knowledge that it was his Nupur that Dhruv had hurt for 3 long years.

But somehow, I get the feeling that Sam's going to be the one to find out the truth first.....I hope I'm wrong!
NautankiSaali17 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Easter Egg Contest Winner (2023) Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: princessyashika

can u please tell me when it was shown that samrat came to know abt nupur being hit with belts. before this "belt" incident even mayank was completely convinced that she isnt their nupur. it was only after seeing that he hit dhruv! do u literally wanna say that if rather than mayank sam wud have seen dhruv doing all this wud nupur, he wud have remained silent! if u think so then i think u have till date only saw MN in the show n missed all other ppl totally, coz samrat shergill can never be like that.
secondly in yesterday's epi it was nowhere shown that samrat comes to know the reason behind this incident. This "mayank must have told samrat" things dont work in tv soaps...it isnt real life that we can assume things must have been done. A thing doesnt happen till its shown. and till now it has nowhere been shown that sam knows abt the belt incident. so from where does this question comes into play? even while sam was looking after mayank's wounds mayank was all lost n didnt tell sam abt what happened. i request pls dont try to forcefully make posts which motivate bashing...there is simply NO LOGIC behind what u have posted!

if i say that why didnt ever mayank came back to support samrat in the past three years despite that he knew that samrat is not the culprit what wud be ur answer??? certain things cant be justified because cvs dont throw any light on them...n similarly sam is totally unaware abt dhruv's limit of obcession n the belt incident.



Yashi🤗
👍🏼
No more comments!😆




relentless. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
@Viggy, i totally agree. I somehow want Mayank to know about his Nupur "first" because i really want him to beat up Dhruv and send him behind bars for abuse, harrasment and torture. And you're right, im loving this track and i hope they stretch it 😉
Edited by Yamini.Arjun - 14 years ago
viggy123 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Yashika, that's my opinion. Can we please be a little more mature and less defensive about this? Everybody who views the show is going to interpret it a little differently. What I read between the lines may have gone totally unnoticed by you and vice versa. It seemed very obvious to me that Mayank would've told Sam the truth. There was no reason for him to hide it.

What I posted can in no sense, shape or form be considered bashing. Please do not stifle other voices in the guise of 'preventing bashing'.

And to your other point, I totally agree with you that Mayank was not right in blaming Samrat. But he had lost his wife. So in my view, he needed someone to blame until he was ready to face the truth. You're free to disagree!
Edited by viggy123 - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".