Why I quit Indian Idol II

cdesai12 thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
Why I quit Indian Idol II
rediff.com

Archana Pania | November 21, 2005 19:04 IST

It's been over a month now. When they found out I had qualified for the second round of Indian Idol II, my family and friends were a lot more excited than I was. I simply had mixed feelings. There had been no childhood dreams of winning a singing competition, after all! Still, it's always fun when you're not taking things too seriously.

The best thing is, this reality show gave me a much-needed reality check.

To start at the beginning, what helped was the fact that there were a lot of other people – including my boss, colleagues, the watchman from Nepal and neighbours – who felt pride at the thought that I was a contestant. Then there was that little thing about emotion – the idea that millions experienced what each contestant went through. It was a bit like war, with participants fighting a battle to win the hearts of millions. Neighbouring aunties promised to vote for me, and even the office canteen boy looked at me differently when he realised I was part of the show!

More on rediff.com !


Mehmood rocks in Bluffmaster!

Harry Potter casts box office spell

Comedy in the Muslim world?


So, keeping all this in mind, and ignoring that nagging voice in my head asking me not to attempt Round Two, I went for it. How I wish I hadn't.

At this point, I can't help recalling an incident from the first round. I was the third person in line when, without warning, a camera and crew shot up in front of me. Wearing a fake smile, a man asked, "Why do you think you will be the next Indian Idol?" Without a second's delay, I replied, "I don't think I will be." People around me burst out laughing. But I was just being honest.

Coming back, I was just not sure about attempting Round Two. I realised I would be just another face generating interesting content for people to giggle about. I knew I wasn't hungry for the title. My colleagues were shocked. I told them I was not interested in sleeping and waking up to a camera just to entertain people. I am not a personality or an actor (who is getting paid for the same). All I had wanted was a bit of fun. So, going through Round Two would mean a waste of not just my time, but also that of the judges and production crew.

But one of my colleagues was insistent. She said she wouldn't go if I didn't. And she had been taking singing lessons for 13 years! I couldn't help agree.

We arrived well in time. One of the women at the show was trying hard to be nice. She probably remembered me from the last time, when I had given her a piece of my mind for making us wait 13 hours without food before asking us for a sound byte.

A
ll contestants are given accommodation for four days during the qualifying round. The girl I mentioned asked us to check in with our bags. Considering I didn't have one, she scoffed at me for the 27th time, gave me someone else's bag, and told us to walk in holding it while they filmed!

There was work to be done at the office, so my colleague and I begged to be let off for a few hours. All the while, I continued to dither. Should I, shouldn't I? I didn't want to go on, but, at the same time, there was that free five-star accommodation to consider. Five hours later, I ended up returning to the shoot. We returned to find a panicky production guy, who said that other contestants had also wanted to go out after we left. Apparently, we had set a bad example, so the show's producer wanted to talk to us. We were duly asked not to leave for the next three days. We could go only where they told us to go, and do only what they asked us to.

After a short conversation with my boss over the cell phone, during which I giggled a lot, my colleague asked me to keep it down. She said there had been insinuations by the production crew that I didn't care about being the next Indian Idol. Laughing was not allowed. At that point, I knew I had to make up my mind. Was I going to take their behaviour? Or was I going to laugh my way out of the place?

I called a friend, a guy I refer to as my spiritual guide. All he said was that if there was no passion in it, and if I was in a "don't know" zone, maybe it wasn't for me. He was right. I had never had much to do with singing. I had tried learning from two gurus in the past, both of whom I had run away from. So, why spend time with people who clearly knew little about music – let alone 'launching' talent – and compete for something I didn't want in the first place? Just to make my neighbours happy?

Turning to my colleague, I told her I had to get out. I hugged her, wished her luck and left.

Looking back, those eight hours changed my life. I stood up for myself. I felt good about the fact that no one managed to take my laughter away from me. I could giggle as much as I wanted to.

A few people still refer to me as 'Idol'. I'm hoping they stop. Soon. I can see no pride in being someone who smiles when he or she is told to. I don't need a title for being someone's puppet. I like my own title, Archana Pania! And, you know what, I don't need a million votes to burst into song whenever I feel like either...

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

syrene thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
Whoa! is that really true 😲 tnx for sharing
jprasad thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
wow...what an article. Thanks for posting.
mysterioussme thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
i m confused....can sumone explain to me...wht is the article abt????? 😕 😕
Shakstar thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
wat an article!! u got a pic of dis person?
delphic_oracle thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: snehal_ms

i m confused....can sumone explain to me...wht is the article abt????? 😕 😕

Here's what I got from the article:

Its well written and all that, shows that the person has the spirit to stand up for herself. That's worth a round of applause. I get the points she is making about Sony people constantly gettign participants to flash fake smiles and holing them up like prisoners who can't do what they want to.

BUT I get the feeling that somewhere in her head this Archana person is regretting her decision to leave the second round. I mean, why else would she write this article? It's just full of justifications, looks like she feels she has to prove a point to someone. If she honestly didn't care and was taking it so lightly, would she have waited those 13 hours in the first place? I don't think so. And if she honestly didn't care, she wouldn't have written this article, cos inna way, its going to get her attention, right?

That's my gut feeling!

cdesai12 thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
it was an interesting article
niky thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: delphic_oracle

Here's what I got from the article:

Its well written and all that, shows that the person has the spirit to stand up for herself. That's worth a round of applause. I get the points she is making about Sony people constantly gettign participants to flash fake smiles and holing them up like prisoners who can't do what they want to.

BUT I get the feeling that somewhere in her head this Archana person is regretting her decision to leave the second round. I mean, why else would she write this article? It's just full of justifications, looks like she feels she has to prove a point to someone. If she honestly didn't care and was taking it so lightly, would she have waited those 13 hours in the first place? I don't think so. And if she honestly didn't care, she wouldn't have written this article, cos inna way, its going to get her attention, right?

That's my gut feeling!

Hi delphic .... hmmm i dont think she regrets anything or trying to get attention , its an article about what she experienced being there . I think for many of us who have watched it on tv but never experienced would never know or understand what goes on there or how it is to be there . you mentioned that she waited for 13 hours .... she was there cos she had a different intention in mind as she mentioned "fun " not on the intention of winning ! But , her experince made her wanna leave from it y ? everything was set by their rules and restrictions the she couldnt deal with the environment that she was in . watchin the indian idol 1 auditions i always wondered how poeple could take insults from anu & farah an also wondered what it was like being there . i guess my question has been answered . Good article !!

mysterioussme thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: delphic_oracle

Here's what I got from the article:

Its well written and all that, shows that the person has the spirit to stand up for herself. That's worth a round of applause. I get the points she is making about Sony people constantly gettign participants to flash fake smiles and holing them up like prisoners who can't do what they want to.

BUT I get the feeling that somewhere in her head this Archana person is regretting her decision to leave the second round. I mean, why else would she write this article? It's just full of justifications, looks like she feels she has to prove a point to someone. If she honestly didn't care and was taking it so lightly, would she have waited those 13 hours in the first place? I don't think so. And if she honestly didn't care, she wouldn't have written this article, cos inna way, its going to get her attention, right?

That's my gut feeling!

thnx a lot delphic_oracle for explainin it to me.......

its monday so i m a bit switched off!!! 😆

Thnx anywayz!!!

delphic_oracle thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
Hmm, i dunno buddy, i personally wudn't wait 13 hours to have fun! nor wud i take so much time off from work if it wasn't sumthing i really wnated to do.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".