Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

Do you all feel that Kunti was wrong in staying silent for a long time regarding Karna? She recognized him the day she saw him..and it's a fact that if she had spoken that day, the history of Mahabharat would have been written some other way......but WHY was she quiet about it?? All through her life, she saw Karna supporting Duryodhan, she knew Karna will never come back to her, she knew Karna and pandavas are developing hatred for each other , yet she never revealed the truth !! Was she right or no? 😕

Charu

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2.6k

Users

7

Frequent Posters

mohit_raja thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
Kunti had a fear of being shameful in front of society that Karna was his eldest son and she gave birth when she was a teen, right before marriage. she had a fear that she would be quetioned before society...this is why she put karna in a basket and put in ganga river.
when she saw his young Karna in competition ground, she fainted..how would she say that time that Karna was his eldest son.
i personally say that Kunti was also a wrong...she could have said that Karna was his eldest son as she gained conscious but she remained silent....A true mother with great maternity will not do such thing...Kunti was just a coward mother......Karna rightly said that whe she didn't come to Adhirath's house to give him bless and tell him that he was his son.........Kunti revealed secrets after lord krishna told her to meet karna......she met him after the declaration of war...it was tooo late
Karna was so kind hearted that he didn't let her mother go empty handed...he promised that she will always have five sons..he will not kill any of pandavas except arjuna.
352006 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
was karan shown in any of de episode of dis week
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: mohit_raja

Kunti had a fear of being shameful in front of society that Karna was his eldest son and she gave birth when she was a teen, right before marriage. she had a fear that she would be quetioned before society...this is why she put karna in a basket and put in ganga river.

when she saw his young Karna in competition ground, she fainted..how would she say that time that Karna was his eldest son.
i personally say that Kunti was also a wrong...she could have said that Karna was his eldest son as she gained conscious but she remained silent....A true mother with great maternity will not do such thing...Kunti was just a coward mother......Karna rightly said that whe she didn't come to Adhirath's house to give him bless and tell him that he was his son.........Kunti revealed secrets after lord krishna told her to meet karna......she met him after the declaration of war...it was tooo late
Karna was so kind hearted that he didn't let her mother go empty handed...he promised that she will always have five sons..he will not kill any of pandavas except arjuna.

you can never understand the delimma of a mother because you are not a woman..unwed mothers don't have a place in the society of TODAY then how is it possible that people would have accepted it in dwapar yug?
but yes, she could have acknowledged that karna is her son long back before the mahabharat war..WHY she didn't do it is the purpose of creating this thread...i think the main reason for it was that it must have been difficult because karna was born before her marriage with Pandu.
Charu
ananyacool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
Apart from her dilemma of being an unwed mother Kunti also feared that if Yudhistara would know that Karna was his elder brother, he would have never excepted that crown, instead he would have given that to Karna and Karna ,under the obligation of Duryodhan would have given that crown to Duryodhan which Kunti never wanted it to happen so that way she was a shrewd mother also 😳
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

Even today, in the 21st century, if women have illegitimate children, people look down upon them, and call the whores and what not. Kunti was a mere maiden of 13 or 14 when she had Karna, and she did not know right from wrong. Although this does not excuse her behavior, it gives us a reason why she did it. What would she have done? She was a young girl, and she was scared she would bring disgrace to her father. Except for one or two of her most trusted maids, no one knew of her pregnancy. If you think of it in today's terms, at least she didn't get an abortion (although I don't think abortions existed back then?).

After marrying Pandu, Kunti became a queen of the Great Kurus, whose fame was known widespread. She had expectations to live up to, so it would have been worse for the news to come out then than before. In the martial exhibition, she didn't say Karna was her son, because she was still a queen, or at least princess, of the Kuru-Vansh, and she still had the house honor to uphold.
I feel sorry for the character of Kunti, because although she made several mistakes, she still suffered. Also, it was destiny that the Mahabharat happen the way it did, or Duryodhan wouldn't die. If Kunti had told everyone that Karan was her son, and if he had joined the Pandavas, much of the story would have been changed, and the war might not even have happened, because without Karna on his side, Duryodhan was nothing.
I think Kunti told Karna about his brothers in the end, because she felt she had no course of action left except for the truth to be known, and she desperately wanted the war to be averted. If she had told the Pandavas that Karna was their brother, they would have refused to fight, and Duryodhan would continue to keep the kingdom while the Pandavas continued to live with Virata and Draupadi would have remained unavenged. I think the one main reason everything happened in the Mahabharat as it did is fate, or destiny. There can be no other explanation.
Aradhana87 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
Wow..nice opinion Godisone😊
I also think Kunti kept her silence as she was a renowned queen.This would "spoil her reputation".
Maybe(my opinion)she was also quiet because who would believe her?Only Pandu, Rishi Durvasa and Madri knew about the boon she got.Maybe the kawach and kundal could be prove that Karna is son of Suryadev but how does she prove that she is his mother?
And would Karna and the parents who raised him accept it?
So I think think Kunti did not say anything because of her reputation and all those questions who could have been asked if she told everyone about Karna.
mohit_raja thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
i agree on godisone's opinion 😕
Edited by mohit_raja - 17 years ago
ananyacool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: luv_khwaish

you can never understand the delimma of a mother because you are not a woman..unwed mothers don't have a place in the society of TODAY then how is it possible that people would have accepted it in dwapar yug?
but yes, she could have acknowledged that karna is her son long back before the mahabharat war..WHY she didn't do it is the purpose of creating this thread...i think the main reason for it was that it must have been difficult because karna was born before her marriage with Pandu.
Charu

Rishi veda-vyas was also born of Queen Satyavati (from rishi Parashar,who was the son of Vashishtha) before her marriage,but she acknowledged vyasa as her son in front of the whole world;not just that but also she made him have 'niyoga' with the widowed wifes of Vichitra virya................Wonder why Kunti doesn't acknowledge Karna as her son born out of wedlock??😕😕
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ananyacool

Rishi veda-vyas was also born of Queen Satyavati (from rishi Parashar,who was the son of Vashishtha) before her marriage,but she acknowledged vyasa as her son in front of the whole world;not just that but also she made him have 'niyoga' with the widowed wifes of Vichitra virya................Wonder why Kunti doesn't acknowledge Karna as her son born out of wedlock??😕😕

Although Satyavati also became a queen of the Kurus, she was originally a fisherman's daughter, and things like honor for her father's family and all that didn't matter to her. Kunti was kshatriya princess, and she had ideals and codes of honor to live up to. Plus, Satyavati's sons already had the throne of Hastinapura practically thrown at their feet no matter what, due to Devavrat's vow, but Kunti's sons were continuously antagonized by Duryodhana, and anything that would mar their chances to the throne, or cause anyone to ridicule them, would have made Duryodhan very happy, so Kunti had to think before she acted every step she took.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".