is it right to blame ashi

well 1st of all let me make it clear I am just presenting my views on this....no offence meant to anyone😊

I think ppl r very conviniently putting the entire blame on ashi.....abt yuvi and ranveer switching identities

I think all 3 of them r at fault and not just ashi......both ranveer and yuvi didnt have the guts to stand up for their rights...and what the poor gal did was try and help them out

Ranveer had the same sad face that he had today...when he didnt get the subject of his choice.......and yuvi didnt have the guts to stand up against his dad....and was equally sad abt it......and only thing ashi did was try and find a solution to it......mabbe it was not the right way...but u learn from ur mistakes rite.....and ashi was upset abt it too......and secondly ashi did say that if u guys have a better plan then speak up....or else lets execute this one

And sorry to say.....but I dont think tia was rite on saying that its ashi's responsibility to get them out of trouble......both ranveer and yuvi agreed to ashi's plan out of their own will although they had full right to disagree with it too.......and abt tia saying that I was not agreeing to this plan coz I didnt want to put ranveer in trouble......all I will say is...... when was she a part of it......and even when she knew abt it...and was not agreeing to it.....she should have bashed ranveer yuvi and ashi at that time rather than bashing only ashi now....and if she would have done it wouldnt things have been much more smoother rite now

well all said and done....I dont think there will be any need to find a solution to this problem......coz I have a feeling that mitra will say that he is not punishing either of them....and they can continue with their subjects.......atleast that is what I interpreted with the shocked faces of everyone 😉

and lastly I repeat myself once again...these r just my views.....plz dont pounce upon me ....I am open to ur views too😛

hi you are 50-50 right 😆
i mean tia is right that ashi should not take risk about yuvi and ranveer's life,career and future
BUT
TIA IS WRONG THAT IT'S ONLY HER RESPONSIBILITY
YUVI AND RANVEER SHOULD ALSO NOT TAKE THIS RISK
MAYBE RANVEER IS NOT AT FALT COZ HE WAS FORCED AS TIA SAID
SO SHORTLY IN ONE SIDE TIA IS RIGHT BUT THE OTHER SIDE SHE IS WRONG 😊

***plz dont post in caps.it is taken as shouting on net.edited my mod***

Ashita! I completely agree with you! I was annoyed, sad to know that Tia's blaming Ashi on this whole identity switch plan.

Ofcourse Ashi asked the 2 boys that they could refuse to execute the plan and if they had a better plan, they should tell it. But no one else other than Ashi had any plan and I don't see both Yuvi and Ranveer blaming Ashi at all.

I don't think that anveer and Yuvi being given any seriously dememted punishment because they can't be suspended or expelled from the school because they're the main characters.

Well, good work ashita! 👍🏼

well dear , i differ not much from your point

but i would like to say that only she shouldn't be blamed ,even yuvi has to be !! well ranveer was forced by the both of them !!he wasn't too convinced at it !!

but the main point is that it was her idea !! so she has to face the music ,coz all will feel they are becharaas just doing what she told them too !! but what they dont think is that these guys also need to use something known as brains !! why the hell did they follow what she told without even thinking of the consequences ??

but tia may be right ,coz what she said was right ,ashi shouldn't have pestered them to do such a thing ithout thinking what will happen if the truth was out !!

anvesha rulz i agree with u 100%.ashi was just tryin 2 help them in whichever way she could and she being anvesha thought of the wildest solution 2 the problem.
all 3 are equally responsible.yuvi and ranveer could have refused her plan but they did not as they had no other way.
i dont agree tht ranveer was forced bcoz ultimately it was his decision 2 follow her plan.
and abt tia.........why is she blaming only ashi.thank god atleast yuvi and ranveer r not doing so.
even i think tht mitra will not impend any serious punishment on them as he has 2 remain in the good books of yuvraj dev.

Originally posted by: Neetaldesai

hi you are 50-50 right 😆
i mean tia is right that ashi should not take risk about yuvi and ranveer's life,career and future
BUT
TIA IS WRONG THAT IT'S ONLY HER RESPONSIBILITY
YUVI AND RANVEER SHOULD ALSO NOT TAKE THIS RISK
MAYBE RANVEER IS NOT AT FALT COZ HE WAS FORCED AS TIA SAID
SO SHORTLY IN ONE SIDE TIA IS RIGHT BUT THE OTHER SIDE SHE IS WRONG 😊

ya...i do agree...its the fault of all 3 of them.....but though she was trying to help them...the plan itself was very stupid...& u cant deny that the master mind of this stupid plan is ashi.......so i think tia is to some extent right atleast in this case.

Hi ....here is my perspective on this...i am a tia ranveer fan...so i dont know how much u will believe me in this...but i am trying to be as objective as possible

Lets look at the three people who can be blamed

Ranveer
he was feeling low...ashi is his best friend..and she came up with a idea to help him...did he agree with it? - no..but he didnt have anyother ideas. was he forced into it? well yes..ashi did bully a bit...with do u think mitra is going to be ur mitr and give u the subject kinda thing...yuvi too pushed ranveer abt this...even then ranveer wasnt convinced....by the end..even vrinda , varun and sid were with the plan...with all his friends supporting him...he dived head on...I dont doubt for a minute that it wasnt stupid of him to do so...he should have used his brains as well....atlest spoken to tia...she was trying to find out abt it...but by the time she found out and adviced him...it was too late...

SO i do agree he has to take some bit of the blame ...but the most minor portion of it..even when tia was talking to ranveer...she said did accept that ranveer had a small part in the blame too

% of blame - 5% ....but he is the one who will end up with 90% of the punishment...even if it doesnt happen now...it will happen over time

yuvi
yuvi is totally in love with ashi...he has never once backed out of any idea that ashi has had...so there was no doubt he would be in this plan....was he responsible too?? yup..sadly...as per the plan he was supposed to let his dad know abt his arts ka subject slowly n his dad was supposed to take care of it...well uv should have known his dad by now...he should have realised that yeshwant dev would never ever be okay with this...so there was a fundamental flaw in the idea...and even then he went ahead...so he has to take up some blame...on top of it...he dragged ranveer into it..knowing that mitra hates scholarship students..and ranveer would end up paying most price for this

% of blame - 25 - 30%...he will prob end up with only 5% punishement though coz he is yeshwant dev's son

ashi
ashi is the prankster..the trouble maker...but i do realise that she has a good heart and her only aim is to help people...but she always focuses too much only on the helping people right now any how and taking care of consequences later..whatever they may be..and this always ends up creating problems...as with TTMO..her heart was in the right place..but she ended up hurting ranveer...she would have had better results if she just locked them in the room rather then doing all this...with the exam too..if tia hadnt used her brains and did what she did...ranveer wouldnt even have been able to give the exam
and most imp the current idea....she too was aware of yeshwant's dev's attitude..and it was obvious to everyone that he wouldnt have agreed....what was going to be the outcome of this --- one - they wouldnt have been caught and ranveer would have studied sci but ended up with a arts degree at the end of the year...(coz uv was studying arts in his name)...second they would have been caught as it did happen...which means that the idea was a big flop..wish i could call it a mistake...but when it can cost someone their future ....it just doesnt remain a mistake does it?....and in this idea..it wasnt just feeling but careers n futures involved...ashi should have been more analytical of this idea

i know the whole blame doesnt lie with her...but she knew that uv would agree with her..and even though ranveer didnt completly use his brains...she more or less dragged him into it....so even though ashi cant be completely blamed for uv's punishement (he was more willing to go with the idea)...she is majorly responsible for ranveer's upcoming tragedy

% of blame 65-70% overall; 90-95% in ranveer's case

tia
ok now lets looks at tia's angle in this....tia did try to find out abt it...but none of them let her in on what they were up to...otherwise she would have shown some sense to them...when she found out..mitra already knew ranveer as uv..it was too late..all she could do was ensure that she didnt let mitra find out abt this...as to why didnt she talk to ashi first and only got mad at ranveer...well think of it this was..when tia found out abt this huge tragedy....she saw 3 ppl being involved in this ranveer, uv and ashi...among this...who was the most imp for her...her life...ranveer...so it was obvious she would be most concerned for him and shout at him for being stupid..coz she felt she had atlest that much right in ranveer's life..with ashi...u must agree...ashi never listens to her...no matter what...and uv..well he was thick into it too..on top of it..tia knew he loved ashi and wouldnt listen to her...even today...tia was looking at it from ranveer's perspective...after this he is the one in all of them that is going to face the music the most...and ashi was the main person responsible for him agreeing with the plan..even though tia might not blame ashi in gen....when it comes to ranveer's involvement in this...tia is justifies in putting blame on ashi...coz the truth be told...everyone including ashi knows that ranveer will be punished the most...and being the brainy one...she was expected to know this

so even though her heart is in the right place..from tia's perspective..she wasnt wrong in getting mad at ashi either

Originally posted by: lamina

Hi ....here is my perspective on this...i am a tia ranveer fan...so i dont know how much u will believe me in this...but i am trying to be as objective as possible

Lets look at the three people who can be blamed

Ranveer
he was feeling low...ashi is his best friend..and she came up with a idea to help him...did he agree with it? - no..but he didnt have anyother ideas. was he forced into it? well yes..ashi did bully a bit...with do u think mitra is going to be ur mitr and give u the subject kinda thing...yuvi too pushed ranveer abt this...even then ranveer wasnt convinced....by the end..even vrinda , varun and sid were with the plan...with all his friends supporting him...he dived head on...I dont doubt for a minute that it wasnt stupid of him to do so...he should have used his brains as well....atlest spoken to tia...she was trying to find out abt it...but by the time she found out and adviced him...it was too late...

SO i do agree he has to take some bit of the blame ...but the most minor portion of it..even when tia was talking to ranveer...she said did accept that ranveer had a small part in the blame too

% of blame - 5% ....but he is the one who will end up with 90% of the punishment...even if it doesnt happen now...it will happen over time

yuvi
yuvi is totally in love with ashi...he has never once backed out of any idea that ashi has had...so there was no doubt he would be in this plan....was he responsible too?? yup..sadly...as per the plan he was supposed to let his dad know abt his arts ka subject slowly n his dad was supposed to take care of it...well uv should have known his dad by now...he should have realised that yeshwant dev would never ever be okay with this...so there was a fundamental flaw in the idea...and even then he went ahead...so he has to take up some blame...on top of it...he dragged ranveer into it..knowing that mitra hates scholarship students..and ranveer would end up paying most price for this

% of blame - 25 - 30%...he will prob end up with only 5% punishement though coz he is yeshwant dev's son

ashi
ashi is the prankster..the trouble maker...but i do realise that she has a good heart and her only aim is to help people...but she always focuses too much only on the helping people right now any how and taking care of consequences later..whatever they may be..and this always ends up creating problems...as with TTMO..her heart was in the right place..but she ended up hurting ranveer...she would have had better results if she just locked them in the room rather then doing all this...with the exam too..if tia hadnt used her brains and did what she did...ranveer wouldnt even have been able to give the exam
and most imp the current idea....she too was aware of yeshwant's dev's attitude..and it was obvious to everyone that he wouldnt have agreed....what was going to be the outcome of this --- one - they wouldnt have been caught and ranveer would have studied sci but ended up with a arts degree at the end of the year...(coz uv was studying arts in his name)...second they would have been caught as it did happen...which means that the idea was a big flop..wish i could call it a mistake...but when it can cost someone their future ....it just doesnt remain a mistake does it?....and in this idea..it wasnt just feeling but careers n futures involved...ashi should have been more analytical of this idea

i know the whole blame doesnt lie with her...but she knew that uv would agree with her..and even though ranveer didnt completly use his brains...she more or less dragged him into it....so even though ashi cant be completely blamed for uv's punishement (he was more willing to go with the idea)...she is majorly responsible for ranveer's upcoming tragedy

% of blame 65-70% overall; 90-95% in ranveer's case

tia
ok now lets looks at tia's angle in this....tia did try to find out abt it...but none of them let her in on what they were up to...otherwise she would have shown some sense to them...when she found out..mitra already knew ranveer as uv..it was too late..all she could do was ensure that she didnt let mitra find out abt this...as to why didnt she talk to ashi first and only got mad at ranveer...well think of it this was..when tia found out abt this huge tragedy....she saw 3 ppl being involved in this ranveer, uv and ashi...among this...who was the most imp for her...her life...ranveer...so it was obvious she would be most concerned for him and shout at him for being stupid..coz she felt she had atlest that much right in ranveer's life..with ashi...u must agree...ashi never listens to her...no matter what...and uv..well he was thick into it too..on top of it..tia knew he loved ashi and wouldnt listen to her...even today...tia was looking at it from ranveer's perspective...after this he is the one in all of them that is going to face the music the most...and ashi was the main person responsible for him agreeing with the plan..even though tia might not blame ashi in gen....when it comes to ranveer's involvement in this...tia is justifies in putting blame on ashi...coz the truth be told...everyone including ashi knows that ranveer will be punished the most...and being the brainy one...she was expected to know this

so even though her heart is in the right place..from tia's perspective..she wasnt wrong in getting mad at ashi either

Thank you atleast someone has the same opinion as me!
I agree with u 100%!

ummm shi gave a pt now it was nt forced upon uv n ranveer umm maybe ranveer said no but at d end agrewed tooo so i think d fault is of all htree of em
its nt entirely ashisfault

Well, Ashi is kind of responsible because she was putting other people at risk. Lamina put it very well.
And Tia, well, its only natural to yell at Ashi because ab dekho kya ho gaya hai - usko bhadaas to nikaalna tha, she is so worreid about Ranveer. And moreover, Tia has already yelled at Ranvir right in the beginning when she heard about the plan.
And even if Mitra doesn't punish bot of them this time because of Yashwant Dev, he will definitely take it out on Ranvir through out the term. Bechaara Ranvir.