JUDGES MISJUDGEMENT

Page

Kajal

@coolasice

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

I feel that judges should not comment on the contestants dressing style etc because this show is in search for a good voice & not for Miss India contests. Contestants feel INSECURITY towards there CLOTHES, Like Rakesh told Hussain that he is looking very simple, why he felt that because Sunidhi told Tia that she is a perfect package. If Tia is a perfect package then she should GO & participate in MISS INDIA contest & NOT in INDIAN IDOL. I don't like Tia, Lakshya, Yashraj & Asit

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sunita

@whatsername

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: coolasice
I feel that judges should not comment on the contestants dressing style etc because this show is in search for a good voice & not for Miss India contests. Contestants feel INSECURITY towards there CLOTHES, Like Rakesh told Hussain that he is looking very simple, why he felt that because Sunidhi told Tia that she is a perfect package. If Tia is a perfect package then she shouldGO & participate in MISS INDIA contest & NOT in INDIAN IDOL.
</div>

<div>
I dont like Tia, Lakshya, Yashraj & Asit

because they can sing and also dress well ?

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Twitz

@Twitz

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

I don't rlly care abt their dressing sense. May be Sunidhi finds Tia a package. It's her opinion.We can't rlly say anything to that. I don't judge ppl based on their dressing sense and since it's a singing competition I think judges shld also not focos that much on that.
But yeh i didn't like Tia Bhoomi's performance either. Even Sunidhi said how Tia's sur wasn't that great.

Edited by Twitz - 15 years ago

Quote

rose-girl

@rose-girl

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

They all r very gud singers with gud dressing sense!

It's Sunidhis opinion she can say what ever she think=)

U r just being tooo much negative ryt now.

I dont think it was wrong by Sunidhi to say to Tia tht u r a full package!

Quote

ananya844u

@ananya844u

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Sunita182

because they can sing and also dress well ?

Tia and Asif dress better than they can sing 😊
I would think if someone can sing well and looks good..that should only be an added advantage..on indian idol its almost like..hey this guy looks cool and hep...and what more..he can sing a bit too..!!lets make him the indian idol then!no offence

Quote

Sunita

@whatsername

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: ananya844u

Tia and Asif dress better than they can sing 😊
I would think if someone can sing well and looks good..that should only be an added advantage..on indian idol its almost like..hey this guy looks cool and hep...and what more..he can sing a bit too..!!lets make him the indian idol then!no offence

I dont think the fact that somebody looks good or dresses well should be used against them. Thats all. its realli not their fault that they like to look presentable.

Quote

Safina

@miss_choxz

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

salim and anu are defo not complaining about clothes!!!

as far as tia is consider........sorry no offence but she just lacks something in every department!!! i dnt understand what she has going for her...........especially her singing its not reasy for this seasons competition yet...... my take.........no offence

Quote

mainkyakaroon

@mainkyakaroon

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: coolasice
I feel that judges should not comment on the contestants dressing style etc because this show is in search for a good voice & not for Miss India contests. Contestants feel INSECURITY towards there CLOTHES, Like Rakesh told Hussain that he is looking very simple, why he felt that because Sunidhi told Tia that she is a perfect package. If Tia is a perfect package then she should GO & participate in MISS INDIA contest & NOT in INDIAN IDOL. I don't like Tia, Lakshya, Yashraj & Asit

you are right

Quote

Lady_of_ice

@Lady_of_ice

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

Salim should NOT state that any one contestant is his favourite.

He is definitely affecting the voting pattern with comments like that.

Even if Yashraj is his favourite, he may not be the favourite of millions of us out there.... even if Salim has a favourite in the bunch he should not state it in express terms.

Salim also has to give more constructive feedback.

All of the judges need to look beyond style. It's desh ki awaaz not desh ki model.

Of course, the singer does need to be presentable, but that's really the bare minumum requirement.

It's about Singing! so we need to sort our priorities out at an early stage.

Quote

Kajal

@coolasice

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#10

Originally posted by rose-girl

They all r very gud singers with gud dressing sense!

It's Sunidhis opinion she can say what ever she think=)

U r just being tooo much negative ryt now.

I dont think it was wrong by Sunidhi to say to Tia tht u r a full package!

It is not abt negative attitude. I do agree gud dressing sense is needed here, but the first priority is there voice, I don't care what sunidhis opinion is abt Tia but because of her that opinion other contestants are having insecurity being they are better singers than Tia. In all the shows I have seen tia is always crying & trying to get sympathy & in the episodes I have seen that among all the other contestants Tia is promoted a lot. If all (including the judges & the ppl) think that tia is a good singer then make her indial idol & finish of the show. No offence.

Edited by coolasice - 15 years ago

Quote

1 2

JUDGES MISJUDGEMENT

Related Topics

Explore Topics