Love is ugly, and this show is uglier

gp00 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
I thought I'd just say a few things about how preposterous this track is getting, and also to provide a "reality check" about all of our assumptions. Please feel free to add or challenge the ideas contained here within.


Time frame from Yuv/Tanya wedding to now: two months or so? Really not that much time for Yuv/Tanya to fall in love.

Yuv/Tanya will fall in love with each other: to this day, everything from the marriage, stolen glances, to balming T's feet, makes it somewhat clear where the track is headed. However, I will play the contrarian. I still am not buying it...fully anyway. I'm not sure why. I do know that Yuv thinks of her as his little sister (a sick thought but hey), and that's okay given how little time has elapsed since the marriages.

Yuv/Tanya will be brought together by the pregnancy, turning from friend to love interests. No, absolutely not. Tanya's pregnancy changes so many things: the validity of her marriage to Yuv to her ability to get close to Yuv knowing she has someone else's baby inside. I've never seen a guy and a pregnant woman fall in love under these circumstances.So for the shorter-term, I expect them to act like sister/brother.

Nupur's manipulation of Tanya
Tanya is easily manipulated as we've seen time and again. She truly loves her sister and has empathy for what she is going--clearly not enough to tell her the truth. In difficult circumstances, it's as if her mind goes on automatic shut-down mode, like nuclear power plants or a US Postal Services. I think Nupur will continue to play with Tanya and will convince her how terrible Trish is being to "sweet, loving Yuv." Tanya will not think and will react. Say what you will about Trish, at least she can figure out what games her mother-in-law is playing. Now, do you think it will come to the point where Tanya will be rude to Trish? And, if so, what will Yuv say to that? I bet you he would not happy about it one bit.


I don't think everyone except Deep has fully dealt with their emotions. I'm expecting fireworks when they do.

Trish "has fallen in love" with Rajdeep
No, I actually don't think that is the case. I think she cares "deep"ly 😆 about him and is committed to making their marriage work. It's been a few weeks - 4 - since their weddings. And this is just not enough time. You can see the hurt still in Trishna's voice when she accuses Yuv of once again trying to destroy her chances at happiness. It's really as if she's suspended her emotions for Yuv and is focusing on salvaging something in her life, something she can hold on to and not be hurt by.

What do you think? Looking foward to your replies.

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

622

Users

3

Frequent Posters

soni_kuri thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
I think the pregnancy can make Yuv and Taanya close its similar to Kumkum where Kumkum was pregnant and married Sumit her brother in law when her husband died

it's not exactly the same though since Tanya has been raped

but who knows :)
Rhimjhimsawan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#3

2 months seem like enough to fall in love (how long did Raj know Trish? ) I don't think Raj or Tanya love each other yet. They are good friends. And they truly care about each other. The relationship will head for a love story soon. The signs have been clear!😳

Maybe you don't remember but they were already married before the ceremony. You might not agree with it but that's how it went. I am not a hindu so my knowledge is limited here 😕. A pregnant woman taking pheras, is that a huge abshagun or does it make the marriage invalid? Eitherway she was already married to Yuv before taking pheras. So it doesn't matter.😆

As for carrying someone else's child Yuv married her to protect her from any sort of harm. I think he will stick by this one too no matter what happens. Realistically I have no experience here Show wise Kumkum Sumit (one of the best couples on tv) and Karan Nandini (the jodi that wins best jodi every year) Nandini was raped. Karan raised and loved the child more than his own son. So I think it is possible to love someone knowing the child is not yours.

I doubt Yuv loves her as a sister. If he did he wouldn't have married her. Under no circumstance does a guy marry a girl he looked at as a sister.When a guy marries his brother's wife (have seen it happen in real life as well as show) I doubt people look at it as a brother sister relationship. Tanya/ Yuv's relationship is far from it. Even before the marriage they were friends rather than this is my sister's future hubby! This is my wife's younger sister. Yuv started protecting her before he jumped into a relationship with Trish.

Tanya is easy to manipulate. But if Nupur's manipulation makes her stand up to the harsh Trish then I am all for it 👏. And if the choice ever came between standing by Tanya or Trish I think Yuv will be by Tanya 😃. Not because he is married to her or he loves her. But they have a different connection. It's quite deep. He feels the need to protect her (very strong urge it seems). He protects her from her nightmares, her own family, even Trish. So he will get mad at Trish instead if she lashes out on Tanya. He already did before.

I didn't see the hurt in Trish's voice. She was furious. And if you were talking about her shaky voice that's mostly her acting. Unless she is mad her voice shakes during emotional scenes. I am not sure if she has completely fallen for Rajdeep but she is definitely falling! She also cares about him. And she also said she won't be able to live without him. Now as a Yuv/Trish fan you might want to look over it. But the fact is the connection is deep. As for her feelings toward Yuvraj she is moving on.😳

cheers!
Edited by Perfangel5655 - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".