re-entry wrong?

we all can safely say that the choice of re-entering gurpreet was so so so much wrong as she didn't deserve to be back but if you could choose one whom would you have chosen to replace gurpreet's position in the re-entry?

Originally posted by: stephhh

we all can safely say that the choice of re-entering gurpreet was so so so much wrong as she didn't deserve to be back but if you could choose one whom would you have chosen to replace gurpreet's position in the re-entry?

Nandita because at least 2 guys were interested in her..

I would say both Nandita and Gaurav. That would have made a 4 way tussle in one end Nan-Gau-Viv-Yash and a 3 way tie Rum-Hit-Gau on the other. One in place of Gur (Nandita) one in place of Silkina (Gaurav).

Girls: Pooja or nandita

out of the girls definitely nandita....just b/c yash or uski jodi bann jaathi. bringing gurpreet back was one thing but they also gave her one week where she was safe from elimination....there was no need for that. whereas the new entry silkina wasnt given the same rights. it would've only made sense for silkina to be given immunity for one week b/c both vivek and yash were showing some interest in her.

i agree that gurpreet was the wrong person to come back instead they should have brought Nadita she was better person than gurpreet.

i always wanted gurpreet back!! but now i def agree wid u all!! it was a total waste...!! i am not a big fan of nandita.....i wud hav wanted poo to come back....i wud also hav luved to c more of silkina...she seemed like a decent gal!!