Creatives Should take their own direction
I think this a poor choice. I wish AR lovers (actually KSG lovers) would see that. If creatives invest in Shilpa I think it is a bad move on their part. They are just going to split the audience. The AR lovers are louder complainers than anything else, if you bring I started watching the right before she left, and it made no difference to me. I think Jennifer is by far the best Rids.
I have not seen shilpa on anything else since. Plus the look of the female leads on the show is more sophisticated now than three years ago. Do you think shilpa can carry that off.? I also think shilpa created the hype for her to come back by going to the media with her Telly Tadka interview. In real life if someone asks you if you are interested in a job versus a offering a real job. YOu do not go and tell everyone I have a job. She does not seem sincere.
I feel like KSG can carry chemistrry with anyone. Even if you brought Naina back it work better than Shilpa. I just feel the demographic has changed. I think the demographic demanding Shilpa is really demanding AR.
If the creatives got off the love triangle and progressed a sid Rid love story and Aarmaan friendship/love story the fans would move on.