3 Idiots Controversy deepnes

now aamir khan is speaking instead of VVC and Raju hirani. 😕

very disappointing .....threatning to drag chetan in court but why 😕 for stealing his story ?....

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6laF2TEYdE[/YOUTUBE]

why they r pushing Abhijat ,co-writer with Raju Hirani, further to drag CB into court why VVC and Raju Hirani r MUM ?

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtzdRz9I5Dg&feature=channel[/YOUTUBE]

that's disgusting. Chetan should drag these people to the court. Gosh atleast admit it's chetan story, not yours.

here is Vid When VVC Said Shut Up to jrns

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngbG_PZMVxQ[/YOUTUBE]

wow 😲 vvc should had calm down. Journalist were just asking, what's the need to insult the journalist? Aamir was very calm.

Originally posted by: Zareena

wow 😲 vvc should had calm down. Journalist were just asking, what's the need to insult the journalist? Aamir was very calm.

exactly and his this anger shows that its his fault .......if they sue CB they themself r gonna lost the case badly

Actually this is one sided. It seems very clear that Raju hirani was CLEAR FROM The start htat 3 idiots is just inspired from 5 Point someone. THey DID give Chetan credit. tHe only difference is its at end credits rather than in the beginning. And WHY SHOUDL they give him so much creidt if ht ebook is so different from the movie?

oh my GOD!! Now they will take Cb to the court? If CB needed publicity he would had filed against 3 Idiots. But he only STATED his feelings on his BLOG!! Is this a crime? WHY is aamir being involved? that's annoy me. It tells who is at fault. If the movie isn't similar to the book at all, why the producer, director and fake writer are hiding? Got SCARED?? I am so disappointed with aamir, he said CB now wants publicity? FOR WHAT??? He has publish FOUR Books and FOUR of them are BESTSELLER!! CB isn't hiding in his home, he isn't telling reporters to SHUT UP, or shouting to the media.

This is a shame! I think CB should take Aamir, Hirani, VVC and the fake write to the court. Aamir says the so called writer worked 3 years on the script? What script?? There are so many similarities which is taken from the movie, even they've changed it, but it was from the book. As CB said what you do to other, will come back to you, well said.

Goodness gracious zareena, they DID give him credit, just not where he wnated. Yes perhaps th emakers should have been mroe flexible, but from what i know, while a lot was borrowed from the book, the movie changed quite a bit of it around. Rather than sayign amking FPS onscreen, it was more liek inspired by FpS

Originally posted by: desigal90

Actually this is one sided. It seems very clear that Raju hirani was CLEAR FROM The start htat 3 idiots is just inspired from 5 Point someone. THey DID give Chetan credit. tHe only difference is its at end credits rather than in the beginning. And WHY SHOUDL they give him so much creidt if ht ebook is so different from the movie?

From the ppl that read the book, the movie is compeltely different. Yes some scenes are taken from in there, but the start, the climax, the story, the journey, the delivery scene, nothing was in teh book. Kareena ends up with SHARMAN in the book. They changed everything in the movie.

they gave him credit bcz they cldnt ignore it bcz it was written in the Contract, if u read his blog he mentioned how they tried to force him to change the line "based on novel "...exact CB's words " What's more, the makers had called me to their office and pressured me several times to withdraw my 'Based on a novel by' credit, which was by contract. They told me they'd replace it with something like 'initiated by' – a credit that doesn't exist anywhere in the world. "

they pushed it towards end and passed quickly, this is not what he deserves.... and they told him they will give him opening credit when they started making the movie

and movie is 70% similar ...and those differences frm the book comes under 30% and when u make a 3 hrs movie its so obvious u have to add songs and stuff so they have to make little bit changes to make a commercial movie that doent mean story becomes ur's ....but the Soul , charachters r all CB's ....and he deserves so......agar woh 5PS na likhta to aaj 3I nahin banti
well u watch that vid where they showed the similarities to know

and having a base story and characters its not difficult to add some changes frm ur own side.....