The Winner Of The Grand Finale Is Already Decided

antar thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
I think this season SRGMP Team already decided to crown Debojeet . Just lets go for a postmortem.

Postmortem:

1. At 29 & 30th August episodes 4 most challenging and strong contestants eliminated (Shashi, Fareed & Arshad, Sunvinder). They were equally strong as Debojeet even in some cases better than him. As long as they are here it will be a difficult task for the team to crown Debo.
2. At 23rd August episode Sayan's elimination also indicate the same. Sayan was from West Bengal and Debo also from the same and the SRGMP team didn't want to see Sayan sharing votes against Debo from the same zone.
3. So far Debo has been over hyped by the judges. Despite a good or bad performance of Debo, it's been a regular exercise for the judges to went into the stage and applause him and celebrate. Specially Himesh's & Adi's asking for autographs to him clearly indicate some disturbing premonitions to crown him.
4. Despite the presence of some excellent & superb female contestants like Yashita, Pratibha, Mitika & Naina, they will not gonna win this season also, IMHO. I think the producer, director & the judges are not yet ready to see any girl as a champ of such shows, for this one too.
5. It's very safe to pull all the Pakistani contestants in the final 12 as because whatever happens at least majority votes will not go for them and they will eliminate one by one for sure.

Calculation:

Boys - 5
Girls - 7
----------
Total - 12

As I already mentioned not a single girl gonna win so among 12 only 5 will remain. Sorry to Yashita, Mitika, Anupama, Pratibha, Sara, Naina & Deepali.

Total 12 - 7 (Girls) = 5 (Boys)

Among the 5 boys 3 are from Pakistan (Faraz, Shujat & Zaheer) and only one of them will reach to the finale (Only per the format of last year).

5 Boys(2 Ind + 3 Pak) -2 Pak = 3 Boys

Now among the 3 finalists it may be Kaushik or any girl, 1 Pakistani & Debo is for sure. There is no chance for Kaushik to win as like as the girls (Same for the contestant who will re-enter through Brahma Aastra).

3-1 = 2 (Debo & 1 from Pak)

And the same thing will happen like last year.

Winner - Debojeet

Now, at the end of Grand Finale, Debo might think people crowned him but if such things happened is it really after all of these !!

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

2.7k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

tripler thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
from a voice quality standpoint, i liked shashi, manisha and sayon
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
Ha ha ha ..SRGMP should take notice of this forum..how well we have understood their strategy ....
Great analysis antar 👏....well , as long as Naina ( the best IMO), Kaushik, Zaheer, Mitika,Pratibha r there among top 7 I am going to watch the show after that li'l champs hai naa😉...at least there I know how Anamika, Amir, Rohanpreet and Vaishali sing😃
mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
So long as naina and pratibha are here...I will watch the show
Once they leave will siwtch to Indian idol 4
it can't get crappier than this;)
m_khan90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
Great Analysis Antar. I wrote after the intro episode that a Bengali is a winner this year too. There were six Bengali contestants and it has to be one a winner. After the Debojeet first performance the way judges react I know they have already decided who is going to be winner. There is one Punjabi girl I do not remember the name she is going to be the first runner up and third will probably be Shujat if he did not get eliminated. So ppl do not waste your money.
Summer3 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
Zee wants a lady singer this time as there have been too many male singers. Pratibha/Naina could be the one. Kaushik seems better than Debu. Things could change as competition progresses.
m_khan90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Summer3

Zee wants a lady singer this time as there have been too many male singers. Pratibha/Naina could be the one. Kaushik seems better than Debu. Things could change as competition progresses.

Its true. The real competition begins from next week with the final 14 or whatever. Things could change for sure. ZeeTv would not give up so easily. They are in the business to make money. How can they give up. I still wonder they paid Himesh 20 crores (highest out of all) as reported somewhere I read. All they do is judge. They are called mentors but I doubt they give any time to their students. I read Taruns interview, he said plain truth that they have no say in choosing the songs. The interviewer ask why you guys choose a song in a do or die situation ( Don, Badshah etc) so Tarun says songs are given to them to sing whether they like it or not. I do not understand why the mentors say that you choose the wrong song blah blah...
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: mintyblue

So long as naina and pratibha are here...I will watch the show

Once they leave will siwtch to Indian idol 4
it can't get crappier than this;)

Singing wise , it does ...only we know what to expect there 😆...but SRGMP comes with huge expectations ...hence the frustrations...
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
I do like Debojit. At times he has given average performances, but at times his performances were superb. His entry one was excellent. I heard the same song sung by Aneek and some others, but no one came to the par level with Debo. He has some presentation/behaviour problems, which his parents talked about once, but I do understand that since I have some relatives like that - kind of very high IQ level, I do think...
Manisha is also from Bengal, and I like her. I also like Mitika, Naina, and Prathibha (she looks like Bani to me). Among the boys, I like Debo and Shujat. I also liked Arshad, Sayon, and Sunvinder. Whatever it is and whoever wins, I will watch the show for the music, dance, and Aditya's hosting skills. 😃 I dont mind either one of Debo, Mitika, Naina, Prathibha becoming the winner. I cannot say for others I have mentioned earlier, as it is not sure yet as to who all would be making to the top ten finalists round...
mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: akanna

I do like Debojit. At times he has given average performances, but at times his performances were superb. His entry one was excellent. I heard the same song sung by Aneek and some others, but no one came to the par level with Debo. He has some presentation/behaviour problems, which his parents talked about once, but I do understand that since I have some relatives like that - kind of very high IQ level, I do think...

Manisha is also from Bengal, and I like her. I also like Mitika, Naina, and Prathibha (she looks like Bani to me). Among the boys, I like Debo and Shujat. I also liked Arshad, Sayon, and Sunvinder. Whatever it is and whoever wins, I will watch the show for the music, dance, and Aditya's hosting skills. 😃 I dont mind either one of Debo, Mitika, Naina, Prathibha becoming the winner. I cannot say for others I have mentioned earlier, as it is not sure yet as to who all would be making to the top ten finalists round...

My dear, Mnaisha and shahsi are out. They will both be singers in future, but sareagam won't be repsonsible😡 and dare they atke the credits!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".