Asha Bhosle vs Alka Yagnik. Who's better?

best_guy

@best_guy

Inactive

5

Posted: 16 years ago

#1

Asha Bhosle vs Alka Yagnik.

both are versatile singers

but who is better?

Reply

Quote

Bankim Chandra Chaterjee

@mr.ass

Rocker

29

Posted: 16 years ago

#2

well, this is a difficult question for me as i rate these 2 singers number 1 for female singers...

lets analyse:

Alka:
warmth in voice
versatile
totally unique

Asha:
seductive voice
versatile
totally unique

although both are versatile, obviously alka scores in the sweet melody department, while asha scores in the seductive and dance number department.

Reply

Quote

Sujal_Fan_No1

@Sujal_Fan_No1

Voyager

16

Posted: 16 years ago

#3

U cant choose bettween them, they are both gd!

Reply

Quote

swan20

@swan20

Sparkler

33

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

#4

Ofcourse Asha Bhosle.......in my opinion nobody can come close to her & Lata Mangeshkar.........they are in a league of their own.......👍🏼

1

Reply

Quote

Bankim Chandra Chaterjee

@mr.ass

Rocker

29

Posted: 16 years ago

#5

hmmm.. i loved lata mangeshkar in the old slow melodious songs like oh sajna, aa jaane jaan, na jaa o mere humdum,raina beeti jaaye, tu chanda,mose chal,etc.. but whenever i listen to the peppier songs like bhagon mein bahaar hain(tho it isnt that peppy), chadthi jawani, jai jai shiva shankar,and many 70 songs i feel that asha ji should have sung it instead. The reverse never happened with me when i listened to asha singing abhi na jaao chodkar or gun guna rahe hain bhavarein, even tho lata could sing those.

just my own opinion. no offence.

Reply

Quote

HariOm

@HariOm

Voyager

16

Posted: 16 years ago

#6

I don't think u can compare legendary Asha to screechy Alka...
Asha is in a different league altogether....

Reply

Quote

Bankim Chandra Chaterjee

@mr.ass

Rocker

29

Posted: 16 years ago

#7

Originally posted by: HariOm
I don't think u can compare legendary Asha to screechy Alka...
Asha is in a different league altogether....

yea asha lasted longer thats a good point... 1940's late till late 80's i think..

alka from 1980 to 2005 i think

but i like alka's voice more.

Reply

Quote

bellevue

@bellevue

Inactive

15

Posted: 16 years ago

#8

Originally posted by: HariOm
I don't think u can compare legendary Asha to screechy Alka...
Asha is in a different league altogether....

I couldn't agree with you more. Alka's voice sounds so shrill at times that I have to cover my ears. I remember taking one of my cousin to hear Ashaji in the early ninetys thinking she will not like the singing (she grew up in USA and doesn't listen to Indian music) and complain. Instead she said what an intoxicating voice! Just imagine Alkaji singing; age bhi janena tu, and yeh hai reshmi zulfo ka!!

Reply

Quote

dockaul

@dockaul

Beginner

1

Posted: 16 years ago

#9

LOL!! Blasphemous IMHO to compare the two!! What next - comparing Md. Rafi Saab & Sonu Nigam ji .. sheesh..

1

Reply

Quote

Bankim Chandra Chaterjee

@mr.ass

Rocker

29

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: dockaul
LOL!! Blasphemous IMHO to compare the two!! What next - comparing Md. Rafi Saab & Sonu Nigam ji .. sheesh..

lol he compared sanu and lata once and said sanu was better than lata, lata was better than rafi and therefore sanu was better than rafi.. on srgmp forums!

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1067436

heres the link

Reply

Quote

Asha Bhosle vs Alka Yagnik. Who's better?

Related Topics

Explore Topics