Kurbaan - Speaking For Moderate Islam?

thornewood9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Hi everyone😃 So most of you probably know about the new Saif and Kareena movie thats coming out. Apparently its about Terrorism and is speaking on the behalf of Moderate Islam.
Now here's my opinion on this.
Muslims do not need Bollywood to make movies and speak on their behalf about moderate Islam. In fact I find it obnoxious and insulting. Plus that poster of naked Saif and Kareena is just disgraceful.
Why is it everytime Bollywood wants to make a movie with muslims in it they always have to mess it up and show muslims/Islam in a way that is completely not Islamic?
This is sounding a lot like Fanaa to be honest. I thought that movie was ridiculous too. No MUSLIM would have any relationship with the the opposite sex outside of marriage. In fact no muslim would have a child outside of marriage. Not to mention no Muslim would go around killing people if they actually practised Islam in the first place.
Why is it that Hollywood and Bollywood can never show Muslims the way they actually are?
Aisha xxx🤓

Created

Last reply

Replies

225

Views

20.8k

Users

28

Likes

256

Frequent Posters

souro thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: thornewood9

Not to mention no Muslim would go around killing people if they actually practised Islam in the first place.

🤣🤣🤣
Don't want to be called a spammer. So, here's my do paisa. Is the movie released yet?? Nope. Have you seen an exclusive screening?? Nope. Then why not wait for another 3 days when it actually comes out and then form opinions.
Edited by souro - 15 years ago
thornewood9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: souro

🤣🤣🤣

Don't want to be called a spammer. So, here's my do paisa. Is the movie released yet?? Nope. Have you seen an exclusive screening?? Nope. Then why not wait for another 3 days when it actually comes out and then form judgements.

Okay whats so funny about that line about Muslims don't kill people?
And hello? The synopsis of the movie is out. We KNOW what its going to be about. We've seen the Trailers. Judgements are formed around that. And the director and actors have spoken about the movie being a voice for moderate Islam.
All Im saying is Muslims do not need Bollywood to speak out for them.
Aisha xxx🤓
-Believe- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: souro

🤣🤣🤣Don't want to be called a spammer. So, here's my do paisa. Is the movie released yet?? Nope. Have you seen an exclusive screening?? Nope. Then why not wait for another 3 days when it actually comes out and then form opinions.

@souro---Dont laugh😡😡 Acha nahe legtha--smile like this way... 🤣
@thornewood9--Dont do acting n other things blah blah.....nobody forcing anyone to do these things....😊everybody have their own rights to live as per their own wish..😊
Edited by Believe - 15 years ago
thornewood9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Believe

@thornewood9--Dont do acting n other things blah blah.....nobody forcing anyone to do these things....😊everybody have their own rights to live as per their own wish..😊

Uh... Im sorry I didn't understand your reply😕
Aisha xxx😕
chimuli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6


This is sounding a lot like Fanaa to be honest. I thought that movie was ridiculous too. No MUSLIM would have any relationship with the the opposite sex outside of marriage.
In fact no muslim would have a child outside of marriage. Not to mention no Muslim would go around killing people if they actually practised Islam in the first place.

Can you guarantee that.....do these things come with package.....
You are unnecessarily highlighting...MUSLIMS.....Well these kind of people can be found in each religion...
I cant see connection.....😕
yes one is supposed to not to have it....


Why is it that Hollywood and Bollywood can never show Muslims the way they actually are?

Have they ever shown things in way things are....?
Bollywood is mostly about masala....n money....
BTW Aamir was a movie....which highlighted.......how muslims are targeted to become terrrorist...



-Believe- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: thornewood9

Uh... Im sorry I didn't understand your reply😕---First you understand Films dont show the real world...reality S*ks..and people dont want see daily life reality in films.....they need something extra...something masla....Ppl making film to earn money....so they can narrate/direct any kind of stories in film....😊 Ask Shahrukh or Saif...why they dont showing reality about muslims...!!😊otheriwse feel free boycott their films...😊
Aisha xxx😕--Vinu yyyy😊

thornewood9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: tetuty66



This is sounding a lot like Fanaa to be honest. I thought that movie was ridiculous too. No MUSLIM would have any relationship with the the opposite sex outside of marriage.
In fact no muslim would have a child outside of marriage. Not to mention no Muslim would go around killing people if they actually practised Islam in the first place.

Can you guarantee that.....do these things come with package.....
You are unnecessarily highlighting...MUSLIMS.....Well these kind of people can be found in each religion...
I cant see connection.....😕
yes one is supposed to not to have it....


Why is it that Hollywood and Bollywood can never show Muslims the way they actually are?

Have they ever shown things in way things are....?
Bollywood is mostly about masala....n money....
BTW Aamir was a movie....which highlighted.......how muslims are targeted to become terrrorist...


I have to disagree. If you follow your religion then you follow EVERY aspect of your religion. You can't pick and choose. In my opinion people who say they are Muslims but then do things that go against Islam are not Muslims. Saying you are Muslim isn't enough. Your actions must also prove it. If you are Muslim and have a child out of wedlock out of your own choice then you have committed an UnIslamic Act. How can you be Muslim if you do that?
And Fanaa was a movie which showed the stupid side of "religion"
Any Muslim who follows his Faith knows that one of the most famous verses of the Quran is:
If you kill one person it is as though you have killed all of humanity. And if you save one person it is as though you have saved all of humanity.
A muslim who participates in Suicide Bombing and Terrorism is not a Muslim. The Prophet NEVER acted in such a way. No hadith shows that the Prophet or his Companions acted like that.
And I know movies don't always show Reality but maybe it's time they did because all they do by making movies like this is increase the ignorance and the disillusions that people hold about certain topics.
Also its not about Boycotting the movie. I WILL watch it so that I can criticise it in full knowledge of it. You ahould always be informed about EVERY viewpoint.
Aisha xxx🤓
chimuli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: thornewood9

I have to disagree. If you follow your religion then you follow EVERY aspect of your religion. You can't pick and choose. In my opinion people who say they are Muslims but then do things that go against Islam are not Muslims. Saying you are Muslim isn't enough. Your actions must also prove it. If you are Muslim and have a child out of wedlock out of your own choice then you have committed an UnIslamic Act. How can you be Muslim if you do that?
And Fanaa was a movie which showed the stupid side of "religion"
Any Muslim who follows his Faith knows that one of the most famous verses of the Quran is:
If you kill one person it is as though you have killed all of humanity. And if you save one person it is as though you have saved all of humanity.
A muslim who participates in Suicide Bombing and Terrorism is not a Muslim. The Prophet NEVER acted in such a way. No hadith shows that the Prophet or his Companions acted like that.
And I know movies don't always show Reality but maybe it's time they did because all they do by making movies like this is increase the ignorance and the disillusions that people hold about certain topics.
Also its not about Boycotting the movie. I WILL watch it so that I can criticise it in full knowledge of it. You ahould always be informed about EVERY viewpoint.
Aisha xxx🤓



I just made a point that...
See...i know....you are telling what is correct........
But dont we know..how many people are there who practice it......
You cant influence outhers....what is wrong will remain wrong..I agree...
And Bollywoood....and reality.....oh my!!!.......miles apart!!!
sonur15 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: thornewood9

Hi everyone😃 So most of you probably know about the new Saif and Kareena movie thats coming out. Apparently its about Terrorism and is speaking on the behalf of Moderate Islam.

Now here's my opinion on this.
Muslims do not need Bollywood to make movies and speak on their behalf about moderate Islam. In fact I find it obnoxious and insulting. Plus that poster of naked Saif and Kareena is just disgraceful.
Why is it everytime Bollywood wants to make a movie with muslims in it they always have to mess it up and show muslims/Islam in a way that is completely not Islamic?
This is sounding a lot like Fanaa to be honest. I thought that movie was ridiculous too. No MUSLIM would have any relationship with the the opposite sex outside of marriage. In fact no muslim would have a child outside of marriage. Not to mention no Muslim would go around killing people if they actually practised Islam in the first place.
Why is it that Hollywood and Bollywood can never show Muslims the way they actually are?
Aisha xxx🤓

Welcome Aisha to DM 😆
Lets wait for the movie then we will decide ..i dont think anyone in bollywood make movie just for anyone. I think they make movies on current situations of India /world and terrorism is the biggest problem of this world .We had movies like Rang de basanti, Fashion, Chak de and many more and they all were HITS because they were based on the current situation of our country and audience can relate to such movies .Obviously now they cant show an affair between a village ki chori and foreign return boy ( movies in 60's and 70's) because we cant relate to such subject . Its not about any religion its all about a current situation of the world.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".