is it right to blame ashi - Page 3

i think ashirulz n so it was not entirely her falt.but tia shouldnt hav givenhe r such a long lectur.in 1 way tia was also right.

Well, this is getting to be a debate topic! Well, I agree with ashita n hellraisers posts! Ashita's thoughts on ranveer was spot on.

And hellraiser put it correctly too. Just what i wanted to say!

I don't agree with Lamina's blame percentage break up at all.

According to me it wasn't ashi's fault at all. She just came up with a plan and the guys agreed to it. So all of them are 2 be blamed equally. And tia was wrong in blaming ashi for the mess.

But about tia's reaction. It was but natural that she was angry at ashi. b'coz ashi is not the victim... the other two are... esp. Ranveer

And coolest esha, the point you made about tia not coming up with any alternate plan.... she did.. and it was to tell the truth. atleast yuvi could have to his dad... but nobody listened to her b'coz she's a timbo and obviously has no brains. But the plan sucked rite from the start and if shyla hadn't stopped latty the whole lie would have come out in the beginning itself. And all the three esp. yuvi are to be blamed for it.

For once I think tia seems to be the smarter one

i wud firstly make it clear dat this is my perception.
i feel its not ashi's fault. its jus dat she tried 2 help ranveer and yuvi 2 get out of their problem. both of dem didnt have guts to stand against the injustice done to them. ashi jus helped dem 2 solve their problem. she can not b blamed dat she comes up wid da weirdest solution 2 any problem. it was always on ranveer to accept or reject da plan.
tia has no right 2 blame ashi for wat happened 2 ranveer n yuvi. wen tia doesnt thank ashi for wat she did 2 save ranveer she cannot even blame her. remember did tia thank ashi to save rnvr wen jumbo decided 2 punish him 4 fighting wid arjun for tia? no she didnt do dat then how can she shout at her wen rnvr has got caught bcoz of ashi's plan.
moreover deep down her heart ashi 2 loves yuvi and tia is very well aware of dis. so why cant she think dat why will ashi take risk wid his life. from the person dat ashi is it is obvious dat if at all bcoz of her anyone gets into trouble she will take the blame on herself and never leave dem in trouble. and she even did so.
so i will once again say dat if at all anyone is 2 b blamed it is rnvr n yuvi not ashi as it was upto dem to agree or disagree wid her plan.tia was wrong at shouting on ashi.
dis is my perception.