Now for the most difficult part of my recap – rating the contestants. One would imagine the hardest part of rating dancers would be the lack of a quantified scale. But that's ok, I am not here for ISO 9000 precision accurate ratings. Heck there is no such thing as ratings that even the legitimacy of scaled scores are disputed. Moreover, I am perfectly happy with my personal tastes and subjective ratings.
The real tricky part is communicating personal tastes without rousing a lynch mob. Especially considering that I have been told I am most likely to die at the hands of a lynch mob due to excessive honesty. Apparently people have their life's emotions and sentiments tied to another person's perception. Some people are actually hurt because someone has a different opinion. Unfortunately, I am no psychiatrist otherwise I would have had some valuable advice on basing ones feelings on everyone's opinions. (Half the people in this world are sad because of someone else's opinion - give it some thought). However, I do have valuable advice on the true meaning on freedom of speech and expression: This is the internet kids. Don't take it seriously. 😆
Anyway diving into my no holds barred assessment on the contestants this year. All opinions are strictly personal, you don't have to accept, confirm, embrace, love, agree or do any such thing with them. Your choices are yours (But it does not prevent me from judging your intellect. 😛). These also come well after the finale, to prevent me from unwarranted libel and slander accusations. In an honest attempt to not rouse a lynch mom I swear not to use any words that I usually use to describe - Ann Coulter, Fred Phelps or Sarah Palin.
But seriously, are you kidding me? Why would anyone use those words for them? Being India's top twelve dancing stars is no mean feat and to begin with lets give them all a huge round of applause. 👏
The Underrated:
Our underrated dancers are those dancing stars whose potential was never fully recognized or appreciated by the junta. They are immensely talented dancers who went out much before their time or never garnered the fan base and popularity they deserved.
Kruthi -
By far the most underrated dancer this season has to be Kruthi. Her elimination was a shocker and the worst elimination this season. When she bid farewell to the stage, the stage bid farewell to a great classical dancer who was truly the most versatile too. We as viewers were deprived of many more performances Kruthi would have delighted us with. She truly deserved more appreciation and go further.
One problem I see is that a lot of people do not seem to appreciate Indian classical as much. Contestants fear to perform pure classical, and masters fear to choreograph a full classical performance. Historically, in Indian reality shows audiences has always had an uncanny soft spot for the hip hoppers.
Kruthi's Bharatnatyam on Draupadi cheer-haran was by far the best performance of DID solos and duets, both seasons. She had impeccable expressions, great movements and beautifully conveyed multiple characters. It rightly won the best solo of the season and hopefully, this is a sign of positive things to come - and classical dancers get the appreciation they deserve.
Amritha -
She came from the back and went far ahead. But two things irk me. One, she should have been there all along. Two, she should have gone further.
Amritha was by far the most passionate dancers this season. Not only was she well trained with impeccable base skills, she had a genuine love for dance and was ever eager to learn and do something different. She truly appreciated dance and was the most vociferous in cheering on and supporting her rivals, the hallmark of the most spirited and sporting competitors. She was also the most versatile, in a short period she attempted everything from classical, to Bollywood. From femininely charming to aggressive like Krumping. Another great skill was her ability to create and maintain characters in her dances.
I think people were turned of by her exuberance and loudness. Loud confident girls tend to turn Indian audiences off. Many people seemed to criticize her and think less of her because of her personality. We as an audience need to learn that this is a dance contest, not a personality contest and we have to look beyond the personality quirks for people.
Shashank -
He was the first to go. He had his fans but never seemed to get a following. No one raved about him much or praised him. Most thought he was mediocre and should not be there. Others were irked by his personality and comments. Some will be shocked that I give him this recognition.
The fact is that being a ballet dancer, that to in an international dance troupe is no mean feat. Ballet is one of the most rigid and hierarchical forms of classical dance. It takes years of practice and Ballet trainers are very stringent about their troupes standards. Male ballet dancers are even rarer as male bodies are typically not well built for ballet, and except in certain countries men are not encouraged to do ballet.
I will admit that Shasank did not stand out as much or do something dazzling. But he sure was of a higher caliber than some others who stayed on. When it comes to western classical ballet leads the pack. There is a story telling aspect similar to those in Indian classical dances. We could benefit from more ballet and ballet dancers.
The Underutilized:
There were those dancers who never had a genuine wow moment. They were good, they had their fans, but they just kept falling short. Our esteemed masters somewhere somehow faltered in unlocking the full potentials of these dancing stars. They were undersold and underutilized.
Punit -
Sure he made the final 4, but he was a classic case of underutilization. When he reached the finals a lot of people had the huh! moment. Where did he come from? Why is he in the finals? Does he deserve to be here?
The fact is that Punit is a good and versatile dancer. Throughout the season he showed potential. He fulfilled every dance he received to the best extent. He rarely had a bad dancing day. Yet he never made an impact. He never made a breakthrough. He barely had any dances that would be memorable. He just came, he did well and then he faded back into oblivion. It was hard to recognize and appreciate the talent he had.
The problem herein was poor choreography. I think Remo was ambitious with Punit and wanted to do something unique for him, but it never really reached full potential. His gopeshwar dance ended up being half baked. His MJ impression was really good, but we have seen so many MJ impressions that he did not shine. With the right choreography, I doubt Punit would be so unnoticed.
Nikkitasha -
She had potential. She had fans. She garnered initial popularity. She got the town talking. But she fizzled and faded and ended up being one of the earlier exits.
A classically trained dancer, with grace, poise as well as humility - I totally expected her to be a strong contender. In fact in the very early stages of the season, I deemed her capable of competing with Shakti. That was never to be, after the initial excitement she hit a plateau and never grew. It was like watching a bright flame, flicker then fade away.
Had she not garnered an ardent fan following or recognition for her abilities - I would have called her underrated. But many fans and viewers did have high expectations of her. Her undoing was that her full potential was never unlocked. Even though she danced well she never got a chance to showcase her versatility, or the ability to tackle on anything. With the right moves, she could have been a stronger contender.
Jack -
Ah the cute boy from Norway with his funny silly Norwegian Hindi. Sometimes I honestly do wonder, was his popularity wave due to his adorability factor or due to his dancing.
There is no denying that Jack is a good dancer with great potential. Parvez said that. The same Parvez who mesmerized us with emotional performances stated boldly and clearly that Jack was a a better performer than him and felt genuinely hurt that he was chosen over Jack. Terence said that too. Terence was in awe of Jack's Europop blend of hip-hop that is unlike conventional hip hop.
Unfortunately, I don't think Terence truly managed to extract the full potential out of Jack. Jack went on to be the mediocre dancer who did not excel much beyond hip hop. His performances were recognized as cute, entertaining - but he never garnered the reaction some of the other contestants did. At times he appeared to be heavy on feet and clunky when he was capable of better.
Terence did get a curve ball with Jack. Should he hone Jacks natural hip hop. Should he work on Jacks identification with India and his desire to do Bollywood and folk. Or should he let Jack shine in contemporary. In the end Jack never got the right blend that should make him stick out.
Kishore -
The boy with the crazy hair. He danced with exuberance and his hair danced along with him. He always had lop sided smile on his face and conducted himself with awkward humility.
When Kishore first went in the bottom two, I did not think much of him as a dancer. He was mediocre. Deserving of top 18, but not the top 12. However, as time went on I grew a slight fondness for him. He has a very rustic rawness to his dancing that is very refreshing. Behind his calm face he had a pretty dare devil attitude, immense strength and a willingness to do any sorts of stunts or tricks involved.
As a dancer I thought Kishore could really shine in Indian folk. Especially the folk dances that involve stamina and strength. He could have been a great person to showcase folk and he did have a few memorable ones. Unfortunately, he never really found his signature strength or selling point that some other dancers did. I'm surprised that Geeta ma did not try to make him a folksy dancing star, it would have suited him. Especially considering how fond Geeta is of Indian styles. The result is that Kishore too eventually faded. Maybe not at the wrong time, but he could have made a more lasting impact.
The Overrated:
These are dancing stars who were good and exceptional. They would not be in the top twelve if they did not have extraordinary skill. However, their bark was bigger than their bite. They were able to garner a rapidly growing large fan base and received lots of love and adoration. The problem was that the love of their fans created a larger than life aura about them which was bigger than the talent they could actually deliver. Perhaps cases where their own fans were their Waterloo.
Dharmesh -
He was definitely the most talked about star of the season. Everyone remembers the Vadodra auditions and the mysterious Dharmesh who trained all these dancers. Only to discover that THE Dharmesh himself was an unassuming humble dance teacher who like everyone else aspired to reach for the stars. A mesmerizing dance routine with his simple personality catapulted him to super stardom. People were touting him to win before the contest even started.
While Dharmesh is a great dancer, he is definitely the most overrated dancer in the seasons of Dance India Dance. The bottom line is Dharmesh did not grow at all. His final routine reinstated that his first routine was his best routine. Within his genre he was repetitive and did not garner the mesmerizing perfection or grace that other dancers achieved. He tried different genres but not enough. Barring a few most were half baked attempts which were disappointingly mediocre. He never really seemed at home outside his comfort zone. To me the saddest thing about Dharmesh was that after his auditions and till the last performance, he never really had the smile and ease of a dancer who is on stage comfortable, enjoying and doing their thing. He never seemed fully at home.
The sad thing is that Dharmesh need not have been that way. He could have been creative in his comfort zone and attained perfection. He could have tried more and more genres and with more heart and effort he would actually been really successful at it. He might have even won the second season. He was really close.
The problem was that with the hype of 'sir'. He was already bigger than everyone else no one really cared to push him to his potential. Remo did try a few times, but I think Geeta was too defensive for Dharmesh as were fans.With continuous number ones and growing fans - he never got the push needed to reach the dancer he can become. As fans grew more crazed by the day, the rest of us were turned off by him each day. Such is the burden of fan following at times that it rests heavily on your shoulder as an idolized image that you are not sure you can deliver to. Such is the burden of fan following that instead of pushing you forward it actually holds you back in place where you are - making you the overrated dancer instead of a breakthrough dancer.
It is so true when they say fans can be a double edged sword.
Binny -
One cannot help but admire and adore Binny. She truly was a fighter. After being rejected the previous year this untrained dancer came back with renewed fervor this year. It was incredible how far determination can take an untrained dancer. She was a formidable foe for everyone, and really impressed as Geeta's veera in the early rounds.
But then she hit a plateau. Sometime into the top twelve she stopped growing. She hit a period of stagnation where she really did not grow. One could say that she was untrained dancer who came so far. But last years Alisha and this years Amar were both untrained dancer. Both who constantly grew, every performance revealing a new growth in their learning curve. They rarely had a bad day or a performance where they let you down. Unfortunately, Binny has not been able to sustain that ascending curve. In the later stages of the contest she fell behind the level of people she was competing with.
Now I will not blame Binny for her lack of growth entirely. Every growing star hits a plateau. It is natural. Considering that Binny was the only girl left in Geeta's gang at a point, she has danced more routines than anyone else in the show. Some of the growth that usually is reserved for crucial stages was exhausted in the early rounds. As a human I feel fatigue and pressure also set in, and she did handle it well mostly.
Had people not been so much in awe of Veera, I think she could have been made aware of the plateau. I'm confident if made aware she would have taken her dancing to the next level and strived to be on par with the contenders. Another case where adulation can shield one from growth.
Saajan -
Saajan is to b-boying as Prince is to locking and popping. Two young boys, two raw dancers, two boys who introduced an entire nation to a whole new genre of dance. Saajan single handedly gave B-boying the popularity and hype it has attained in India. Now every kid wants to be cool doing some hot b-boying moves.
The question is whether that is enough to make one a dancing star. B-boying is one sub style of dancing. A true dancing star has sound fundamentals, shows perfection potential as well as versatility. As a self taught dancer Saajan's fundamentals were shaky. Even as a b-boy he had the moves and the tricks, but a street dancer would tell you that Saajan did have to work on rhythm and get his b-boying groove right. The shaky fundamentals were a barrier from him being versatile and multifaceted. He came much further than he actually ought to have.
A lot of people are in awe about b-boying. It is a very tough dance which requires immense strength and practice. I wont take that away from it. However, it is not a formal dance form that has rigorous training. Most original b-boys learned to dance on the streets. As a free form dance it has signature tricks and moves, but has a lot of room for self variation. Original breaking was only amidst some black and latin communities. Over time Asians and girls too have become self taught street dancers and breakers. A large number of breakers are self taught or street taught. It is only in more upper crust areas and in other places where street style breaking is formally taught. So in that context the hype over him self teaching b-boying is actually overdone.
That being said Saajan was definitely good at what he did and no one can take away the fact that he created this years trend. Moreover, he is young and willing with plenty of room to grow - in b-boying as well as dance as a whole. Hopefully, he takes this break given by DID to do exactly that - because he has a long way to go.
to be continued.....
Next: Dynamic Duo - Shakti & Amar