Chapter 27: Please. Iss Baar Nahi
The question landed without warning.
Gautam had almost — almost — let something loosen. The spoon in his hand, the food his mother had made, his father sitting across from him without agenda or defence. Something had been quietly shifting in the room and then Gautam felt it shifting and something in him refused it. The resentments came back in a rush, familiar and reliable, and without looking up he said sharply:
“Aap kyun karte hain mom ke saath aisa. Baar baar.”
Mihir said nothing.
Not immediately. Not because he had an answer ready and was choosing how to deliver it. But because the question hit somewhere that had no clean surface to push back from. He set his own spoon down. Looked at the table. At the grain of it. At the dhokla box to the side.
“Baar baar,” he repeated. Almost to himself. As though he needed to hear it again to understand what was being asked.
Gautam still hadn’t looked up.
Mihir opened his mouth once. Closed it. Whatever had assembled itself into words dissolved before it could be spoken. He looked at his son — at the rigid set of his shoulders, the careful angle of his face away — and tried again.
“Main—” He stopped. Exhaled slowly through his nose. “Tujhe iska jawab dena chahta hoon. Theek se. Bas — ek second.”
The kitchen tap dripped once in the silence.
Somewhere below an auto rickshaw leaned on its horn and moved on.
When Mihir finally spoke, the words came out slowly. Carefully. Not rehearsed — the opposite of rehearsed.
“Shayad tujhe bhi… kahin na kahin pata hai.” A pause. “Ki maine kabhi — kabhi bhi — kisi aur aurat se pyaar nahi kiya. Sirf teri maa se.”
Gautam’s jaw tightened. The spoon turned once in his fingers. Then he set it down.
“Toh phir—”
“Main jaanta hoon.” Mihir’s voice was quiet. “yehi toh problem hai na. Yeh love story nahi hai jo main suna raha hoon tujhe apni safai mein. Yeh… yeh meri apni hi samajh mein nahi aata mujhe. Ki aadmi ek hi aurat se pyaar kare poori zindagi. Aur phir bhi.” He stopped again. Something moved across his face — not grief exactly, not shame exactly, something that didn’t have a clean name. “Aur phir bhi.”
He didn’t finish the sentence. He didn’t need to.
The room held it.
Then, quieter still:
“Tera ye jo gussa hai na mujhse.” Mihir looked at his son directly for the first time since the question. “Woh abhi bhi — main jaanta hoon bahut zyaada hai — lekin phir bhi woh mere apne gusse se bahut kam hai. Jo mujhe khud pe aata hai.”
Gautam said nothing. But something in the rigid line of his shoulders changed — almost imperceptibly, almost against his will.
Mihir looked at the table. At nothing in particular. He reached for the glass of water in front of him and drank — slowly, steadily — and set it back down. When he lifted his face again his eyes were dry but something around them had given way slightly, the way old plaster gives way — not dramatically, just a quiet surrender of surface.
“Pehle khana khatam karte hain,” he said. Simply. “Teri maa yahan hoti toh yehi kehti. Phir jo bolna hai, jitna bolna hai — bol lena.”
Gautam’s eyes moved briefly across the flat — the door, the kitchen, the empty space of the room — and then came back to his bowl. He said nothing.
But something crossed his face — there and gone. He picked up his spoon.
They ate.
The dal chawal had gone slightly cool. Neither mentioned it. The afternoon light moved slowly across the table. The city outside carried on — an auto, a pressure cooker somewhere above, children in the corridor returning from school. Inside, two men ate in a silence that was not comfortable but had stopped being combat.
The dhokla box sat between them untouched.
Mihir’s phone lit up on the table.
*Gautam aaya wapas? Jab kar sako mujhe call karo.*
He glanced at it. Looked up. Gautam was watching him.
“Teri maa ka message hai.” He tilted the screen toward his son.
Gautam read it. Looked away. A muscle worked in his jaw.
“Woh kahaan gayi hain?”
“Damini ke paas.”
The spoon stopped.
“Kyun.” Flat. Hard. Not a question. “Kisne kaha unhe? Yeh unka—” He stopped himself. Set the spoon down with a small controlled click. “Yeh unka kaam nahi hai.”
Mihir said nothing. He waited.
The silence stretched. Gautam stared at the table. At the bowl in front of him. Something moved through his face — the anger first, sharp and immediate, and then underneath it something quieter that he didn’t give words to and didn’t look up to show.
He picked his spoon back up.
They finished the meal in silence.
-----
The lift opened on the fourth floor just as the door to flat 4B swung open from the inside.
Damini had her keys in her hand, her bag on her shoulder, and was pulling the door shut behind her when she looked up.
She stared.
“Aap?”
She was dressed carefully — a structured blazer the colour of slate, straight trousers, small earrings. Her hair pinned back. The kind of put-together that takes effort and intention and a certain amount of convincing yourself in the mirror. She looked, Tulsi thought, like someone who had decided to be ready even if she didn’t feel it.
Tulsi smiled. The same smile she had given Arora in the airport lounge — warm, unhurried, entirely unbothered by the coldness receiving it.
She stepped forward and put her arms around her daughter-in-law.
Damini stood with her keys still in her hand and did not move. Her bag strap slid slightly off her shoulder. She did not return the embrace. She did not step back from it either — just stood there, rigid and uncertain, waiting for it to end.
Tulsi stepped back without comment. As though the response had been perfectly ordinary.
“Kaisi ho Damini.” Not a question exactly. An acknowledgment. “Kahin bahar jaa rahi ho?”
“Interview hai,” Damini said. The word came out flat. “Job interview.”
“Achha.” Tulsi nodded, as though this was pleasant news. “Ek minute ruko.”
She walked past Damini into the flat.
She found the kitchen without asking.
It was a small flat — the kitchen visible from the entrance if you knew to look — but Tulsi moved through it with the particular confidence of a woman who has navigated a thousand unfamiliar kitchens and knows that a kitchen is a kitchen. Damini followed, incredulously, keys still in hand, bag still on shoulder, not quite able to process what was happening in her own home.
The refrigerator first. Tulsi opened it with the same matter-of-fact ease with which she had walked past Damini at the door. She found the dahi on the second shelf — a fresh container, nearly full. She set it on the counter. Then the cabinets, one, two — sugar on the third. A small bowl from the dish rack, already clean and dry.
Damini stood in the kitchen doorway.
“Yeh aap kya kar rahi hain?”
Tulsi didn’t answer immediately. She was spooning dahi into the bowl — not too much, just enough. A small measure of sugar. She mixed it slowly, the spoon turning in small unhurried circles, and then turned around.
She held the spoon out toward Damini.
Damini stared at it. At her. At the small bowl of dahi chini being offered in her own kitchen by her mother-in-law who had arrived unannounced on an early afternoon on a Saturday and walked past her into her flat without being invited.
She opened her mouth — and closed it.
She ate from the spoon.
“Tumhe job mil jaayegi, Damini,” Tulsi said. Simply. As though this were an established fact.
Damini swallowed. Looked at the bowl. At the spoon still in Tulsi’s hand.
Something moved across her face — a tightening first, the kind that happens when a person has been holding themselves together very carefully and something small and unexpected finds the exact wrong place to press.
“Nahi milegi,” she said.
It came out quietly. Not bitter — just true. The flatness of someone stating a fact they have already made peace with even if the peace is not comfortable.
“Sirf BBA hai mera.” She set her bag down on the kitchen counter. The keys were still in her hand — she seemed to have forgotten them. “Koi experience nahi. Aur main—” She stopped. Started again. “Entry level positions ke liye main bahut badi hoon. Seniority wali positions ke liye main totally unexperienced aur unqualified hoon. Kahin fit nahi hoti.”
She said it without self pity. That was the most painful thing about it — the absence of self pity. Just a clear-eyed assessment of a situation she had turned over many times already in the privacy of this flat and arrived at the same conclusion every time.
“Main iss job ke liye fit hi nahi hoon,” she said. “Kisi bhi job ke liye.”
The keys turned once in her fingers.
Tulsi looked at her daughter-in-law — at the careful blazer, the pinned hair, the effort of the morning visible in every detail — and said nothing for a moment.
Then: “Kaam kyun karna hai tumhe?”
Damini blinked.
The question seemed to catch her entirely off guard — as though she had spent considerable energy preparing for every possible response except this one. Sympathy she had braced for. Reassurance she had braced for. A practical suggestion about retraining or certificates or LinkedIn profiles she had braced for.
Not this.
“Matlab—” She stopped. “Matlab kaam toh — sab karte hain—”
“Tumse pooch rahi hoon,” Tulsi said. Gently. “Tum kyun karna chahti ho?”
Damini opened her mouth. Closed it. The keys turned in her fingers again — a small restless rotation that she seemed unaware of.
The silence stretched.
Something shifted in her face — not the careful flatness of before but something rawer underneath it. The anger came first, the way it always does when a question finds the place where there is no ready answer. She looked away from Tulsi, at the counter, at the dahi container still sitting open.
“Pata nahi,” she said finally. The words came out with more force than she intended. “Pata hi nahi. Yehi toh problem hai.”
She set the keys down on the counter. A small definitive click.
“Kya karoon?” The anger was fading now into something flatter, more honest. “Din bhar. Akele. Nakul bhi chala gaya.” A pause. “Uske jaane ke baad toh—”
She didn’t finish.
She didn’t need to.
Tulsi said nothing for a moment.
She looked at her daughter-in-law — at the keys on the counter, at the careful blazer that had taken effort to put on this morning, at the face of a woman who had just admitted out loud that she did not know what to do with herself and was angrier at that not-knowing than at anything else.
She took the dahi container and closed it. Set it back on the counter neatly. The small bowl still between them.
“Aayi kyun hain aap aaj yahan?” Damini said. Not hostile now. Just — asking. Genuinely. “Gomzi ne bheja hai?”
“Nahi,” Tulsi said.
“Toh?”
“Toh kuch nahi.” Tulsi’s voice was simple. “Aana tha. Aa gayi.”
Damini looked at her for a long moment. Something in her face was trying to decide what to do with that answer — whether to accept it, whether to push back, whether to believe that a woman could simply arrive at your door in Bangalore on a Saturday because she wanted to.
She didn’t push back.
The kitchen had gone very quiet. Outside, the city continued — a bird somewhere on the building ledge, the distant sound of a building lift arriving and departing, a child being called in from a balcony two floors above.
“Din bhar akele,” Tulsi said finally. As though she had been turning it over since Damini said it. “Nakul bhi nahi. Gautam bhi nahi.”
Damini’s jaw tightened slightly. She nodded. Once.
“Hamare paas aao,” Tulsi said.
Damini looked up.
“Shantiniketan mein.” Tulsi said it the way she said most things — simply, without performance, as though she were suggesting something entirely reasonable. “Aa jao. Milke sochenge — kya interest hai tumhara, kahan aptitude hai, kya karna chahti ho actually. Ek saath.”
The silence that followed was of a different quality than the ones before it.
Damini set her hand flat on the counter. Steadied herself slightly.
“Shantiniketan?” The word came out carefully. “Maa — aapko pata hai na. Gomzi aur main — hum toh—” She stopped. Started again. “Maine aapko phone pe bataya tha.”
“Haan,” Tulsi said. “Bataya tha.”
“Toh phir—”
“Toh phir yeh bhi toh pata hai tumhe.” Tulsi’s voice was quiet but entirely steady. “Jab bhi Shantiniketan mein kisi bahu ne pehli baar kadam rakha — uss din se Shantiniketan se uska rishta jud gaya. Woh rishta kabhi uske pati pe nirbhar nahi raha. Kabhi nahi.”
Damini stared at her.
“Pehle bhi nahi,” Tulsi said. “Aur ab bhi nahi.”
The keys sat on the counter between them. The dahi container. The small empty bowl with its residue of white and sweet.
Damini said nothing for a long moment.
Then something in her face — the careful composure of ten months of managed solitude, of western formals and job applications and not going to Australia and not answering Gautam’s calls — something in all of that gave way.
Not loudly. Just — gave way.
“Maa—” Her voice came out smaller than she intended. “Main — main kitni akeli ho gayi thi.”
Tulsi moved first.
She didn’t say anything. She simply stepped forward and put her arms around Damini properly this time — not the careful greeting at the door that Damini had stood rigid through, but the kind of embrace that doesn’t ask permission and doesn’t wait to see if it is welcome. The kind that simply arrives and stays.
Damini’s hand came up — not to push away but to grip. The blazer fabric at Tulsi’s shoulder. The keys were somewhere on the counter behind her and her bag had slid to the floor and none of it mattered.
She cried the way people cry when they have been not crying for a very long time. Not elegantly. Not with any of the composure that the blazer and the pinned hair and the carefully applied makeup had suggested. Just — completely. The way a dam doesn’t leak but breaks.
Tulsi held her and said nothing.
There was nothing to say. There was only this — a kitchen in a Bangalore flat on a Saturday afternoon, a daughter-in-law breaking open in her mother-in-law’s arms, the dahi container on the counter and the bird still moving on the ledge outside and the city entirely indifferent below.
After a while — Tulsi couldn’t have said how long — the crying gentled. Became quieter. Damini’s grip on her shoulder loosened slightly though she didn’t step back.
Tulsi stepped back slightly — not away, just enough to look at her. Then she did what she had been doing all afternoon without announcement or explanation. She simply moved. One hand at Damini’s elbow, gentle and unhurried, steering her out of the kitchen and into the sitting room.
She brought her to the sofa and sat her down. Sat beside her. Close enough that their shoulders nearly touched.
Damini let herself be moved. She had stopped having opinions about what was happening. The blazer she had put on so carefully this morning was creased at the shoulder where she had gripped Tulsi’s arm and she didn’t notice and it didn’t matter.
Damini looked at her.
“Mere maa-papa ne—” She stopped. Cleared her throat. Tried again. “Inn — inn das mahino mein. Kitni baar kaha. Australia aa jao. Bas aa jao.”
Tulsi was still. Listening.
“Main gayi nahi.” Damini’s voice was flat again now, the way it gets after crying — scraped clean. “Pata nahi kyun. Bas — nahi gayi.”
She knew why. They both knew why. Neither said it.
“Das mahine,” Tulsi said quietly.
Not a question. But it was.
Damini pulled back slightly and looked at her. Something moved across her face — the realisation arriving slowly.
“Aapko pata nahi tha?”
Tulsi said nothing. Which was its own answer.
“Humne — humne das mahine pehle—” Damini stopped. The composure that had briefly reassembled itself after the crying gave way again at the edges. “Main samajh rahi thi aapko pata hai. Jab maine phone pe bataya tha — maine socha tha aap samajh gayi hongi ki—”
“Tum alag ho gayi ho das mahine se,” Tulsi said. Quietly. As though she needed to hear herself say it.
Damini nodded.
Something moved through Tulsi — quick, deep, the kind of thing that happens below the surface where faces don’t show it. Ten months. Nakul gone out of country, she presumed. Damini alone in this flat with this careful blazer and its job applications for jobs she didn’t want. Gautam alone — wherever Gautam had been in these ten months. And she had not known. She had known something was wrong, she had felt it at the edges of every rejected phone call, but she had not known it had been ten months of this.
She held it. All of it. Held it the way she had been holding things all day — the airport lounge, the flight, the morning with Gautam — kept her face steady and her arms where they were.
“Tumhare maa-papa,” she said after a moment. “Woh theek hain?”
“Haan.” Damini almost smiled — a tired, watery thing. “Woh toh — woh bahut theek hain. Sydney mein bahut khush hain. Bas mujhe lekar—” The almost-smile faded. “Bas mujhe lekar kaafi pareshaan rehte hain.”
“Haan,” Tulsi said. “Maa-baap ka kaam hai.”
Damini looked at her. Something in that simple statement — the plainness of it, the absence of judgment in it — made her eyes fill again.
“Maa—“ said Damini, clearly at a loss for words.
Tulsi let the silence sit.
She didn’t fill it. Didn’t offer comfort in words or rush to the next question. Just — sat with Damini in the incomplete sentence, in the *maa* that had come out without planning and then found nowhere to go.
“Yahan kaafi time se ho?” Tulsi said simply after a while.
Damini blinked. The shift — away from the large things, toward the small — loosened something slightly.
“Aath-nau mahine,” she said. “Pehle ek bada ghar tha — jab hum teen the. Gomzi, Nakul, main.” She looked around the flat briefly. “Woh ghar — akele mein bahut bada ho jaata hai. Bahut — “ She didn’t finish. “Toh yahan aa gayi.”
Tulsi nodded. She understood exactly what *bahut bada ho jaata hai* meant for a woman alone and didn’t ask her to say more than that.
“Koi hai yahan? Saheliyan, log — koi jaana pehchana?”
“The.” Damini looked at her hands. “Gomzi ke colleagues ki wives mostly. Woh — woh log achhe the. Lekin jab sab hua toh—” A pause. “Woh friendships ek taraf ho gayin apne aap.”
Tulsi nodded. She understood exactly what that meant and didn’t ask Damini to elaborate.
The small questions had done their work. The air in the room had changed — less braced, less defended. And into that slightly loosened space, without being asked directly, Damini began to talk.
She started where people always start — not at the beginning but at the place that was most immediately painful. Gautam’s moods. The heaviness that descended without warning and lifted on its own schedule. The evenings where the air in the flat had a particular quality she had learned to read over years. Not anger exactly. Not cruelty. Just — absence. A man present in body and emotionally just not there.
“Woh jaanbujhkar nahi karta,” Damini said. She was looking at her hands. “Yeh main jaanti hoon. Lekin—”
She stopped.
Tulsi waited.
“Lekin jaanbujhkar nahi karta — yeh jaanne se kuch nahi badlta.” The flatness of a fact turned over so many times it had lost its edges. “Roz nahi hota. Weeks achhe jaate the. Aur phir kuch ho jaata tha — koi chhoti si cheez bhi — aur phir woh emotionally just — gone. Apne andar kuch aisa hota tha ki woh bas mere saath nahi hota.”
Tulsi said nothing. She was listening in the particular way she listened — not waiting for her turn, not gathering evidence, just present. And underneath her stillness something was turning slowly. She had known this. Not this exactly — not Damini’s version of it, not what it looked like from inside that Bangalore flat — but the shape of it. She had known the shape of it for twenty-five years.
She had been the one, after all, who had first seen Gautam as a young collegian in Shobha’s college.
Not as Damini was seeing him now — as a husband who couldn’t stay present, who carried something heavy and unnamed — but as a young man who had arrived in India like something flung from a great height. Damaged in ways he didn’t have words for. Kiran papa’s silences and Aarti mom’s sharpness had done their work on him long before he ever reached her door. He had taken it out on Shobha first — his own sister, bullying her in college — and Tulsi when she came to know his real identity, understood it even while it broke her heart. Then she had spent months, careful months, bringing him back into something that felt like family. Had almost managed it.
And then Karan had come.
She didn’t let herself go there now. This was not the moment for her own reckoning. She brought herself back to the sofa, to Damini’s hands in her lap, to the afternoon light on the floor.
“Pehle main samjhaane ki koshish karti thi,” Damini was saying. “Poochti thi — kya hua, baat karo na. Woh kehta — kuch nahi. I’m fine.” A pause. “Saalon mein maine figure out kiya. I’m fine ka matlab hota hai — abhi door raho.”
“Haan,” Tulsi said quietly. Not surprise. Recognition.
Damini looked at her. Something in that single syllable — the weight it carried, the decades behind it — made her pause.
“Aapko pata tha,” Damini said. Not accusatory. Just — realising.
“Haan,” Tulsi said. “Pata tha.”
A silence.
“Toh phir aap log itne saalon mein—” She didn’t finish. But Tulsi heard the whole sentence. *You knew. You’ve known for twenty-five years. And still.*
“Kuch cheezein,” Tulsi said slowly, “bahut gehri hoti hain. Itni gehri ki time bhi nahi pahunch paata. Sirf bahut dheere dheere. Bahut saare saalon mein.” She paused. “Aur kabhi kabhi — nahi bhi pahunchta.”
The room held that.
Damini looked at her hands again.
“Jab hum Australia mein the,” she said after a moment. Her voice had changed — quieter, going somewhere further back. “Woh better tha zyaada. Naya tha sab. Nakul tha, teenager ho gaya tha, apni life mein busy tha. Gomzi ka kaam achha tha. Aur—” A pause. “Aur door the. Yahan se. Sab se.”
Tulsi understood what *sab se* meant.
“Kareeb saade chhe saal pehle hum wapas India aane wale the,” Damini said. “Plan ho gaya tha — seedha Shantiniketan. Nakul ki padhai, Gomzi ka ek offer bhi tha ek Mumbai-based law firm mein — sab settle ho raha tha.” Her voice had gone very even. The evenness of something accepted at great cost. “Aur phir khabar aayi.”
She didn’t say what khabar.
Tulsi sat very still.
“Gomzi nahi kar sakta tha,” Damini said. “Wahan jaana. Itne sab ke baad — emotionally woh nahi kar sakta tha Shantiniketan ke paas rehna.” She looked up briefly. “Main samajh gayi thi. Toh Bangalore.”
Toh Bangalore.
Two words. Almost seven years.
Something moved through Tulsi — deep, swift, the kind that doesn’t reach the face. A city nobody had chosen becoming their life because the city they had planned for had been taken away. And the taking away — she knew exactly who had done that. She and Mihir. Their collapse rippling outward in ways she was only now beginning to fully see.
She held it. Kept her hands still. Kept her face where it was.
Damini was still talking.
“Bangalore aake pehle theek tha,” she continued. “Busy the, Nakul bhi tha. Aur phir Nakul apni studies mein laga, phir college, phir woh chala gaya further studies ke liye.” She turned the edge of the cushion in her fingers. “Aur jo — jo andar tha Gomzi ke. Woh surface pe aane laga. Zyaada. I couldn’t even pinpoint exactly when it shifted. Bas hota raha.”
“Aur tum handle karti rahi,” Tulsi said. “Akele.”
Damini looked at her. Being seen that precisely did something to her face.
“Haan,” she said. Very quietly.
A long silence.
“Maine ek baar suggest kiya tha — therapy. Kisi professional se baat karo.” Damini’s voice was carefully flat. “Usne suna. Said nothing. Gaya nahi.” A pause. “Maine dobaara nahi kaha.”
Tulsi nodded. She understood that particular calculation — the energy required to make a suggestion into silence, and the quiet decision about whether one had enough left to try again.
“Aur Karan? Use lekar resentment?” Tulsi said. Gently. Carefully.
Damini was quiet for a moment.
“Gomzi ne kabhi directly kuch nahi kaha,” she said slowly. “Lekin woh period — jab sab hua — it did something to him. Jo abhi bhi hai.” She paused. “Woh feel karta hai — main nahi keh rahi woh right hai, main sirf keh rahi hoon woh feel karta hai — ki jab bhi kuch bada hua, jab bhi koi real emotional demand aayi — that fear of being abandoned, of being pushed aside — woh wapas aa jaata hai. Every single time.”
She stopped.
Started again.
“Bachcha lagta hai kabhi kabhi,” she said quietly. “Woh chhota sa bachcha jo samajh nahi paaya ki usse kyun choda gaya. Pahle aap dono ne. Phir Kiran papa ne. Aarti mom ne. Emotionally. Aur phir — phir dobaara. Alag tarah se. Baar baar.”
The room was very quiet.
Tulsi sat with all of it — Damini’s words, and underneath them everything she herself knew and had not said. The boy who had arrived at Shantiniketan like something broken. The years she had spent carefully, patiently, bringing him back toward something whole. And then Karan — and Gautam watching her open her arms to Mihir’s illegitimate son, watching her find room for yet another claim on her heart — and feeling, somewhere in the wordless part of him, that he had been set aside again. That when it came to it, he was always the one who got set aside.
She had not known he had felt it so precisely.
Or perhaps she had known. And had told herself there was nothing to be done. That she was doing everything she could. That it would settle.
It had not settled. It had gone to Australia instead. And then to Bangalore. And now it was here — in this small flat, in Damini’s carefully chosen words, in ten months of separation and a job interview for a job she didn’t want.
She kept her face still. This was Damini’s hour. Her own reckoning would find her later.
“Tum thak gayi thi,” she said finally. Simply.
It wasn’t a question.
Damini’s face crumpled slightly and then steadied.
“Haan bahut,” she said. “Itna thak gayi thi, maa. Main — I just couldn’t take it anymore.”
Damini was quiet for a moment after that. The telling had taken something out of her — not in a bad way, the way a wound takes something out of you when it finally drains. She looked lighter and hollowed out at the same time.
“Nakul ke jaane tak theek tha,” she said finally. “Not great. But — manageable. Hum dono ke beech ek common ground tha. Woh.”
Tulsi said nothing. Listening.
“Nakul ke liye toh — woh bahut achha father hai,” Damini said. Present tense. *Hai.* “When he was born toh Gomzi pehli baar — pehli baar properly khush tha. Like genuinely. Nakul ke saath woh — woh wala Gomzi tha jo shaadi ke pehle do teen salon me tha. Woh wala.”
Something moved across her face — not quite grief, not quite tenderness. The complicated expression of a woman remembering what she had loved and why.
“Toh jab tak Nakul tha — ghar mein ek cheez thi jo hum dono ke liye same thi. Uski padhai, uska future, uske saath time. Woh ek direction tha jo shared tha.” She paused. “Aur phir usne bola ki woh further studies karna chahta hai. Bahar jaake.”
“Kab gaya?” Tulsi asked quietly.
“Ek saal pehle. Almost exactly.” Damini looked at the window. “Gomzi chahta tha jaane do — let him spread his wings. Main chahti thi woh yahan rahe, India mein hi kahin. But—” A small shrug. “But Nakul jaana chahta tha. Toh gaya.”
A pause.
“Uske jaane ke baad ghar itna — itna bada ho gaya,” she said quietly. “Itna quiet. Pehle bhi quiet rehta tha lekin — Nakul tha toh ek aahat rehti thi. Music, phone calls, uske doston ka aana jaana. Kuch na kuch. Aur phir woh bhi nahi.”
She turned the cushion edge in her fingers again.
“Woh pehla mahina bahut bura tha,” she said. “Hum dono ke liye. Pehli baar itne saalon mein sirf hum dono the. Koi buffer nahi. Koi common agenda nahi.” She stopped. “Gomzi zyaada andar chala gaya. Woh emotionally — woh bahut door ho gaya. Main poochti thi, woh kehta I’m fine. Woh kaam par jaata, wapas aata, khaana khaata aur so jaata. Aur main — main wahan hoti thi lekin hum dono ek hi ghar mein akele the.”
Tulsi sat with this.
“Ek mahine baad,” Damini said. Her voice had gone very flat. Very even. “Maine kaha — yeh nahi chal sakta. Aise nahi chal sakta. Kuch karo — therapy, baat karo, kuch bhi. Ya phir—”
She didn’t finish the sentence. She didn’t need to.
“Usne kuch nahi kiya,” Tulsi said. Not a question.
“Usne kuch nahi kiya,” Damini confirmed. “Main — maine ultimatum diya tha. Therapy, ya phir — woh ghar chhod ke chala gaya.” A pause. “Usi raat.”
She said it without drama. Just fact.
“Main us bade ghar mein akeli reh gayi,” she continued. “Bahut bada tha woh ghar. Teen logon ke liye tha. Ek ke liye — bahut bada. Bahut quiet. Har cheez ek reminder thi. Toh ek do mahine baad main yahan aa gayi.” She looked around the small flat briefly. “Yahan manage ho jaata hai.”
The room was very quiet for a few minutes. Then Tulsi looked up.
“Das mahine,” she said. Almost to herself.
“Das mahine,” Damini said.
They sat with that number between them. Ten months of separation from Gautam. Ten months of the big house being too big and too quiet and too full of the shape of a life that had emptied itself out. Ten months of her parents calling from Sydney. Ten months of not going.
“Nakul ko pata hai?” Tulsi asked.
“Haan.” Damini’s voice was tired. “Woh — woh bahut upset tha. Dono pe. Mujhpe bhi, Gomzi pe bhi.” A pause. “Woh regularly call karta hai. Dono ko. Alag alag.”
Tulsi nodded.
A long silence settled between them — not uncomfortable, just full. The kind of silence that comes after everything important has been said and the room needs a moment to absorb it.
The silence then settled into something almost restful between them. The afternoon had moved on — the light in the room different now from when Damini had opened the door in her interview blazer what felt like a very long time ago.
Damini was leaning slightly into the sofa back. The careful posture of the morning — the blazer, the pinned hair, the keys ready in hand — had given way to something looser. Not defeated. Just — emptied of its performance.
Tulsi looked at her.
Then she said, simply: “Jao.”
Damini blinked.
“Interview ke liye,” Tulsi said. “Jao.”
“Maa—” Damini looked at her. “Abhi? Main — abhi mood nahi hai, aur waise bhi yeh job—”
“Mood interview nahi dega,” Tulsi said. “Tum dogi.” A pause. “Jao. Muh dho lo. Makeup theek karo. Jao.”
Damini stared at her for a moment. Something moved through her face — the beginning of an argument, and then the slow recognition that the argument would not find purchase here. Tulsi was not asking. She was not requesting. She was simply — pointing toward the door with the quiet authority of a woman who had been pointing people in the right direction her entire life and had never once needed to raise her voice to do it.
Damini stood up.
She was quiet for a moment, standing there in her interview blazer — slightly creased now at the shoulder — and her pinned hair and her small earrings. Looking, Tulsi thought, less like someone who had decided to be ready and more like someone who actually was.
“Yeh job nahi milegi mujhe,” Damini said. One last time. But the certainty in it had shifted slightly — less flat, more complicated.
“Hopefully milegi,” Tulsi said. “Jao.”
Something moved across Damini’s face. Not quite a smile. Something quieter than a smile — a small involuntary softening, the kind that happens when a person has been held properly for the first time in a long time and doesn’t quite know what to do with the aftermath of it.
She went to the bathroom.
Tulsi sat in the suddenly quiet sitting room and listened to the sound of water running, of a drawer opening and closing, the small ordinary sounds of a woman putting herself back together. She looked at her own hands in her lap.
After a few minutes Damini came back out. The makeup was redone — carefully, competently. The hair still pinned. The blazer smoothed.
She picked up her bag from where it had slid to the floor. Found her keys on the kitchen counter.
At the door she paused. Turned.
She looked at Tulsi for a moment — at this woman sitting on her sofa in a simple silk saree who had arrived unannounced and found her kitchen and fed her dahi chini with a spoon and held her while she broke and asked her exactly the right questions and was now sending her out the door to an interview she didn’t want.
She opened her mouth. Closed it.
“Main — “ she started. Stopped.
“Haan,” Tulsi said. As though the sentence had been completed.
“Main yahin miloongi jab tum wapas aaogi” she assured her.
Damini nodded once. Turned back to the door. Opened it.
And then she was gone.
The door clicked shut.
Tulsi sat for a moment in the silence Damini had left behind. Then she reached for her phone. Typed and sent a message:
*Gautam aaya wapas? Jab kar sako mujhe call karo.*
She put the phone face down on the cushion beside her. Looked at the room — the sofa, the window, the crow long gone from the ledge. The flat that Damini had made manageable. Small and chosen and hers.
The phone lit up.
*Haan aa gaya. Khaana khaa raha hai. Thodi der mein call karta hoon.*
She read it twice. Something in her chest loosened — quietly, without announcement. He came back. He was eating. Mihir was there.
She set the phone down again.
After a while she got up. Not restlessly — just the natural movement of a woman who does not sit still for long when there are things to be seen and understood. She moved toward the kitchen.
The cooker was on the counter. She lifted the lid — and stopped.
Khichdi. A full portion. Still faintly warm.
She stood there looking at it. Damini had made khichdi for her lunch today. Of all the things — khichdi. Tulsi turned this over quietly. Either her stomach had been off. Or she hadn’t been eating properly and khichdi was the thing that required the least effort and went down the easiest.
Either way the conclusion was the same.
She put the lid back gently. Moved through the small flat toward the restroom — and then stopped.
The photographs were on the wall of the narrow corridor. She hadn’t noticed them on her way in.
She stopped now.
There were several. Single frames, group frames, the accumulating visual record of a life lived in three. Nakul at various ages — a gap-toothed boy, then a lanky teenager, then someone who had become almost recognisably a man. Damini in a few alone — one laughing at something off camera, unselfconscious and bright. Gautam in one she almost couldn’t look at directly — sitting on some beach somewhere, arms loose at his sides, face open in a way she almost didn’t recognise. Her son. Unguarded.
And then the two of them together. Gautam and Damini. More than one.
A restaurant somewhere, their heads bent toward each other over a table. A doorway — some occasion, both dressed up, Damini’s hand through his arm. Another one she couldn’t quite place the location of, just the two of them outdoors, Gautam’s arm around her shoulder and Damini looking not at the camera but at him with an expression that said everything about how she had felt about him once, or perhaps still felt, or perhaps both simultaneously.
They started undoing her. Quietly. Without permission.
She moved past them toward the bedroom. The restroom was through it — she had seen the layout earlier. But she stopped at the threshold.
On the bedside table. A single framed photograph.
The three of them. A holiday somewhere — the light behind them warm and golden, the particular warmth of a place that had been chosen for happiness. Nakul as a young teenager, grinning at the camera with the uninhibited ease of a boy who doesn’t yet know that happiness is not a permanent condition. Gautam laughing at something just outside the frame — laughing fully, without self-consciousness, the way he almost never did. And Damini’s hand on Nakul’s shoulder, her face turned slightly toward Gautam rather than the camera.
A family. Her family. Happy.
Tulsi picked it up.
She didn’t mean to. Her hands simply — moved. And then the frame was in her hands and she was looking at it and something in the room had shifted and she found the single chair in the corner without quite knowing how she reached it, without quite deciding to sit, and then she was sitting and the photograph was in her lap and her fingers were on the glass.
Gautam’s face. Damini’s face. Nakul’s face.
Her thumb moved — lightly, without pressure — across each one.
And then it came. Not gradually. All at once, the way things come when they have been held back for the length of an entire day that had started at four-thirty in the morning in a Mumbai kitchen.
She sat in the chair with the photograph in her lap and the afternoon light on the floor and she cried.
Not the way Damini had cried — not that breaking open of something long dammed. Just quietly. Steadily. The way someone cries who has had a lot of practice at crying alone and has learned to do it without making a production of it. Tears that simply — came. Without asking permission. Without announcing themselves.
She didn’t stop them.
For once, in this bedroom in this city that nobody had chosen, with nobody watching and nothing that needed doing for the next few minutes — she simply let them come.
If only she had not left when she did.
But what else could she have done? When her husband himself had admitted — had stood in front of her and admitted — that he had slept with another woman. What self-respecting woman could have stayed after that? What was she supposed to have done — straightened her saree and carried on? Pretended it wasn’t what it was?
She had done the only thing available to her. She had left.
And this was what had happened.
She looked at the photograph again. At Nakul’s gap-toothed grin. At Gautam laughing. At Damini’s face turned toward her husband with that expression.
This. This was what she would have seen in her own home. Her son happy in his marriage. Her grandson growing up with his parents together and a large loving joint family. Her son’s family of three that had been trying, imperfectly, to be whole.
If only Mihir had kept some limits. If only he had — if he had just — even if everything else, even if the years of distance and the gradual erosion — if he had at least safeguarded their marriage. Drawn some line. Kept some boundary between friendship and whatever it had become with Noina. If only he had protected what they had built together — four decades of it — if only he had thought, once, about what its collapse would cost. Not just her. All of them. This room. This photograph. This family that had never quite managed to come home.
She was so tired.
She was so tired of cleaning up after earthquakes she had not caused.
Her phone rang.
She looked at it. Mihir.
She sat for a moment with it ringing in her hand. Then she pressed accept. Put it to her ear. Said nothing.
“Tulsi.” His voice. Warm, careful. The voice she had known for over forty years. “Sab theek hai?”
“Haan,” she said. The word came out steadier than she expected.
“Damini se mili?”
“Haan.” A pause. “Woh — woh interview ke liye gayi hai. Job interview. Main yahan hoon, wapas aane ka intezaar kar rahi hoon.”
“Achha.” She could hear him absorbing this. “Gautam ke baare mein — woh bahut—” He stopped. Started again. “Uske andar bahut kuch hai. Gussa. Dard. Bahut saari pent up feelings hain. Especially mere liye.” A pause. “Aur galat bhi nahi hai woh.”
She listened.
He told her — quietly, carefully — what had happened at the table. The gist of it. She listened without interrupting, the photograph still in her lap, her thumb still against the glass.
“Tum theek ho?” he said when he had finished.
She didn’t answer.
A beat of silence.
“Tum — tum ro rahi thi kya?” His voice had changed. Quieter. More careful. “Tulsi?”
She said nothing.
“Please batao na. Kya hua?”
And something in the *please* — something in the gentleness of it, the genuine wanting-to-know of it — broke the last thing that she had been holding.
“Main thak gayi hoon, Mihir.”
A pause.
“Tumhari galtiyon ka bojh uthate uthate. Unn galtiyon ke consequences ko sambhaalte sambhaalte.”
A breath.
“Bahut thak gayi hoon.”
She cut the call.
The room was very quiet. The photograph still in her lap. She set it face down on her knee — she couldn’t look at it right now — and sat in the silence she had made.
Her phone lit up.
Mihir.
She didn’t pick up.
It rang out. Then again. She watched it light up and go dark, light up and go dark. Third time. Fourth.
Then a message.
*Main aa raha hoon.*
She stared at it. Something flashed through her — and she called him back.
He picked up before the first ring had finished.
“Tum wahan se hiloge bhi nahi.” Her voice came out low and hard. “Ek baar apni life mein, Mihir Virani — ek baar — get your priorities right. Mushkil se Gautam baat kar raha hai tumse. Mushkil se. Aur tum kya kar rahe ho? Bhaag rahe ho uski kadwi baaton se?”
“Tulsi, tum jaanti ho aisa nahi hai. Tum wahan akeli—”
A laugh came out of her. Short, humourless, the kind that has no warmth in it and isn’t meant to.
“Chhe saal, Mihir.” The words came out before she had decided to say them. Raw at the edges. “Chhe saal main bilkul akeli thi. Ek ek cheez. Ek ek din. Ek ek problem. Sab akele. Chhe saal aur toota hua dil. Sambhaal liya tha khud ko. Tab bhi kar liya.” A breath. “Ab bhi kar loongi.”
Silence on the line.
She wasn’t making a point. She hadn’t planned to say it. It had simply — come up. The way things come up when you have been holding them at a particular angle for a very long time and something shifts and the angle changes and suddenly there is no holding it anymore.
She sat in that silence. The photograph face down on her knee. The afternoon light moving on the floor of someone else’s bedroom.
She didn’t expect anything.
That was the truth of it — not strategy, not self-sufficiency, not pride. Just the simple exhausted resignation of a woman who had learned, over forty-four years, that when she said *main kar loongi* the response was always silence and then the sound of the problem being left entirely in her hands. She had stopped expecting anything else. Some part of her had stopped expecting it so completely that she didn’t even register the stopping anymore. It was simply — how things were. How they had always been.
She waited.
“Please.”
His voice came out differently than she expected. Something stripped from it that was usually there — the composure, the steadiness, the Mihir Virani-ness of it.
“Tulsi. Iss baar nahi.” A beat. She could hear him breathing. “Main kuch nahi maang raha. Kuch nahi. Bas — yeh ek haq de do. Please. Tum akele nahi deal karogi iss baar. Bas yeh. Bas itna. Please.”
The room was very quiet.
Something moved through her at the *please.* Not the first one — the second and third. The repetition of it. Mihir Virani did not repeat himself. Mihir Virani did not beg. And yet here he was — and it didn’t sound like performance, it didn’t sound like management, it sounded like a man who was genuinely afraid. Of her hanging up. Of her dealing with it alone again. Of being left on the other side of that particular door one more time.
She sat with it.
The photograph was still face down on her knee.
“Gautam ko akela mat chhodna,” she said finally. Her voice had come down from where it had been — still flat, still carrying the weight of everything, but no longer at that sharp edge. “Woh mushkil se—”
“Haan,” he said immediately. “Haan, main nahi jaa raha. Main yahin hoon.”
A silence.
She should have hung up. She had said what needed saying. He was staying. That was enough.
She didn’t hang up.
“Woh—” She stopped. Started again. Something was moving up through her that she hadn’t planned for. The anger had spent itself slightly and in the space it left something else was surfacing — something she had carried alone for years. Since the day she left Shantiniketan. Since before that. “Tumhe pata hai Mihir—”
She stopped again.
“Batao,” he said quietly. “Jo bhi hai. Batao.”
And because he said it like that — not *kya hua* with its managerial efficiency, not *theek ho* with its anxious reassurance, just *batao, jo bhi hai, batao* — something in her simply opened.
“Woh wapas aane wala tha.” Her voice came out very quiet. “Gautam. Woh — unka plan tha. Woh aur Damini. Shantiniketan. Hamesha ke liye. Sab ho gaya tha almost — Nakul ka school, Gautam ka ek offer tha Mumbai ki kisi law firm mein — sab.” She paused. “Aur tab main ghar chhodke chali gayi.”
Silence.
Complete silence.
“Mihir.”
“Haan.” His voice had changed entirely. Something had gone out of it.
“Woh ghar aa raha tha,” she said. “Apne ghar. Apni maa ke paas. Apni family ke paas. Aur jab woh pahuncha toh — toh ghar tha hi nahi. Main nahi thi. Tum the — lekin woh waala ghar nahi tha.” A breath. “Toh woh Bangalore chala gaya.”
The line was so quiet she could hear the city outside Damini’s window.
“Lekin woh aa raha tha, Mihir. Apne ghar. Aur ghar nahi tha.”
Silence.
“Yeh tumhe pata hona chahiye abhi,” she said finally. “Isliye nahi ki tum kuch kar sako. Kuch ho nahi sakta ab. Lekin — jab tum usse baat karo toh samjhne ki koshish karo. Uski takleef ko. Toh yeh bhi samajhna. Ki woh sirf tumhari galtiyon ka bojh nahi utha raha. Woh ek ghar bhi dhundh raha hai jo uss waqt se — uss ek waqt se — kabhi mila hi nahi usse.”
She stopped.
The photograph was still face down on her knee. She didn’t turn it over.
From the other end of the line — nothing. No words. Just Mihir, sitting with what she had just put in his hands, in a Bangalore flat where his son was somewhere nearby, not knowing that his father was on the phone being broken open by his mother’s voice.
She waited.
“Haan,” he said finally. Very quietly. Just that.
She nodded, though he couldn’t see it.
“Gautam ke paas jao,” she said. “Woh akela hoga.”
She cut the call.
-----
He had found a quiet corner while Gautam was in the restroom. The kitchen doorway — the same place he had stood watching his son eat dhokla without knowing he was being watched. He had leaned against the doorframe and called her.
He had not expected what came.
The humourless laugh first. And then her voice, low and raw at the edges. *Chhe saal aur toota hua dil.* He had no defence against those words. He had never had a defence. He had stood in the kitchen doorway and taken every word because every word was true.
He had called back four times. She hadn’t picked up. He had sent — *main aa raha hoon* — before he had quite decided to, because what else was there, what else could he do.
And then she had called back. And he had said *please* and meant it in a way he wasn’t sure he had meant anything in a long time. And she had stayed on the line.
And then — quietly, without preamble — she had told him.
*Woh ghar aa raha tha, Mihir. Apne ghar. Apni maa ke paas. Aur jab woh pahuncha toh — toh ghar tha hi nahi.*
He had said nothing. He couldn’t.
*Toh woh Bangalore chala gaya.*
He had known he had cost Tulsi. He had been living inside that knowledge for years — carrying it the way you carry something that has no resolution, that simply has to be borne. He had sat on balcony and accounted for himself. He had named his failures one by one and she had listened with that particular quality of listening that neither forgives nor condemns but simply — hears. And through all of it she had been Tulsi. Composed. Present. Containing whatever she felt in that room nobody else was allowed into.
She had never let him see it. Not once. Not through Mandira. Not through the showdown just before she left home due to his perceived affair with Noina. Not through six and a half years of silence. Not through any of the balcony confessions where he had sat in his worst moments and she had received them without breaking in front of him.
Until today.
*Chhe saal aur toota hua dil.*
She hadn’t planned to say it. He had heard that — heard the rawness of something that escaped before she could stop it. And he had stood in this kitchen doorway and taken it and known, with a certainty that had no comfort in it, that he was hearing something she had never shown anyone. Not her children. Not Baa. Not herself, perhaps, in the clear light of words.
She had let him see her break.
And then she had told him about Gautam.
*Woh ghar aa raha tha, Mihir. Apne ghar. Apni maa ke paas. Aur jab woh pahuncha toh — toh ghar tha hi nahi.*
He had cost Tulsi. He had known that. But this — a plan almost finalised, Shantiniketan at the end of it, a son on his way home — this he had not known. Not like this. Not with this specificity.
He was still standing in the kitchen doorway when he heard the restroom door open down the corridor. Gautam coming back.
He straightened.
“Ek second,” he said, not quite looking at his son as he moved past him. His voice came out level. He had spent a lifetime making his voice come out level. “Main abhi aata hoon.”
He closed the restroom door behind him.
The tap. He turned it on — cold — and stood there with both hands under the water. The sound of it filled the small room. He didn’t look at the mirror above the basin.
He stood there for a moment and let himself — briefly, silently — come apart. Just slightly. Just enough. The way a man cries who has spent years not crying — without sound, without surrender, just his eyes and the cold water running over his wrists and the wall in front of him blurring slightly and then steadying.
He turned the tap off.
He dried his hands on the towel on the rail. Stood for a moment with the towel in his hands.
Then he hung it back. Precisely where it had been.
He looked at the door.
On the other side of it — his son. Who had been on his way home six and a half years ago and had ended up here instead. Who had eaten his mother’s dhokla today and asked the question he had been carrying for years. Who was waiting, alone, in that sitting room.
Mihir put his hand on the door handle.
Opened it.
-----
Writer’s Note:
This chapter took a long time to write. Some chapters find themselves quickly — the scenes arrive almost fully formed and the work is just transcription. This one didn’t. This one had to be earned.
If you’ve been reading since Chapter 1, you know that Tulsi doesn’t break easily. She doesn’t show you her broken places. She manages. Woh sambhaalti hai. She says main kar loongi and means it and then does it — alone, quietly, without asking anyone to witness.
This chapter she didn’t manage. Not completely. Not entirely alone.
I’ll leave it there.
As always — if any part of this stayed with you, please say so. A line, a word, anything. Writers need to know when something landed. And this one — this chapter, this phone call, this *please* — I need to know if it reached you the way I meant it to.
Thank you for still being here at Chapter 27. It means more than I know how to say.
— ElitePerfumer
Edited by ElitePerfumer - 37 minutes ago
of this chapter for me.
O Humnava Tum Dena Saath Mera
Asian Shows
19