Edward human....? hmmm, wat wud dat b like?

Page

Next Last

Tahmina Aliya Begum

@-Aliya-

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

Edward wished that he could be human, especially for Bella. But what if, instead of Bella turning into a vampire, Edward turned back into a human??? What if the Twilight Saga wasn't Bella's story but Edward's and instead of - in the end (Breaking Dawn) Bella didn't turn into a vampire but Edward turned back into a human?

That would be interesting. I'm not saying Bella's story isn't enough or wateva u wanna cal it coz dats jus a whole other thng and its nt wat im sayin. I don't want to get comments sayin 'Naaa i fink Bella's story is enough etc.' coz im nt sayin dat bt imagine it was the other way round... That would be soo different and strange and it may or may not be a hit bt it mite change the way we look at Edward or mebe let us discover a different part of him........hmmm i wonder if Stephenie Meyer had any ideas or dreams (Twilight was based on her dreams). Im not suggestin it jus wonderin wat u guys think, wat if it was lyk dat.

Enjoy😊😉

Arite guys, reading some ppls comments has disappointed me. Swearing is one of them. And obviously everyones opinions are different so get used to it. If you find someone elses opinion hard to understand then it may be that they are finding it hard to understand your opinions or agree with them. So plz respect. And anyway, wen did the topic bcum bout Edward's beauty?!😕 I really didnt know that i would have to remind some ppl about the rules of this forum. And I apologize to those ppl who were disrespected or had to stand up to other ppls rude comments. I know I'm freaking out and over reacting but I just don't like these sort of things and plus I'm in a weird mood rite now or else i don't over react like this. Thank You.

Edited by tarm - 15 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Kruti Shah

@KrutiLuvEdward

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

Hmm....I wonder about this too.....

Sometimes I often get the thought that since VAMPIRES are more beautiful that humans, and technically bella seemed to be acttracted to his beauty more than anything (especially in twilight), she may have chosen jacbo over him if edward turned into human....

In everybook in about every chapter she is always talking about his inhuman beauty...and then if he doesnt have that inhuman beauty anymore....for some reason I can picture her leaving him and chosing jacob.........I don't think about this much though, because it is technically impossible to change back into a human..

xo Kruti

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

...ASB100...

@...ASB100...

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: KrutiLuvEdward
Hmm....I wonder about this too.....

Sometimes I often get the thought that since VAMPIRES are more beautiful that humans, and technically bella seemed to be acttracted to his beauty more than anything (especially in twilight), she may have chosen jacbo over him if edward turned into human....

In everybook in about every chapter she is always talking about his inhuman beauty...and then if he doesnt have that inhuman beauty anymore....for some reason I can picture her leaving him and chosing jacob.........I don't think about this much though, because it is technically impossible to change back into a human..

xo Kruti

what u say is pretty true, but in NM when Carlisle was telling Bella Edward's story, he siad edward had been a really handsome boy, right? i mean with green eyes and all those other qualities which Carlisle described, i feel Edward would still have that inhuman beauty which u mentioned. no offence, but i somehow don't like Jacob and bella being with Jacob just doesn't seem right to me.

Quote

-Alina-

@-Alina-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

Well I get it want you want to say...and I think it would have been so much good..... if that would have happened !!!!! I so agree with winnerasha(sorry don't know your name) Carlisle did said that Edward was a beautiful looking guy with green eyes and all...so maybe Bella still have chosen him over Jacob !!!!
And maybe then it would have been so amazing to see Edward as a normal human being.....I so wish Meyer had thought about it !!!!!!!

luv Alina

Quote

Kruti Shah

@KrutiLuvEdward

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: winnerasha

what u say is pretty true, but in NM when Carlisle was telling Bella Edward's story, he siad edward had been a really handsome boy, right? i mean with green eyes and all those other qualities which Carlisle described, i feel Edward would still have that inhuman beauty which u mentioned. no offence, but i somehow don't like Jacob and bella being with Jacob just doesn't seem right to me.

I'm not a fan of Jacob either...But in Breaking Dawn, Stephanie describes the difference in Bella before and after her beauty....Bella who used to think she was average finds herself beautiful after the transformation...No doubt Carlisle said that edward was beautiful before he became a vamp, but when they describe bella's change...I always thought that all the vampires became even more beautiful than they were while human.......

maybe I'm the only one who sees it this way, but stephanie DID decribe maginificent changes in bella once she was a vampire......

by the way...I'm not taking any offense..lol....this is just a friendly disussion😆

Quote

JK Dhillon

@Angelic_J

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

I agree with what KruitLuvEdward has said😛 If Edward was human then he stood no chance against Jake😆 The only reason Bella was transfixed with Eddy was because of his lure as a vampire and his "Beautifulness" [if that's even a word]😆

Quote

innocentdevil.

@innocentdevil.

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

I was gonna say that. ^^^^

She only got interested in Edward cause of his beauty. In fact she loves Jake for who he is. Not for his beauty. =)

Oh and Edward would be nothing but a freak if it weren't for his beauty. I mean around the humans he doesn't fit in. He's only known cause he has a pretty face. Or else he'd be nothing but a nobody.

Edited by ShadowKiss - 15 years ago

Quote

sarah

@faghia

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: ShadowKiss
I was gonna say that. ^^^^

She only got interested in Edward cause of his beauty. In fact she loves Jake for who he is. Not for his beauty. =)

Oh and Edward would be nothing but a freak if it weren't for his beauty. I mean around the humans he doesn't fit in. He's only known cause he has a pretty face. Or else he'd be nothing but a nobody.

hello

did u guys actually read twilight or just pretend to...............bella didnt love edward cause of his beauty it was all destiny they were meant together................not bcause of some inhuman beauty and by the way the person u love is always teh most beautiful person to u ........bella loved edward first and then his beauty!!11

i see teher si a lot of bella bashing in this forum ..read the buk again and try to think frm her point of view...........she agev edward and jacob the ebst life she could./she agve jacob renessme is tht less

Edited by faghia - 15 years ago

Quote

sarah

@faghia

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

awesome topic yaar never thought abt it this way.......it would be grt to see edward adjusting into bella s world.....i would also love to see some edward jacob bonding

Quote

innocentdevil.

@innocentdevil.

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#10

I read the book. In fact Bella never out of the blue fell in love with Edward and one day just notice Edward is beautiful. She herself repeats how beautiful EDWARD is. Yeah read the four books over again. And almost everytime you'll see "He was so beautiful i couldn't believe he loved me" or something like that.

Originally posted by: faghia
did u guys actually read twilight or just pretend to...............

WTF? Just cause i don't like edward and Bella and love jacob it means i didn't read the book?

Okay maybe you think Bella did the best thing she could. I say she could have done better wayyyyyy better that is.

Really everything i say is from my own opinion. So really go ahead and love Bella&Edward don't ask my if i read the book or not cause you don't agree with me.

Edited by ShadowKiss - 15 years ago

Quote

1 2

Edward human....? hmmm, wat wud dat b like?

Related Topics

Explore Topics