Round 2: Mahalaxmi Iyer

Udit has overshadowed her in this song, the lines which she sang were nice. I would give her a 7.

One of my favourite songs!..this will be difficult to evaluate..lets see..

Starting is beautiful, I just love the way Udit ji sings "Yeh Badal ki Chaadar, Ye Taaron Ke Aanchal..". Anyways, coming back to Mahalaxmi's singing here, the ductility in the singing is there, it is pleasant the way she starts from a low note then rises to a higher note. There is calmness and elegant beauty in her voice, which is clearly portrayed here.

However, I felt the throw could have been more powerful like Udit ji's. I won't say that this was an easy song, because it is quite difficult to sing in the lower notes. I believe that Mahalaxmi has been able to retain her magic here. I will deduct marks on the basis of low energy and lesser throw of the voice. Also, I felt Mahalaxmi is not given much scope for singing here as compared to the male-counter part, that is one the reason that she is not able to create a 'wow' impact.

None-the-less, it remains one of my favourite romantic songs. I would like to give it an 8 out of 10.

Originally posted by: saq123

Why is she still here?? Couldnt u find better singers😕