Unfair Eliminations

I NO I HAVE MADE THIS POST BEFORE BUT NO ONE RESPONDED

EVERY SINGLE ELIMINATON IN c2005 BEEN UNFAIR

1. Raktima - was a good singer. did not deserve to go 1st
2. Swananda - was a great singer with a great voice. did not deserve to go 2nd
3. Sharib - the MOST UNFAIR. anyone can tell how trained he is
4. Rajeev - didn't even deserve to be in the top 12
5. Twinkle - deserved to go earlier regarded just her performances in the finals.
6. Ujjaini - deserved to go earlier. She was amazing before the finals but not so great in the finals
7. Paresh - should not have been in the top 12
8. Nihira - VERY UNFAIR - was the most trained singer
9. Himani - ALSO VERY UNFAIR - after Nihira went, she was the best along with Hema
10. Hemachandra - UNFAIR - deserved to go farther than Vinit

What kind of contest is this where EVERY ELIMINATION is UNFAIR???

Pleezzz Respond!!!!

Originally posted by: DizzyBanana21x

I NO I HAVE MADE THIS POST BEFORE BUT NO ONE RESPONDED

EVERY SINGLE ELIMINATON IN c2005 BEEN UNFAIR

1. Raktima - was a good singer. did not deserve to go 1st
2. Swananda - was a great singer with a great voice. did not deserve to go 2nd
3. Sharib - the MOST UNFAIR. anyone can tell how trained he is
4. Rajeev - didn't even deserve to be in the top 12
5. Twinkle - deserved to go earlier regarded just her performances in the finals.
6. Ujjaini - deserved to go earlier. She was amazing before the finals but not so great in the finals
7. Paresh - should not have been in the top 12
8. Nihira - VERY UNFAIR - was the most trained singer
9. Himani - ALSO VERY UNFAIR - after Nihira went, she was the best along with Hema
10. Hemachandra - UNFAIR - deserved to go farther than Vinit

What kind of contest is this where EVERY ELIMINATION is UNFAIR???

Pleezzz Respond!!!!

lolz.. i feel nobody shud ve been oout.. everybody shud ve stayed

😆 every thing is fair in love and war and when grown up mentors are fighting against each other then the ellimation will be unfair as this challenge is not for talent but for mentors self satisfaction

but in coming years...sharib, hema & nihi will surely go high..winners will go down the drain singing for Zee weddings

Hey DizzyB, I agree with your analysis for the most part. But when it is handed to the public to make a choice then this is what we get.
I think many teens and college kids voted for good looking people, ones who could dance well etc. and not necessarily for those who are genuine singers. The aim of SaReGaMaPa was to find the best singer (I think) and not a hyped-up entertainer. In the next SRGMP, Gajji must make some changes or else we will continue to see the same pattern.

Originally posted by: Aawaz

but in coming years...sharib, hema & nihi will surely go high..winners will go down the drain singing for Zee weddings

I think Himani will also make it as she has a very contemporary voice. I think her voice quality is better than Sunidhi because she can sing loud and western, but can also sing soulful soothing numbers (Jiya Dhadak, Chittiye) and Qawali's (Der Na Ho Jaye).

But you have to agree one thing dizzy that this is a gameshow so every week somebody had to get eliminated at sometime or the other. Otherwise if nobody gets eliminated then the show will go on and on and will never end. I am not saying that anyone who got eliminated in unfair but I would say that the sequence of elimination was wrong and it was all because of public voting because public didnot know the perfect music and couldnot vote for the right person. Otherwise sometime or the other everybody except one had to get eliminated.

Regarding Nihira, I would say that her each and every performance throughout the competition had been very nice and her SAATHI RE WAS the best performace. She had rendered the song so well that it was unfair that public voted her out. But someone had to go and unluckily it was Nihira. But I still say that if the judges were to judge Nihira in that episode then, definitely she would have got the greencard to remain in this competition from the jury. In fact I think she would have become winner. But due to public voting she had to go. So no probs. Each week each person has to go as all are good and the facts should be accepted

Originally posted by: Nehakapoor

But you have to agree one thing dizzy that this is a gameshow so every week somebody had to get eliminated at sometime or the other. Otherwise if nobody gets eliminated then the show will go on and on and will never end. I am not saying that anyone who got eliminated in unfair but I would say that the sequence of elimination was wrong and it was all because of public voting because public didnot know the perfect music and couldnot vote for the right person. Otherwise sometime or the other everybody except one had to get eliminated.

Regarding Nihira, I would say that her each and every performance throughout the competition had been very nice and her SAATHI RE WAS the best performace. She had rendered the song so well that it was unfair that public voted her out. But someone had to go and unluckily it was Nihira. But I still say that if the judges were to judge Nihira in that episode then, definitely she would have got the greencard to remain in this competition from the jury. In fact I think she would have become winner. But due to public voting she had to go. So no probs. Each week each person has to go as all are good and the facts should be accepted

Good point👏.

since its a contest obviously some has to come third, fourth and so on. I think what all of us are trying to say here is that the criterion on which the contestants were eliminated were not fair. Nihira defintely deserved to be in the final two, but was eliminated early as she could not 'entertain' well. But like you said, the show must go on and the winner must be selected on the basis of no. of votes which has been the criterion for all the 12 finalists.

i totally agree wid ya but i think ujjaini was also a gud singer
i was sad when sharib was voted out i just loved da song yamma yamma dat he sung and dat was unfair ke jatin lalit ji ke gharaney ke log sub se pehley chaley gayee!!!! i think dat rajeev was da 1 who should have been voted out first and then da others and i think nihira's and himani elimination was also not fair......but wut can we do..........saregamapa mein itney piliticians jo baitheen hain 😡
When nihira, himani and sharib went out i digested it but now when it's da turn 4 hemu..i can't digest it...it's just not fair 😭 he was da best

Most unfair elimination was ofcourse Nihira who was best amongst all remaining contestants. Everyone knows how much hype has been created for Vinit who dosent deserve to be in top 5 at all. Anyone who has learned music will definately say that he may be good but he is not best.

Himani, can sing pujabi types of songs very well. Again good singer but not the best and we saw that the other day when 2 of them presented "Aye mere watan ke logo" where Nihira was outstanding and Himani was making every effort to pull the chords.

At present whatever is going in this show is not the contest but big B.S. Hope atleast Debojit who is genuine in his every attempt wins.

Cheers

yeh sub kuch himesh ki wajah se ho rha hai bcoz vinit was da 1 who got da least votes 😡 ............but he talked 2 gajji to eliminate hemu
am sad 😭 well jaisi kerni waisi bharni
i hope god will punish himesh 4 destroying gud talents and vinit i think ur songs will not last 4 long but hemu songs will 👏