Smita.S thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Well this is the very first time i am opening a topic here....on the very onset i would say that I dont really fancy anyone...from all the contestants, on purely the basis of what you see in the episodes telecast....for a person like me...I have just merely heard of Hard Kaur seeing her in a couple of music videos, same goes for Baichung and Karan Grover. And Gauhar, i hadn't heard of her till i saw this show.

So well what i am trying to put across is, the first thing that hits on your face is how very scripted this show is. Infact if you remove the dance element it would seem just like a la Big boss/ Big brother. They make contestants give their opinions...about the rest and then project them as though they are jealous? They are actually bad mouthing others??

It was really disgusting to see the entire Hard Kaur/ Gauhar scenario yesterday.......dont tell me both the ladies are so immatuer that they talk ill about each other on camera?? Being from the field both Hard Kaur and Gauhar do know how opinions can be twisted. But still Jdj can manage to leech out opinions and project it as cat fights!!

Another tactic is targeting Karan Grover and Baichung. Knowing Karan is weaker in dance....target him by creating a controversy over the votes he gets. Though i would still give him a salute for taking it all in the lighter vein, and not argue back or throw tantrums as that was just hat is expected. Same goes to Mr Baichung.

Baichung had maanged to stay away from the evident controversies surrounding the show very tactfully. But they did not spare him yesterday either. Whatever he and Sonia remarked were their own opinions......why show them as though he was talking ill about Karan?? Again Karan was smart enough not to add malice to it and take a safer route. So was Baichung...on stage when he remarked jokingly about votes.


Wish the show would focus more on dance and better rounds then making another Big boss. They know Karan , Gauhar and Hard kaur are magnets to controversies, they cant drag in Baichung as hes a national figure from the sports field...whereas the rest are from the fame industry hence they can be embroiled in such controversy easily. Next i guess looking at the response..which they usually do...looking at what people are talking, create a script and throw it at contestants....i guess they will either get Hard Kaur and Gauhr against each other...in face off.....as they have made claims that Baichung and Karan get votes....or to spice up things further have Baichung vs Gauhar or Hard kaur or Karan vs the ladies......the clinched part being why make dancers compete with non dancers and then ridicule ur own show by claiming Baichung and Karan get underserved votes and that Gauhar and Hk are over confident??

I guess i'll stop now. Sorry to put u guys off to sleep. Just my two cents..I knw it may seem lame as ultimately we do watch this crap...watever we may claim. :)

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.6k

Users

16

Frequent Posters

hope4u thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
hehehe... scripted it is... good post.. 👏 👏
and controversy is the second name of a reality show.... strange these people dont realize that we watch a dance show for the "dance", and not the "drama".. have they tried focussing ourely on dance? they might get a better response and trp's..
and the reason baichung is drawn so less into controversy is because he practises in kolkatta..no cameras there.. for this circus round, he had to practice in jhalak house and for the first time we saw a vt on baichung and sonia which could have become controversial, had the 2 men in question not handled it maturedly..
and what ur saying with respect to the finals is also true.. we have no idea as to what happens behind closed doors.. if they have decided to keep their biggest money earners and most popular stars till the end, nothing is gonna change it.. probably the only real thing in the entire show will be the final result, coz they will have nothing to gain out of manipulating it.. 😆
jia.. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Kudos to the topic starter! Cudnt agree better. HK and Gauhar dance on an entirely different level if compared to Karan and BB. They have very smartly kept their highest vote gainers and great dancers till the end. And now i am sure many more controversies are on our way.....to gather more eye balls for the show as dance plays little factor in doing so.
ABHAYSGIRL thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
u r so right, i can bet hk n gk will face dance off n judges sk n vm will choose hk n at d finals it will be all male dis season cos hk will b voted off by reason of her fight wit gauhar! dis guys r genius i tell u...lol
Micky_elle thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
Yeah..i guess ur right that the show must be scripted, but i definitely prefer this show to nach baliye...coz the scripting looks so evident in nach baliye..atleast in Jhalak they act naturally and make the drama look real 😉
Wrackspurt thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
I agree with your post 👍🏼.......i really did not like the way they showed that HK and Gauhar are against each other.......i mean thats totally ridiculous.......what would they get speaking ill of each other???.....absolutely nothing......they are not competing to gain fame or anything.....both are well-eastablished in their own profesions.......i agree to your point that they cannot portray BB in a negative manner since he is a national figure 😉...well JDJ this season is a well scripted unreal reality show 😆😆😆
digitalone 33 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
i full to agree with u for sure..................
352869 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
yaar itna sab kaun padhega..
ny1 plz give a small note of wht is it all abt?? 😆 😆
aish_punk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Hmm..i hafa agree wid u..i wont say it's scritped..bt they overdo sutff 2 get in controversy..Gauhar n HK myt have just said stuff in a fun n joking manner..bt they pep evrytyn up..n did Karan-Baichung also go agnst each oda? 😲
Riddikulus thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Smita.S

Well this is the very first time i am opening a topic here....on the very onset i would say that I dont really fancy anyone...from all the contestants, on purely the basis of what you see in the episodes telecast....for a person like me...I have just merely heard of Hard Kaur seeing her in a couple of music videos, same goes for Baichung and Karan Grover. And Gauhar, i hadn't heard of her till i saw this show.

So well what i am trying to put across is, the first thing that hits on your face is how very scripted this show is. Infact if you remove the dance element it would seem just like a la Big boss/ Big brother. They make contestants give their opinions...about the rest and then project them as though they are jealous? They are actually bad mouthing others??

It was really disgusting to see the entire Hard Kaur/ Gauhar scenario yesterday.......dont tell me both the ladies are so immatuer that they talk ill about each other on camera?? Being from the field both Hard Kaur and Gauhar do know how opinions can be twisted. But still Jdj can manage to leech out opinions and project it as cat fights!!

Another tactic is targeting Karan Grover and Baichung. Knowing Karan is weaker in dance....target him by creating a controversy over the votes he gets. Though i would still give him a salute for taking it all in the lighter vein, and not argue back or throw tantrums as that was just hat is expected. Same goes to Mr Baichung.

Baichung had maanged to stay away from the evident controversies surrounding the show very tactfully. But they did not spare him yesterday either. Whatever he and Sonia remarked were their own opinions......why show them as though he was talking ill about Karan?? Again Karan was smart enough not to add malice to it and take a safer route. So was Baichung...on stage when he remarked jokingly about votes.


Wish the show would focus more on dance and better rounds then making another Big boss. They know Karan , Gauhar and Hard kaur are magnets to controversies, they cant drag in Baichung as hes a national figure from the sports field...whereas the rest are from the fame industry hence they can be embroiled in such controversy easily. Next i guess looking at the response..which they usually do...looking at what people are talking, create a script and throw it at contestants....i guess they will either get Hard Kaur and Gauhr against each other...in face off.....as they have made claims that Baichung and Karan get votes....or to spice up things further have Baichung vs Gauhar or Hard kaur or Karan vs the ladies......the clinched part being why make dancers compete with non dancers and then ridicule ur own show by claiming Baichung and Karan get underserved votes and that Gauhar and Hk are over confident??

I guess i'll stop now. Sorry to put u guys off to sleep. Just my two cents..I knw it may seem lame as ultimately we do watch this crap...watever we may claim. :)

first of all, a very nice and sensibly thought out post...👍🏼 certainly didn't put me to sleep, for one...hehe...
second, i completely agree with you on each point...although i'm not so sure about everything being scripted, it certainly does come across as quite ridiculous sometimes...besides, i don't get where the need for such controversies arises in a dance show in the first place...and trust them to make matters worse by coupling already caustic AVs with aftershock question-answer sessions with each of the contenders involved...you wanted opinions...you were given opinions...why exactly must those opinions then be stretched into non-existent controversies for no plausible reason? give you a high, diluting the already edgy ambience with bitterness...?! 😳
and @the highlighted part...you stole the words right out of my mouth...don't think i can add anything to that, since you put it so well 👍🏼...just don't get these people...
oh well...strange are the ways of Reality Shows...
cheers!😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".