stupid show with mean rude judges - Page 2

i read an article on this forum that say that anu malik struggled to reach where he is . He used to wait outside music directors offices , most of the times without food and people had been the rude to him . He is known to be the rudest judge on indian idol and he doesnt care .He said himslef that he has a "i dont give a damn attitude" He simply 4 gets he is what he is today because of the people of india . It is them who appreciate his music . he needs to learn how to give back and respect people. Just cos he struggled doesnt mean he needs to be rude to others . Get a life Anu Malik !

yeah nida..i totally agree with u the judges are horrible..they just go way outta line sometimes with their criticisms and stuf..and they think they are so funny at times..they just really need to recognize that we as viwers dont appreciate this.....i do enjoy the show though but not because of them but its fun cuz sometimes some of the contestants try to make such fools of themselves like the guy who was trying to sing "ashiq banaya apne "

I agree wid u all somewat. I think they shpuld tone it down a little. But havin said that, i find anu malik's comments really funny sometimes. Sonu is da best judge though.

i dont understand the point of having farah khan as a judge anyway..she's not even a singer?? does anyone agree?..maybe its cuz she is a choreographer so they want her to judge the performance of the contestants is that why?? but in indian idol its more of singing and less performance..hmm..anyways just a thought

Indian Idol is overall everything. The singing.. voice.. performance.. the way you carry yourself.

But I HATE ANU MALIK. He should listen to his own voice and make comment on him only. They don't need to be rude. I remember when a school teacher came for audition and he sang I think a song from Namakhalal.. "o' neenaaaaaaaaaaaaa", he was so funny and voice quality was so poor.. but Anu made very nasty comment on him saying that tum teacher ho, teacher hi bane raho.. kabhi bhi gaane ki koshish mat karna. You are not even near to singing level.. something like that. I think that was very rude. Anu should known that lots of his student probably watching him performing. How insulting was that.

I feel like I go to India and participate in Indian Idol II, just to shut Anu's mouth by insulting him about commenting other ppl's performance. I am not a good singer but would just like to go to audition to insult all of them, especially Anu Malik. 😡

Sorry folks!