Judges being to diplocamatic ...

Page

Next Last

Shubham Gulati

@shubham150

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

I believe that judges are being diplomatic in some cases ....they r being biased .. they r being unfair ....

for eg ... Swaroop did't do anything great ....and he is actually not an indian ido material .. but still judges are applauding him like anything ......for swaroop's performance .....all of you must hav noticed how harsh his voice was sounding( i appreaciate that he did made an effort , despite his throat not doing well ) ...but still he was not good ... you cannot cover up things like this ..... for me he is that much good ,...... and he is NOT AN INDIAN IDOL material ...

in case of manisha also ... they should have openly said to her that whatever u hav done .. is really bad .... she's like really awful there .... she completely lost it ..... still judges were like its ok ....
salim was like teaching her how to manage that .. despite her clearly saying that u dont deserve to b here ...

i really dont like this ..

what u say guys ???

Quote

Frequent Posters

fierzer

@fierzer

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

Contrary to your own opinions, Swaroop is a great find for Indian Idol. Maybe you don't personally appreciate his voice texture or quality, but there's a reason why the judges have been complimenting him. So again, we're all entitled to our own opinions; doesn't mean one is 'right' and one is more 'wrong' than another. It's getting annoying hearing people continually complain about Swaroop not being 'so great' because he's unconventional.

And yes everyone knows Manisha's performance wasn't anything extraordinary, and the weakest of the bunch. But the they're here to improve and be chosen as the next Indian Idol. We all already know she didn't do well, and the judges duty is to help their singers improve. It's beating a dead horse to bash her for her lackluster performance when everyone''s already aware and seen it themself. Plus, we're not in that position, whereas the Judges are apart of the industry and are aware that sometimes mistakes are made in those circumstances; thus a little more forgiving than the rest of us.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

472195

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

yaaa harsh voices this, harsh voices that.........
He has a great and a very powrful voice.....which is going 2 gain success in bollywood......
His performance was one of the best....
I dunno but the contestant who is unique and different is offended and bashed a lot....like Toshi in SVOI...Wen he was in VOI a very few people could understand his singing....
And now Swarup...A raw powerful voice which is singing all kinds of songs with such ease...Even his Kal Ho na Ho was gud enough...
He was praised because he deserved it...Judges are not soo stupid..
now lemme clear smthngs abt Swaroop's singing
1. His voice is his USP.....He's not like every other singer whose voice is nothing special.

2. The throw of words, this thing makes his singing xtremely powerful.

3 The easy control he has over Taalkaari, he never misses any beat. But can improvise the tempo in between by missing the beat deliberately and not going off...

4. U say he's not indian idol material...is singing just about mainstream songs, is bollywood just about playback..No his voice canb create an atmosphere and in some songs can be a playback material as well...

5. He's a fast learner..And is improving step by step unlike all the contestants who haven't shown any improvement except Shashi....

Quote

324284

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: shubham150
I believe that judges are being diplomatic in some cases ....they r being biased .. they r being unfair ....

for eg ... Swaroop did't do anything great ....and he is actually not an indian ido material .. but still judges are applauding him like anything ......for swaroop's performance .....all of you must hav noticed how harsh his voice was sounding( i appreaciate that he did made an effort , despite his throat not doing well ) ...but still he was not good ... you cannot cover up things like this ..... for me he is that much good ,...... and he is NOT AN INDIAN IDOL material ...

in case of manisha also ... they should have openly said to her that whatever u hav done .. is really bad .... she's like really awful there .... she completely lost it ..... still judges were like its ok ....
salim was like teaching her how to manage that .. despite her clearly saying that u dont deserve to b here ...

i really dont like this ..

what u say guys ???

You forgot to mention that Anu Malik applauded yashraj despite giving not so good performance.

Edited by slumdog - 15 years ago

Quote

472195

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: slumdog
You forgot to mention that Anu Malik applauded yashraj despting giving not so good performance.

Heyy ur sooo gud...even I forgot about that....
LOL....

Quote

Jaspal

@JasToronto

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

Hey shubham,

I do not agree with you at all. Please be prepared to see Swaroop in top 3 as he is a very strong and polished singer. He didn't sound perfect in his last performance because he had a kind of throat infection.

Its amazing to watch, how he mixes his folk aalaps and texture in bollywood music, just brilliant stuff.

I'm not a big fan of Manisha anymore. In order to stay in the competiton, she has to come up with some extraordinary performance this time, otherwise she will be thrown out.

Quote

472195

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: JaspalToronto
Hey shubham,

I do not agree with you at all. Please be prepared to see Swaroop in top 3 as he is a very strong and polished singer. He didn't sound perfect in his last performance because he had a kind of throat infection.

Its amazing to watch, how he mixes his folk aalaps and texture in bollywood music, just brilliant stuff.

I'm not a big fan of Manisha anymore. In order to stay in the competiton, she has to come up with some extraordinary performance this time, otherwise she will be thrown out.

Ya did u listen to him.....
U must listen to grown ups...