Laboratory Experiment Results of Episode: 12.12.08

Here is the Laboratory Experiment Results (Written Update) of today's episode (12.12.08):

Combined performances of the Past (2005 - 2007) & present contestants.

1. Debojeet (SRGMP C 2005) & Vaishali

Song: Dhoom Tana

Singers: Abhijeet & Shreya Ghosal

Judges Comments:

All judges: History. You both sang like playback singers.

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

A wonderful performance by both of them. To Me: History

2. Harpreet (SRGMP C 2007) & Pratiba

Song: Pardesi Girl

Singers: Shankar & Vishal

Judges Comments:

Shankar & Aadesh: Super Hit

Pritam: Didn't give her any mark

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

I didn't enjoy the performance. Another average performance by Pratibha, to me. They both sang in lower scale.
To Me: Hit

3. Sumedha (SRGMP C 2007) & Soumen

Song: Tu Hi To Mera Dost Hein

Singers: A.R. Rahman & Shreya

Judges Comments:

All Judges: History

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

An excellent performance. I never had any doubt on the sweetness of Sumedha's voice neither that time nor now. Her voice is as sweet as like her. I enjoyed her performance more than Soumen's.

To me: History (Only for Sumedha)

4. Aneek (SRGMP C 2007) & Yashita

Song: Rock On

Singers: Farhan Akhter

Judges Comments:

All Judges: History

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

An excellent rocking performance. Yashita & Aneek both rocked the whole stage. Yashita again proved, she is a versatile and a true rocker.

To Me: Universal

5. Raja (SRGMP C 2007) & Asma (Didn't match at all)

Song: Tujhey Ackha Beach Ghumadu

Judges Comments:

Aadesh & Shankar: Hit
Pritam: Super Hit

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

Another Greek tragedy. Nothing to say more about this performance. Better you decide.

To me: Disaster

6. Mauli (SRGMP C 2007) & Debojeet

Song: Billo Raani

Singers: Anand Raaz & Richa Sharma

Judges Comments:

All Judges: History ?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!

Aadesh gave him history only for Debo's honesty when he admitted of 90% satisfaction on his own performance. What a reason to give History!!!!!

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

A very good one. Debo was a bit nervous during the performance. No doubt this boy is going to place in Guinness Book of World Records as one of the most over hyped contestant in musical history.

To Me: Super Hit

7. Zaheer Abbas couldn't perform as he was in Pakistan. He greeted all the mentors, contestants and Aditya over phone.

Sangeet Chakra: Pratibha

Eliminated Contestant: Zaheer

His last words were, "I am really sorry if I had committed any mistake"

What song is Dhoom tana?I missed that performance. Asma's performance was not good.I liked Yashita's performance.She rocked.

Asma was disastrous. Shankar didn't even give a comment on her singing. Good thing Raja sang with her.
I like Asma but she needs to go now.

All the old contestants sang so well.

Originally posted by: devashree_h

What song is Dhoom tana?I missed that performance. Asma's performance was not good.I liked Yashita's performance.She rocked.

Thanks for writing this.

A song from the movie Om Shanti Om. Definitely Yashita is a true rocker. BTW, thanks man.

Originally posted by: antar

A song from the movie Om Shanti Om. Definitely Yashita is a true rocker. BTW, thanks man.

asma cant sing.. sorry folks. she just cant sing.

Originally posted by: DizzyBanana21x

Asma was disastrous. Shankar didn't even give a comment on her singing. Good thing Raja sang with her.
I like Asma but she needs to go now.

All the old contestants sang so well.

She is a great entertainer but as a singer she yet has to learn a lot.

GPA of today performance

1. Soumen (Jai Ho Gharana) 👍🏼 A- 3.7 second topper.

Originally posted by: nausrat_fatali

GPA of today performance

1. Soumen (Jai Ho Gharana) 👍🏼 A- 3.7 second topper.

2. Pratibha (Lakshya Gharana) 😲 C 2 for producer to select this song for her
3. Vaishali (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 A- 3.7 today topper.

4. Yashita (Dhoom Gharana) 😊 B+ 3.3 third. was she overconfident again or something wrong with me?

5. Zaheer (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 A+ 4 no performance yet for talent n good person. unfortunate elimination.

6. Debojeet (Dhoom Gharana) 😊 B+ 3.3 gud performance

7. Asma (Rock Gharana) 😡 F 😡

A small correction: Yashita (Dhoom Gharana) 👏 A+ Equally topper with Vaishali

Originally posted by: nausrat_fatali

GPA of today performance

1. Soumen (Jai Ho Gharana) 👍🏼 A- 3.7 second topper.

2. Pratibha (Lakshya Gharana) 😲 C 2 for producer to select this song for her
3. Vaishali (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 A- 3.7 today topper.

4. Yashita (Dhoom Gharana) 😊 B+ 3.3 third. was she overconfident again or something wrong with me?

5. Zaheer (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 A+ 4 no performance yet for talent n good person. unfortunate elimination.

6. Debojeet (Dhoom Gharana) 😊 B+ 3.3 gud performance

7. Asma (Rock Gharana) 😡 F 😡

nausrat bhai bas bina dar se negative markings de do!! 😆