27th Dec: Were the judges fair?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Tweety

@SayCheese

Dazzler

Posted: 17 years ago

#21

I am seeing this from both sides.

The jodis were being unprofessional and before going Nach Baliye 4 it was written in their contract that there will be changes in the format.

But i really didnt like the way Farah spoke. She was just too rude if she would have being a constent she wouldnt take it that easily swearing on national tv come on children watch this shows jodisare also people who work long hours the judges are from a bigger industry so it doesnt give them a right to swear at the people who are under them. The jodis said that they didnt want to dance because they get told about this in the middle of the week so why cant they tell them earlier.

And whereas as for Chetan, he is new and already started creating fights. He had prepared a dance so why what was the drama for. I feel it was the others jodis who encouraged him to say all of this but in the end they backed out.

Quote

@asiabunny

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

#22

I understand that the judges were doing their jobs and trying to remain professional - maybe part of the blame might have to go to the production team. They should've informed the jodi's before this round (like a week in advance) for example, if they really wanted to introduce it this week, told them about it the week Mauli was eliminated or told them this week for NEXT week and kept NFL this week.

The judges didn't have to be rude - the jodi's did sign a contract but they also have other jobs that they are commited to. They wouldn't even be considered for NB if they weren't in their serials. NB is a side show they do - they've already got their stardom through the serials they do, NB needs them for people to watch the show.

Two days is plenty IF they didn't have schedules and other things already set up. NFL allowed them to manage their times along with their teamates who could step up if needed. I'm sure if the judges were put in that position, they probably would've reacted the same way.

If we're talking about professinalism, the judges didn't do a good job presenting themselves. I particularly disrespect Farah and Arjun for this - how could they treat the contestants like that? If the contestants weren't there, they wouldn't be judging in the first place. The contestants shouldn't give the judges any more respect that what the judges give them - it doesn't matter whether they are judging or are seen as 'superior', its the contestants at the end of the day that are performing. Everyone deserves equal amount of respect- and I think that the contestants were fair to reply to the judges the way the judges treated them.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

jess

@jeetu19

Beginner

Posted: 17 years ago

#23

hi all,

well it was just too sad to see all that happened. yes the judges were fair and their anger😡 is also justified as we all also know that this naach has 'twist'...so why so much of fuss when its time to face it. yes we may not like many things, i mean the twists, like i don't like yash tonk re-entry its unfair for the existing jodis. but its the format what this show holds.

i appriciate👏 that only sudeep and shaleen were openly supporting chetan as i guess chetan has a small son so it must be more difficult for him. and when chetan voiced the common issue which all jodis also wanted ,...which was so very evident ....no one supported, esp kanjali, naman, reshmi....i am sure if chetan brought out this fact in front of the judges it must have had the consent of the rest jodi's as well.

but judges were right...it is a contest after all and professional attitude is imp, though on the other side i feel sad for all the jodis as most of them are in daily soaps and in addition i also saw shaleen perform in idea ita awards....

i wish all this had not happened🥱...i wish them all the luck for the nest week performances.

Quote

187176

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

#24

They were fair these things happen in EVERY reality show unless these contestents really do live in a bubble (doubt it since most have done 101 reality shows) they know that changes happen at last minute. I can understand farah getting mad as well she is one of the top choreographers and to give her excuses when shes turned up to judge is stupid.

Quote

1 2 3

27th Dec: Were the judges fair? - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics