Round 8 - Feedback Thread

Page

Next Last

Anuradha Ravi

@Anuradha

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

THIS IS A "MEMBERS ONLY" POST
The Author of this post have chosen to restrict the content of this Post to members only.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Summer3

@Summer3

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

Wow Great, I notice everyone has put great efforts in the singing and sung well. Looks like they should be able to replace the current bunch of singer on the SRGMP Show. further comments will follow.👏👏👏

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Summer3

@Summer3

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

I note that all the singers have taken great trouble to record and perfect themselves. Basically all have the potential to be great singers as the voice quality and timings are good. Differences are mainly due to the singing technique and song selections.

NB: Kindly note that I am musically untrained and judgment is quite flawed, but I liked Lava's song the best followed by Rock n Roll and Kiti. I am judging on a scale of 1 to max 5 points.

Sorry if I have offended anyone.

1. Lava. Nice song selectiona and good control and technique. Nice voice for sentimental songs. Voice a bit soft but okay. - This is History. 5 points

2.Minirulz. Sang well and can definitely sing catchy fast numbers well. Song is quite demanding with lots of variations.- This is a Superhit - 4 pints

3.Evilseye. Nice voice for country and folk songs. Song was a bit draggy.Super Hit. 4 points

4. Rock n Roll - Very sweet voice and plenty of power. Diction very clear. Song is quite demanding. Sung well needs slight refinement in technique. super super Hit. 4.5 points

5. Kiti. Nice voice and sung well. High part "O" was not fully released. Still a Super super Hit. 4.5 points

6. Mala. Sang well but certain parts "baala ma" was slightly out. Still a Super Hit. 4 points

7. Naughty nice. Good voice a bit flat in some areas. Nicely performed. Super Hit 4 points

Quote

Don't worry, be happy.

@Ranbirrocks

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

Wow, this is Semi finals now. As usual I am here to give my FB. Shall keep on editing , so please bear with me.once again, a Disclaimer that I have no knowledge of music and I can't sing to save my life😳, but I listen to songs and I can surely give FB as a layman ( why is there no Laywoman😉)...

1) Kirti aka Kitti_g : 👏👏 You sung the song really well. Nice song selection to show off your talent in this crucial round. Started off really well, but in the antra (para), specially first and last para, you kind of lost sur in one place. But you recovered very well . I will not give you 4.75/ 5 😃.

2) Mala - You sung the song well👏. The only thing that I found missing in the entire song was "Pep", the naughtiness that is in the original song . I wish you sung some lines of Ila Arun's part also. But it was a good attempt. Good luck. I give you 4/5

3) Naughty_n_nice - You sung really well 👏. I feel that this type of song needs the support of background music and if you are singing without it, no matter how much you try, it will sound as if it lacks the pep. You got a very good voice and I wish you had choosen a better song. 4/5 👏

4) Mini - Perfecto ⭐️. I was trying hard to find a single slip😆, but I couldn't find anything lacking. I loved the way you sung "meri jaaaan....kurbaaaan".....5/5 😃⭐️👏

Rest in the next post 😳

Edited by tvfan1401 - 17 years ago

Quote

Don't worry, be happy.

@Ranbirrocks

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

5) Lava : You have a lovely voice and you have chosen a perfect song to display all your abilites👏. At one place I felt that during the low notes, your sur dipped.....but its a Lata Mangeshkar song, so I will be giving you a 5/5 for giving a near perfect performance !!!!!

6) Rock n roll - 👏👏 Perfect !!! What a throw you have in your voice 👏.....very well sung and without any commentry, let me say its 5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️

7) Evils Eye - You sung it really well.👏.....its a song that is played almost in every event now a days and sung in all reality shows, so you have a disadvantage of being compared with everyone😆.......Very nice attempt .....I felt that you didn't sing it with 100% power or throw in your voice.....I don't know the technical term to describe it, but it sounded 95% to me😳.....I may be wrong as I am complete zero in music.....Apologies if I am blaberring😳.....I give you 4.5/5 .....

Edited by tvfan1401 - 17 years ago

Quote

advil

@advil

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

Reserved. Shall post my comments as soon as I am done listening to the songs.

Request to members, mentors , all participants as well as coordinators to please give their feedback. The show is almost at its last lap, lets give the contest the ovation the only way we can...by participating in it.😛

Edited by advil - 17 years ago

Quote

amukta

@amukta

Dazzler

Posted: 17 years ago

My candidate Lava was the best in this round.Her song selection and the way she sang was just fab.Rock and roll and Kiti were also good ...but in this round .. Lava was the best.Her voice is so clean and very sweet sounding..All the others have done a good job too.

Quote

Lata

@muscleprotein

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

very impressive performance by all contestants!! sounded very original. very commendable , especially with no musical accompaniments to back up!!! Well done one and all. Judges are going to have a tough time!!!

Me no great music expert , below are my comments :

lava 29: A lovely composition of Gulzar and Bhupen Hazarika, pictursied on teh lovely Dimple Kapadia!!!

renedered perfect. singing with a little more feeling will take you the the top!!

Mini : rendered the song well, with the pep but the teasing banter could have been used more!!

Rock n Roll: good voice control on the whole and rendered with feeling!!!!! sounded faintly nasal otherwise very good !!!

evils eye: started very well, with a lot of feeling!!but sort of tapers off in the middles , eventually picks up at the end!! need to be more consistent!!

kiti_g :good rhythm and voice control, but slightly a little high pitched at one point, makes it sound a littel off key!! the part of ooooo hooooooo very good!! a light hearted song need to render with a slightly naughty feel , otherwise very good!!!!!!

mala_sss : a rajasthani song picturised on Sridevi. a fairly difficult song!!! need to sing with a lot more feeling , the slow bit did not fit in well here, but being fair there was no muscial instrument back up!! towards the end you do bring in that masti tone!!

naughty n nice: a song which relies a lot on beat of a dholki , despite that a good job done!!! gets a little out of tune at one or two places!!

Good luck to all!!!