Panchi vs. Prachi today - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.8k

Users

13

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

Deepika26 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: blackcurrant

@jyoti06. I agree she does look uncomfortable as Panchi Das Gupta. Unfortunately, she is also carrying that look in her scenes with Milind where instead she is supposed to be looking misearble, guilty but also madly in love with him. That part is just not being conveyed.

@Opti&JC. Milind's situation during the PA track is a lot like Prachi's in this one. He was also supposedly torn between his duty to Ayesha and love for Prachi. But it was just not convincing cos they severly cut down on the Milind-Ayesha scenes which is a pity cos no matter what anyone says, Shabbir and Sanjeeda did have chemistry. It may not be on the scale of Michi but they are both such good actors and thier scenes always looked very polished in terms of acting. Anyway, if there had been more Ayesha-Milind scenes, we would have been more convinced of his dilemma. Just like in this track, Prachi main reason for staying with the Das Gupta's seems to be Suproteek but we have not a single scene of them really bonding.


very true!!!!!!!!!! there was not a single scene shown between suproteek and panchi bonding😕
Opti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: blackcurrant

\ Milind's situation during the PA track is a lot like Prachi's in this one. He was also supposedly torn between his duty to Ayesha and love for Prachi. But it was just not convincing cos they severly cut down on the Milind-Ayesha scenes which is a pity cos no matter what anyone says, Shabbir and Sanjeeda did have chemistry. It may not be on the scale of Michi but they are both such good actors and thier scenes always looked very polished in terms of acting. Anyway, if there had been more Ayesha-Milind scenes, we would have been more convinced of his dilemma. Just like in this track, Prachi main reason for staying with the Das Gupta's seems to be Suproteek but we have not a single scene of them really bonding.

Very true BC, but in the PA track I think they were forced to cut down on the Ayesha scenes after the reactions they got for that first MA hug and the scene where he carried her over his shoulders in front of the entire family. What irritated me the most is that Milind was made to look like a fool in it and not like a business tycoon. Afterall the guy was a wealthy businessman in Turkey where he was supposed to have had the accident (atleast according to Ayesha). All he lost was a year's memory. Yet he did not seem to register anything. Even at work all he did was to give blank stares. People hated the PA track for what it did to Milind and Shabbo. That track literally numbed one's senses.
In this track they could have shown more of Prachi-Suproteek bonding but for some strange reason, except for the odd occassion when she mentioned Suproteek, all they showed was Prachi mouthing dialogues about how she cannot leave the D-family for what they did for her. Maybe the reason they are doing it is Prachi will ultimately leave the family. If they had showed a close bond between Suproteek and her, then it would have been more hard on the child. I am not too convinced by this argument myself because BT shows have never placed the child's interest first. Anyway this whole leap track is beginning to stink like a cess pool. I thought the LIL track will be interesting to watch with Milind finding innovative ways to keep tapping at Prachi's conscience till she buckles and a lot of Mito interactions in between. The start was good but they seem to not know how to carry it forward. Mito scenes have dwindled and the scenarios are becoming more and more ridiculous. Its time they put a full stop to this nonsense and get Michito back together.
NosVemos thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#23
There is one difference between Milind's situation in PA and Prachi's in fake track. Milind didn't know why he was in a dilemma. He was confused as his brain told him he loved Ayesha and was going to marry her but his heart went out for Prachi.
But Prachi has no PA. She is in all her senses and she is not supposed to look confused. She is supposed to look miserable, hurting and emotionally torn. She cries a lot, but doesn't convey Prachi's pain.
Opti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#24
Shubs, I dont think Panchi is too convinced playing Panchi Dasgupta. I dont think Shabbo was too convinced by the PA Milind too because he did not look sufficiently confused by his mixed emotions for Prachi and Ayesha. His stares were mostly blank. Even towards the end of the track on the terrace scene when he realised Prachi's love for him, I felt Panchi's acting was better than Shabbo's although there was scope for him to perform in that scene. It looked like the hibernation of the preceding four months had taken a toll on his acting. In the scene where he stands in front of the mirror and wonders what he should do before the wedding we saw the return of the old Shabbo. The MA wedding scene was awesome and the there was no stopping him. I guess the actor too needs to be convinced by his/her character to give it their best. The screen play and the direction too matters.
Edited by optimist - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".