[
Right i absolutely agree with you. Bhanu Pratap Singh his name is. He was trying to control his tears , and i salute him for even under such emotional stress he sang so well and then Anu Malik felt let him come in and try his luck so that next time he will not try.
He sings well and his voice is good too. He will improve staying over there practicing and learning and thereby growing.
Actually some people fall in love with music and they cannot think of leaving it totally even if they know they cannot become Indian Idol or a play back singer. But they are happy to go for some conert and shows and keep singing in their heart and also earning something.
Bhanu is a good singer and should come upto atleast top 15 or 10. so that people know him and he gets some social functions and festivals offer to sing , may be he will feel happy that way that he is in touch with music. WHO KNOWS HE MAY IMPROVE OVER TIME AND HAS A STRONG MIND AND DETERMINATION AND WITH ALL OF OUR VOTES MAY GET ENCOURAGED TO DO BETTER
QUOTE=Surkilla]
Originally posted by: salmaankhan86
no, i think you're wrong here .. he was initally rejected because of his performance .. but anu malik can be weird sometimes and takes instantaneous decisions sometimes .. i feel anu got emotional seeing bhanu trying to get through to the "top 28" for the third time and he felt bad telling him he was out .. when javed akhtar gave the example, anu malik got more charged up and decided to ask him to sing a song, and if bhanu reached anu's expectations, he was in - which he did!
it wasn't that the judges were playing with his emotions - not at all!
.. my opinion anyway! 😊
Even I thought the same. Anu rejected him based on his performance but when Javed Sab gave the example and suggested Bhanu to try again, Anu thought why to have that guy go through all that misery again if he is going to try indian idol again why not give him another chance right then and if he is not good , he will do something better with his life, So he gave him another chance and that guy, Bhanu poured his heart out and sang a song so full of emotions that all the judges decided that this guy who is singing with such an honesty deserves a chance.
I felt when he was crying judges were very uncomfortable and they were trying all they could to make him stop crying. It was such an emotional moment for everyone there.
Bhanu was controlling his tears all the time and the moment he heard that he was in, he just let go.
Seher Hone Ko Hai
Taara
Indian Premier League
Anupamaa
