Did you realise?

In book 7, Hermione says that no1 can make food apper out of thin air as it is one of theexception of gamp's law of elemental transfiguration..

he didn't 'create' cakes but summoned them... not by accio spell... there must be another spell for that... bcoz this happens many times in books... molly weasley makes onion soup appear out of thin air n dumbledore summons madam rosemerta's finest mead in the dursley's house in the 6th part...
it's not producing but summoning simply...

^ That's what I think, he summoned it.

Wanna know what I noticed, in DH Hermoine said she confudled her parents and made them go to Australia. However, after when they left the Wedding and then there were death eaters near them, she said she doesn't know how to do those spells but only knows the theory.. tha'ts another mistake.

Originally posted by: -Navi

^ That's what I think, he summoned it.

Wanna know what I noticed, in DH Hermoine said she confudled her parents and made them go to Australia. However, after when they left the Wedding and then there were death eaters near them, she said she doesn't know how to do those spells but only knows the theory.. tha'ts another mistake.

Great questions and replies guys! It was very interesting reading the posts in this thread!

The memory charms used by Hermione on her parents and the one she was talking about doing on the death eaters were different charms, that's what I read on Leaky:)
About Hagrid, he didn't actually 'conjure' the food, it was lying somewhere in his home and he just summoned it:)

The memory charms used by Hermione on her parents and the one she was talking about doing on the death eaters were different charms- because she modified her parents memory whereas she had to remove the Death Eaters. You can't make food appear out of thin air- you have to have the food in the first place and then summon it. Dumbledore must have had the drinks then transfigurised them or made them vanish so he could summon them or make them appear whenever he wants.

umm....hermione CONFUNDED her parents...n for da death eaters, harry askd her to remove deir memories wich is da obliviate spell...same as da ones lockhart used to use....

Originally posted by: nimy.10

umm....hermione CONFUNDED her parents...n for da death eaters, harry askd her to remove deir memories wich is da obliviate spell...same as da ones lockhart used to use....