My opinion on yday...

Henna 786 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
Hey!
Almost 24 hours late but who cares lol
Am i the only one who thought ydays episode was an absolute waste of time? 😕
I felt i was watching a musical.. Songs for every move! the only thing missing was backup dancers lol
Now the next part is PURELY my opinion (hey hear me out 😆): I thought the way Jai smiled and stuff was finally natural, usually i feel its sugar coated. Ive always thought RKs strongest point is a crying scene, happy scene i feel is 'fake' no heart is put in it. Bani was good i thought - i had no issues with the way she hugged Jai 😆 Bani is supposed to be the shy one.. guess thats a shy hug, PD did the same too.
I wish they had less scenes like that though, im all up for happiness on screen, if it looks and feels right. Randomly twirling and 'dancing' is taking the micheal (wiv me atleast)
If u missed the episode u havent missed anything major. im starting to miss Meera actually.. some chalak-giri is needed, when everything is happy i cant help but think its artificial looking (before ppl say its cuz its GK, ive said the same in PD phase too 😊)
And on top of everything, im not even the slightest excited over the new Veer.. (well i like Tae Yang so its understandable 😆) storyline will be gripping in the beginning.. then downhill from there 😳
Now everything was just what i feel, im not bashing, its MY thoughts, if ppl can praise, im sure we can give constructive crit too 😊 I know im shooting myself by saying i dnt like RK's acting yday (and other times) when this forum is full of supporters but i do hope many see where i am coming from with it lol.. no one is a complete actor, not even Amitabh Bachan!
Henz......

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

719

Users

3

Frequent Posters

SuganthiS thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

Henna, I'm going to answer your post because I feel that you're pretty fair in writing your posts!

Ok, I'm a RK fan and yes, crying/emotional scenes are his strongest points. And his scenes with the children are really good and scenes which require him to be sarcastic or angry.
But I'm going to differ from you on the happy scenes, cos looking back, Jai as a character has not had too many of those. But I still remember some scenes, like the one where he found out that he's going to be a dad for the first time. Or the ones where he's happy with Krishna and Atharva or his other children. I simply loved those scenes, the happy, carefree Jai. I have found most of his happy scenes "sincere"! (Clever me, I am using sincere as a opposite of fake!😆)
Having said that, I also know that when a majority feel a certain way, some can look at a scene and feel differently. You are right, no one is a complete actor and everyone is learning everyday!
Coming to yesterday's episode, I felt it was a relief from the usual negativity, that's why I liked it. Some felt there should have been an emotional reunion between Jai and Bani. But, Jai and Bani have already bonded as Jai and Pronita. As for the emotional reunion, remember, there was one, which was Pronita's dream before Jigs got her kicked out!
I felt that there was some unnecessary criticism of Gurdeep's acting yesterday, I felt that both Ram and Gurdeep were good in their acting yesterday. Both had to say a lot without words and they did that. But again, some people may see the scenes differently, and hence criticism of Gurdeep.
Honestly speaking, I think Ram is one of the better actors of tellyland who is more subtle in his acting and Gurdeep is good too, though she sometimes does speak a little loudly for the character of Bani who started out as a quiet person. But Henna, as you said, no one is a complete actor, even Amitabh or Aamir, everyone has room to grow!
As for the Veer track, I'm going to wait to give the verdict. Life, and TV land, it seems are unpredictable! About everything being happy, remember, this is KS! There is no "Happy" ever after. I think we'll soon see some big time problems for JB!
Edited by suganthirani - 17 years ago
Henna 786 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: suganthirani

Henna, I'm going to answer your post because I feel that you're pretty fair in writing your posts! aww thanks a huge ton for that 😃

Ok, I'm a RK fan and yes, crying/emotional scenes are his strongest points. And his scenes with the children are really good and scenes which require him to be sarcastic or angry. oh yeh, i forgot to mention, i think he is great with the young kids too, sometimes with Ganga i think it can go too far but hes good with kids 😊
But I'm going to differ from you on the happy scenes, cos looking back, Jai as a character has not had too many of those. thats tru 😆 But I still remember some scenes, like the one where he found out that he's going to be a dad for the first time. Or the ones where he's happy with Krishna and Atharva or his other children. I simply loved those scenes, the happy, carefree Jai. I have found most of his happy scenes "sincere"! (Clever me, I am using sincere as a opposite of fake!😆) damn hats a good word to use! Sincere, you know i understand what u mean, i feel exactly the same, its just overcooked with loads of sugar 😊 Say GK has a issue with her eyebrows, she over does them (when to me i think its cuz of her brow arch, its been shaped like that 😆) RK needs to tone down the way he portrays happiness😊
Having said that, I also know that when a majority feel a certain way, some can look at a scene and feel differently. You are right, no one is a complete actor and everyone is learning everyday! yup.. which is why opinons are great 😃
Coming to yesterday's episode, I felt it was a relief from the usual negativity, that's why I liked it. Some felt there should have been an emotional reunion between Jai and Bani. But, Jai and Bani have already bonded as Jai and Pronita. As for the emotional reunion, remember, there was one, which was Pronita's dream before Jigs got her kicked out! ydays episode i just felt wasnt really there as a union, i felt it was like a weddin anniversary that needed to get over and done with 😆
I agree it was different with the usual negativity but the balance tipped too much to the right, we need Jigs and her venemous words to tilt it back to the middle 😆
I felt that there was some unnecessary criticism of Gurdeep's acting yesterday, I felt that both Ram and Gurdeep were good in their acting yesterday. Both had to say a lot without words and they did that. But again, some people may see the scenes differently, and hence criticism of Gurdeep. i thought GK was better out the two yday, but i think Direction was bad.. why have all those dances - im still baffled about it lol
Honestly speaking, I think Ram is one of the better actors of tellyland who is more subtle in his acting and Gurdeep is good too, though she sometimes does speak a little loudly for the character of Bani who started out as a quiet person. But Henna, as you said, no one is a complete actor, even Amitabh or Aamir, everyone has room to grow! yup.. just like the way education doesnt stoip after uni.. acting doesnt stop at one show, everyone develops.
As for the Veer track, I'm going to wait to give the verdict. Life, and TV land, it seems are unpredictable! About everything being happy, remember, this is KS! There is no "Happy" ever after. I think we'll soon see some big time problems for JB!woot probs for JB something to look fwd to.. again 😆

ABCD thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
I agree with you.....it was more like a filler episode...I wanted to laugh when Rano and Adi were extolling everyone on how great a relationship they shared...and didn't need any words ...blah ...blah ..... it was all so forced and reflective of partial amnesia the creatives and characters suffer from !
SuganthiS thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
Henna, just to clarify, when I used the word "sincere", for the happy scenes, I really meant that I found most of Jai's happy scenes good, sincere!! 😳
Edited by suganthirani - 17 years ago
Henna 786 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
ABCD - lol.. i liked the way Rano spoke she delivers really well i think, but great relationship? Hardly, its a relationship u learn from lol
Suganthirani - cop ya! 👍🏼 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".