roxthefox thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
"Lagtha hai criticism merey team ke liye hi bani hai"

🤢

Can this talentless woman get any more self absorbed? I feel like Mithin, and the other two masters are scared of her outbursts, and as a result, keep most of their comments to themselves out of fear. Let's face it, she sucks. She's a horrible choreographer with little to no versatility. She got through this season based on sympathy from Mithin (not that his opinion matters, because his vocabulary only contains two words), and Dharmesh carried her through, mostly through his own choreography. Yet, any constructive feedback offered to her contestants, which doesn't praise her contestants to high heavens, results in snarky comments from Geeta. She always tries to justify any criticism by getting defensive, and even hostile. What's the point of having 'judges', if you are going to fight with them when they offer their opinion? It's like having a discussion forum, but not allowing members to post any negative comments. Oh wait....😛 She's a horrible sport, and for the most part, extremely bitter. She praises her incompetent teammates to high heavens, yet always nitpicks at the dumbest things in other performances, in order to make her teammates look better. Can't stand this pompous woman and her lame ass excuses.

Plus, Binny and Dharmesh are two of the worst dancers I may have ever seen. I can pretty much do what Binny does, and I'm not a professional dancer by any stretch. Dharmesh is only good at hip hop, and that too is nothing jaw dropping. He's a crappier version of Prince, and definetely lesser than Puneet.
Edited by set_raj - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

5.4k

Users

20

Likes

126

Frequent Posters

Kabshah thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
I do not think it is appropriate to call someone a bitch. specially when you know that Geeta fans might be participating in this forum. This is wrong
Kabshah thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: roxthefox

"Lagtha hai criticism merey team ke liye hi bani hai"

🤢

Can this talentless woman get any more self absorbed? I feel like Mithin, and the other two masters are scared of her outbursts, and as a result, keep most of their comments to themselves out of fear. Let's face it, she sucks. She's a horrible choreographer with little to no versatility. She got through this season based on sympathy from Mithin (not that his opinion matters, because his vocabulary only contains two words), and Dharmesh carried her through, mostly through his own choreography. Yet, any constructive feedback offered to her contestants, which doesn't praise her contestants to high heavens, results in snarky comments from Geeta. She always tries to justify any criticism by getting defensive, and even hostile. What's the point of having 'judges', if you are going to fight with them when they offer their opinion? It's like having a discussion forum, but not allowing members to post any negative comments. Oh wait....😛 She's a horrible sport, and for the most part, extremely bitter. She praises her incompetent teammates to high heavens, yet always nitpicks at the dumbest things in other performances, in order to make her teammates look better. Can't stand this pompous woman and her lame ass excuses.

Plus, Binny and Dharmesh are two of the worst dancers I may have ever seen. I can pretty much do what Binny does, and I'm not a professional dancer by any stretch. Dharmesh is only good at hip hop, and that too is nothing jaw dropping. He's a crappier version of Prince, and definetely lesser than Puneet.



You are such a bum loser..you make no sense whatsoever..change the title..you have no right whatsoever to call anyone a bitch, you sore loser...you start swearing- now be prepared to get one from Geeta fans too!!!

Express your opinion- but you can express your opinion showing some respect to others sentiments too..
roxthefox thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Kabshah



You are such a bum loser..you make no sense whatsoever..change the title..you have no right whatsoever to call anyone a bitch, you sore loser...you start swearing- now be prepared to get one from Geeta fans too!!!

Express your opinion- but you can express your opinion showing some respect to others sentiments too..



Haha, ya I'm a bum loser, because I'm the one screaming and swearing at others for sharing their opinions. I have every right to call whomever whatever I like, just like you have the right to call me a loser, and I have the right, in return, to call you a douchebag.

You can express your opinions with showing respect to others too, and not calling other people losers, but I guess it only works one way, eh?

Anyway, I have no desire to fight with sensitive children :)
Kabshah thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: roxthefox



Haha, ya I'm a bum loser, because I'm the one screaming and swearing at others for sharing their opinions. I have every right to call whomever whatever I like, just like you have the right to call me a loser, and I have the right, in return, to call you a douchebag.

You can express your opinions with showing respect to others too, and not calling other people losers, but I guess it only works one way, eh?

Anyway, I have no desire to fight with sensitive children :)



Me- sensitive child!! Get a life, sister!! Get a life!!

Expression is your right- but demeaning and degrading- that makes you a sore loser!!! GET A LIFE
pigbelly4myfeet thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
LMAO Totally LOVED your post! 👏

Looks like you were just dying to say all this and take out your badhaas on Geeta in one post. I don't know if I'm right but THANK YOU for writing this post.

I have nothing much to add because you've pretty much stated exactly how I feel about Geeta. She's one of the most annoying judges I've ever seen. She's the perfect example of hypocrisy at it's best.

But seriously what else can you expect from someone who can't even recognize true talent?? Who choses Tina over Amrita??? Who can't differentiate between different dance styles?? Who gets confused between contemporary and freestyle?? Who claims to be an expert in classical but really hasn't shown any such choreography to support this? Atleast we've seen Remo and Terrence promote and SHOW what they're good at. The only reason DID has hieghtened my interest in classical dance is because of contestants like Vrushali, Kruti and Amrita. Geeta did nothing to promote classical dance in India.

I can't stand her, she's just too full of herself. 👎🏼
roxthefox thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: cute2stay

LMAO Totally LOVED your post! 👏

Looks like you were just dying to say all this and take out your badhaas on Geeta in one post. I don't know if I'm right but THANK YOU for writing this post.

I have nothing much to add because you've pretty much stated exactly how I feel about Geeta. She's one of the most annoying judges I've ever seen. She's the perfect example of hypocrisy at it's best.

But seriously what else can you expect from someone who can't even recognize true talent?? Who choses Tina over Amrita??? Who can't differentiate between different dance styles?? Who gets confused between contemporary and freestyle?? Who claims to be an expert in classical but really hasn't shown any such choreography to support this? Atleast we've seen Remo and Terrence promote and SHOW what they're good at. The only reason DID has hieghtened my interest in classical dance is because of contestants like Vrushali, Kruti and Amrita. Geeta did nothing to promote classical dance in India.

I can't stand her, she's just too full of herself. 👎🏼



Believe me, I stopped posting on IF all together. My 'badhaas' towards Geeta was so pent up, that it finally reached a boiling point today and warranted a thread after nearly 5 months of exile. 😛 She always dismisses other talented dancers, without providing any real justification behind her comments. I think a few weeks ago, she made a lame comment about how Shakti's performance wasn't as good because she turned her head at 45 degrees, rather than turning it at 45.5 degrees *rolls eyes*. She always feels the need to belittle other performances in order to prove that her dancers are better, while crying a river at the SHEER AMAZINGNESS of her own team's performances. If her choreography was so good, it would speak for itself, without the need for her to constantly defend herself, often with hostility, towards any criticism.

This show isn't promoting the best dancer. Quiet simply put, it's a competition between choreographers, which Geeta is handling rather bitterly.
Purrrfect thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

It's okay to put your thoughts forward in constructive manner - but the tittle of the topic is very rude. We are not even allowed to start a topic with Caps, here you are with foul language....eeks

roxthefox thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: cute2stay

LMAO Totally LOVED your post! 👏

Looks like you were just dying to say all this and take out your badhaas on Geeta in one post. I don't know if I'm right but THANK YOU for writing this post.

I have nothing much to add because you've pretty much stated exactly how I feel about Geeta. She's one of the most annoying judges I've ever seen. She's the perfect example of hypocrisy at it's best.

But seriously what else can you expect from someone who can't even recognize true talent?? Who choses Tina over Amrita??? Who can't differentiate between different dance styles?? Who gets confused between contemporary and freestyle?? Who claims to be an expert in classical but really hasn't shown any such choreography to support this? Atleast we've seen Remo and Terrence promote and SHOW what they're good at. The only reason DID has hieghtened my interest in classical dance is because of contestants like Vrushali, Kruti and Amrita. Geeta did nothing to promote classical dance in India.

I can't stand her, she's just too full of herself. 👎🏼



Oh, and I agree about Geeta not recognizing true talent. She only picked Dharmesh, because he was a safe bet due to his dancing background. In contrast to someone like Terrence, who picks unconventional dancers, such as Jack, because they're different and unique, and poses a challenge for Terrence. Ah well, Terrence is in a different league altogether. He's not here to compete with other choreographers, but rather, to share his sheer love for dance.

pigbelly4myfeet thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
Honestly I don't even mind her irritating comments about the contestants any more. I simply don't care about what she has to say about anything at this point.

She just appears so fake. I mean even if by accident she praises a contestant (!), other than her own ofcourse, she has to cover it up with a "but it was a good ATTEMPT". Pffttt seriously, learn to appreciate awesome dancing when you see it, Geeta.

It's these things about her that make her comments totally meaningless.

But what I really can't stand about her though is her hipocrisy. And her unprofessionalism. That's what bugs me the most about her. She's like this five year old kid who always has to get her way.

About her hipocrisy though, there have been countless examples of how she's told other contestants to NOT do something and then goes and does the very same things when it comes to her own 'betas'.

Honestly if she was an international judge she would've been fired long ago. It's only because she's in India that she's surviving. She has ZERO professionalism. She doesn't know how to interact with fellow colleagues. And she has no respect for true talent and dance. I honestly don't know why she's in this profession when she clearly has no respect for true talent. All she seems to care about is herself and winning.

Totally agree with you though, that this show is all about the masters instead of the contestants. If judges like Geeta HAVE to be a part of this show, the whole format needs to be changed. Mentors who are choreographing the contestants should not be allowed to judge them as well. Their biasness and comments hold no meaning in that case.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".